HomeMy WebLinkAbout12/06/16 Minutes - Regular MeetingCITY OF DIAMOND BAR
CITY COUNCIL STUDY SESSION
DECEMBER 6, 2016
STUDY SESSION: M/Lyons called the Study Session to order at
6:00 p.m. in Room CC -8 of the South Coast Air Quality Management
District/Government Center, 21865 Copley Drive, Diamond Bar, CA 91765.
Present: Council Members Carol Herrera, Ruth Low, Steve Tye, Mayor
Pro Tem, Jimmy Lin and Mayor Nancy Lyons.
Staff Present: James DeStefano, City Manager; David DeBerry, City
Attorney; Ryan Mclean, Assistant City Manager; David Liu, Public Works
Director; Greg Gubman, Community Development Director; Anthony Santos,
Assistant to the City Manager; Amy Haug, Human Resources/Risk Manager;
Cecelia Arellano, Public Information Coordinator, and Tommye Cribbins, City
Clerk.
Also Present: LASD Capt. AI Reyes and Lt. Phillip Marquez.
► PROPOSAL TO AUTHORIZE A $10,000 REWARD FOR INFORMATION
LEADING TO THE ARREST AND CONVICTION RE: DEATH OF
RESIDENTS CHENG LONG WANG AND MEI CHU CHUNG.
CM/DeStefano stated that the 5:30 p.m. start time of the Study Session
was incorrectly published on the City's website and in consultation with the
City Attorney and staff's beliefs, it was felt that the best thing to do was to
move the Study Session to 6:00 p.m.
CM/DeStefano explained that the reason Captain Reyes and Lieutenant
Marquez have joined tonight's meeting is that the Sheriffs Department has
been aggressively going after those responsible for the two mid-October
homicides. Those in Homicide have asked for the public's assistance via
the City Council considering a Reward for Information that would lead to
the arrest and conviction of those responsible. On a couple of occasions
Council has done this before and in short, staff concurs with the Sheriff's
Department with asking the Council if it has any interest in offering a
$10,000 reward for the arrest and conviction. The term of the reward
would be for one year and if, for some reason, no conclusion could be
generated the Council would always have the option to extend the time -
period. If the Council has an interest in doing so, this matter would be
formalized by Resolution at the City Council's meeting on the 20th, but
between now and the 20th, staff would be able to work with the Sheriff's
Department as they gear up with their publicity.
C/Low asked how material the information would have to be in order for
someone to obtain the reward money.
Captain Reyes said his understanding was that it would have to lead to the
arrest and conviction.
DECEMBER 6, 2016 PAGE 2 CC STUDY SESSION
C/Low asked who decides that.
Captain Reyes said it would be decided by the City
CM/DeStefano said the information referenced in his memorandum were
open cases and this issue has not come to a conclusion. Like the existing
Report for Reward Program, it would be a combination of the Sheriff's
Department and City staff making a recommendation to the Council as to
the amount of the award; however, since it has not been done before it
would be new territory.
CA/DeBerry said that the Council would want to have language in the
Resolution that said something to the effect "at the discretion of the City
Council". So going to the materiality question from C/Low, someone who
perhaps gave a smidgeon of evidence that led to evidence and to the
arrest, the City Council would have the discretion as advised by staff and
the Sheriff as to whether or not it was material enough to specify for the
award.
C/Low asked if the reward was severable between multiple informants.
CA/DeBerry said that echoing what CM/DeStefano said, it would depend
on how the resolution was set up. If there is a $10,000 reward and there
are several people that are eligible, it would be divided based upon the City
Council's discretion as to whose evidence was most material or it could be
given to one person.
M/Lyons asked if the person has to be convicted, it could take a long time
and in that case, is this reward offer really much of incentive?
Captain Reyes explained that Homicide is asking so that they can hopefully
draw out people to provide information. If there is somebody out there that
may be a material witness or can possibly provide the department with
information as to who "this person or persons" is who may have committed
the crime. The Board of Supervisors is putting forth such a request for a
$20,000 reward on this case.
MPT/Lin said he thought that because of the process it may take a long
time for it to materialize.
Captain Reyes said he did not know the timeframe.
MPT/Lin said that residents who are interested in this case told him that
getting reward money from the County would take a long time.
DECEMBER 6, 2016
PAGE 3 CC STUDY SESSION
M/Lyons said she wondered if a promise of money down the road was
sufficient to motivate somebody to tell homicide what would be helpful to
solve the case.
Captain Reyes said it would be up to the person or persons who might
have that kind of information. It is homicide's position that it would be
helpful to stimulate information if that information is out there and if
anybody has information that would prompt them to proceed with the
investigation.
M/Lyons said if it doesn't work the City would not have to pay them.
Captain Reyes said that M/Lyons was correct.
C/Low asked if anyone had spoken with the family of the victims and
whether they said anything.
Captain Reyes said he is not aware that anybody has spoken to the family
of the victims regarding the offer of a reward.
C/Low asked if the family lives in Diamond Bar, or whether just the victims
lived in Diamond Bar?
Captain Reyes said the information he has indicates it is only the victims
that resided in Diamond Bar. He is not aware of any other family members
living in the City or in the area.
C/Low asked how long the victims lived in Diamond Bar.
M/Lyons said she believed it was 15-16 years.
CM/DeStefano said it could be longer but it was at least a good 15 plus
years.
MPT/Lin said he was contacted by residents and a newspaper reporter
who told them that the Sheriffs Department tried to have the County put in
some reward money but they were informed it may take a long time for it to
happen. Regardless of what the County does, this occurred in the City of
Diamond Bar and the Council should initiate some action here. In terms of
the reward, he remembers a couple of years ago when there was a
gunfight at Big Bear Lake and a $200,000 reward was offered. Multiple
people came out to claim that they were the one who gave the tip and he
believes the County of San Bernardino split the reward money to different
people.
Captain Reyes said that in that case, the suspect was known. It was the
Christopher Domer case.
DECEMBER 6, 2016 PAGE 4 CC STUDY SESSION
CM/DeStefano said that it was complicated because he was never arrested
or convicted because he died during the gunfight at the end.
CM/DeStefano said that the issue before the City Council tonight is one of
simply whether or not the Council would like staff to move forward and
bring this back to the Council on the 20th for formal decision. In terms of
the details (payouts, etc.)
that can be worked out over time. Staff wants to know whether the Council
has an interest so staff can get the formal answers.
C/Tye said it is for arrest and conviction.
CM/DeStefano said that is what staff's recommendation is which is typically
the way it is set up; however, it is Council's choice.
C/Herrera asked if Captain Reyes agreed with arrest and conviction or did
he think that conviction might be more difficult and not lead to any tips.
Captain Reyes said that homicide recommended arrest and conviction.
CA/DeBerry said that if conviction is not included the City is giving money
to somebody who has given information that did not result in the suspect
being convicted and you do not want to invite "false" information just to get
the reward.
M/Lyons asked for Council's conclusion and Council unanimously agreed
to move forward with the request.
► STATEWIDE ELECTION LEGISLATIVE UPDATE — SB 415 & 450.
CM/DeStefano stated that this item has to do with mandatory changes to
the City's election schedule moving away from odd numbered year
elections to even numbered year elections. Staff is introducing this topic to
the City Council tonight and there will be decisions the Council will make
over the next few months (not this evening) as the November 2017 election
approaches.
Assistant to the City Manager Santos reported that there are two pieces of
legislation this presentation covers: 1) SB 415 and 2) SB 450. The
Council has elections that have been held in odd numbered years since
incorporation. Statewide elections are held in even number years. There
has been discussion at the state level about consolidating elections to even
numbered years as a mechanism to increase voter turnout.
SB415 requires cities that have a decrease in voter turnout greater than 25
percent relative to their municipal election versus the turnout during
DECEMBER 6, 2016 PAGE 5 CC STUDY SESSION
statewide elections to institute a change or have a plan by January 1, 2018
that requires those elections to be in even numbered years by November 8,
2022. Average voter registration was about 30,517 in the last four June
and November elections; ballots cast were about 15,194 with a voting
percentage of 49.79 percent. For the statewide primary election (June) the
voter registration was 30,153 and ballots cast were 7,781 for a percentage
of 25.8 percent. The statewide total average of the four indicates there
were about 30,335 registered voters with an average of 11,487 actual
ballots with a voting percentage of about 37.87 percent. For the City there
were 30,658 registered voters and ballots cast were 5,101 for an average
voting percentage of 16.64 percent. All factors considered, the average is
56.06 percent discrepancy between the voting percentages of the
statewide even numbered year elections and the citywide odd numbered
year elections, well above the 25 percentage threshold. Because Diamond
Bar is above that threshold (difference), the City must change its voting
from odd to even -numbered years. Diamond Bar has to have a plan in
place by January 1, 2018 to evaluate options on when the City decides to
change its election cycle. The second target date is the November 8, 2022
where the City elections must begin the even numbered year cycle
elections. The City cannot change the term of office for existing Council
Members. Council Members are elected for four-year terms and Council
Members must sit for the remainder of their four-year terms. The
Government Code allows cities to extend or reduce future terms by 12
months which means the Council can institute a five-year term or a three
year -term, not a two and one-half year or five and one-half year term.
Understanding the deadline for the plan and the target date for
commencing the even year cycles led to the following options:
Option 1 — Instituting three year terms beginning in the 2017 year election
so that the preceding even year election will occur in 2020. Thereafter, it
will be a four-year term. For the 2019 election it would be a three-year
term for an even numbered election beginning in 2022 which would then
become a four-year term and the next election would be 2026.
Option 2 — Instituting a five-year term beginning in 2017 and instituting an
even -numbered election in 2022 and again in 2026. The same would apply
to the election of 2019, a five-year term for the 2024 election which would
again institute a four-year term.
Option 3a — No change in 2017 which could then be a four-year term and
2019 would institute a three-year Council term and in 2021 another three-
year term to commence the even numbered cycle in 2024 and 2026.
Option 3b — Institute five-year terms and do nothing in 2017, institute a five
year term in 2019 and subsequently in 2021 which would then trigger the
even numbered term beginning in 2018 and 2026.
DECEMBER 6, 2016 PAGE 6 CC STUDY SESSION
These are informational options. Again, there are two deadlines — 1)
Having a plan in place by January 1, 2018 and 2) initiation of Option 1 or 2
prior to calling the election in 2017. If the Council wished to wait, Option
3a and 3b would mean no immediate action for this year (change the 2019
and 2021 election). In either case, the City Council would have to institute
a plan by January 1, 2018.
If the City Council were to choose to go to a five-year extension it could
choose whether it wanted to have the elections in June for the statewide
even numbered cycle or November because the Council could extend up to
12 months.
CM/DeStefano asked if the Council had questions at this point or wished to
assign staff homework to research and provide information to the Council
at a later date.
C/Herrera asked if a three-year term versus a five-year term saves the City
money.
CM/DeStefano said it looks like Option 3a would be the most expensive
because the City would be running back to back elections with each being
probably $175,000 to $200,000 by that time.
Asst.toCM/Santos said that if the term was shortened it would affect the
budget by 50 percent additional for one year depending on the County's
cost. It is to the City's advantage to institute a plan sooner rather than later
to make sure it can be consolidated with the County because they have
limited capacity which in theory, will decrease the pro -rata share.
However, it is unknown what the implementation will be like from the
County's perspective but consolidation is less expensive than a free-
standing election.
CM/DeStefano said that while there is uncertainty with respect to what the
County will do it is still better than the City having to gear up to hold
separate elections.
MPT/Lin asked what the absolute deadline would be for Council to make its
decision if Council decided to have an election in November 2017.
CM/DeStefano responded by May 2017.
MPT/Lin said he believed a five-year term was too long for a municipal
government. Three years is fine but five years is too long.
C/Tye felt that from a public standpoint, he believes it is better for the
community to go for the shorter term. It is better for Council Members to go
longer because of the aggravation and cost, but it is better for the
DECEMBER 6, 2016 PAGE 7 CC STUDY SESSION
community to go shorter term and then the community knows the Council is
doing -what is best because of this State law. The City has no choice; the
numbers speak for themselves.
MPT/Low said she did not necessarily believe it was beneficial to the public
that shorter is better.
Tye said he did not mean it was better. He was talking about public
perception.
MT/Low said that on the other hand, maybe people are so tired of seeing
the signs they say "thank God" we can put that off for another year.
M/Lyons suggested the City Council consider this item and have a further
discussion about it in January.
CM/DeStefano said he expected other cities and colleagues will begin to
discuss this more and more because everyone has to make these
decisions.
MPT/Low asked how the City could get the County to start agreeing to let
Diamond Bar put ballot statements online as opposed to printing them
which would likely be a savings for anybody who wants to run.
C/Tye and M/Lyons agreed it would be a good idea
Public Comments: None.
ADJOURNMENT: With no further business to come before the City
Council, M/Lyons recessed the Study Session at 6:28 p.m. to% the Regular
Meeting.
Tommye Cribbins, City Clerk
The foregoing minutes are hereby approved this 20th day of December
2017.
Jim ayor
MINUTES OF THE CITY COUNCIL
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY OF DIAMOND BAR
DECEMBER 6, 2016
STUDY SESSION:
6:00 p.m., Room CC -8
► Proposal to authorize a $10,000 Reward for Information leading to the
Arrest and Conviction Re: Death of Residents Cheng Long Wang and Mei
Chu Chung — Discussion and Action
► Statewide Election Legislative Update — SB 415 & 450 — Discussion and
Action
Public Comments: None.
Recessed: 6:28 p.m.
CALL TO ORDER: Mayor Lyons called the Regular City Council meeting
to order at 6:34 p.m. in the South Coast Air Quality Management District/Government
Center Auditorium, 21865 Copley Drive, Diamond Bar, CA.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: Mayor Lyons
INVOCATION: Luke Pamplin, Director of Young Adult Ministry,
Evangelical Free Church, gave the invocation
ROLL CALL: Council Members Herrera, Low, Tye, Mayor Pro Tem
Lin and Mayor Lyons.
Staff Present: James DeStefano, City Manager; David DeBerry, City
Attorney; Ryan McLean, Assistant City Manager; David Liu, Public Works Director; Greg
Gubman, Community Development Director; Anthony Santos, Assistant to the City
Manager; Amy Haug, Human Resources/Risk Manager; Cecelia Arellano, Public
Information Coordinator; Ehren Magante, Systems Administrator; and Tommye
Cribbins, City Clerk.
Mayor Lyons announced that no reportable action was taken during the Study Session.
APPROVAL OF AGENDA: As Presented.
REORGANIZATION OF CITY COUNCIL:
1.1 Selection of Mayor
C/Low nominated MPT/Lin to serve as Mayor. C/Tye seconded the nomination.
C/Herrera moved nominations be closed.
DECEMBER 6, 2016 PAGE 2 CITY COUNCIL
C/Lin was unanimously elected to serve as Mayor of the City of Diamond Bar by
the following Roll Call vote:
C/Herrera
Yes
C/Low
Yes
C/Tye
Yes
C/Lin
Yes
C/Lyons
Yes
1.2 Selection of Mayor Pro Tem
C/Lyons nominated C/Low to serve as Mayor Pro Tem. C/Tye seconded the
nominations. C/Herrera moved nominations be closed.
C/Low was unanimously elected to serve as Mayor Pro Tem of the City of
Diamond Bar by the following Roll Call vote:
C/Herrera
Yes
C/Low
Yes
C/Tye
Yes
C/Lyons
Yes
M/Lin
Yes
1.3 Presentation to Outgoing Mayor Nancy A. Lyons
M/Lin and City Council Members presented Outgoing Mayor Lyons with a
commemorative gavel.
C/Lyons said that it had been a great honor to serve as the City's Mayor and that
she has enjoyed working with the terrific staff and Council.
C/Tye presented a commemorative Bobble Head to outgoing Mayor Lyons
RECESS/RECEPTION: M/Lin recessed the City Council Meeting at 6:42 p.m.
RECONVENE: M/Lin reconvened the City Council Meeting at 7:06 p.m.
1. SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS, CERTIFICATES, PROCLAMATIONS: None.
DECEMBER 6, 2016 PAGE 3 CITY COUNCIL
2. CITY MANAGER REPORTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
CM/DeStefano stated that it was his pleasure to join the Engineering/Public Works
staff at the American Public Works Association luncheon during which the City
received an award from the Southern California Chapter of the American Public
Works Association for the Grand Avenue Beautification Project. Diamond Bar
was chosen to receive this 2016 Project of the Year because of the details, effort
and excellence that was put forth in that project. In addition to improving Grand
Avenue and Diamond Bar Boulevard the City has set forth the framework and
palate to install the same types of public improvements/streetscape amenities
throughout the City with projects and resource availability. To that end, the City
recently completed the intersection of Brea Canyon Road at Diamond Bar
Boulevard. Diamond Bar was represented by 'statements from the APWA
indicating that the City leaders wanted a bold statement to initialize the citywide
branding of this public right-of-way and talked about the steel cut panels, timber
rails, details in the crosswalks, sidewalks and the landscape design overall as the
City's attempt to hearken back to the "ranchland" history of the City. In addition to
staff members, individuals from the design firm of David Volz Design who assisted
in crafting the streetscape elements for the Grand Avenue project were present.
Congratulations to David Volz and to staff who implemented the project and
managed its construction.
3. PUBLIC COMMENTS:
Pui Ching Ho, Diamond Bar Library spoke about upcoming December library
events beginning with the Holiday Music Concert on Saturday, December 10 at
3:00 p.m. All ages are welcome and the program is sponsored by the Diamond
Bar Friends of the Library. Santa will be at the library on Saturday, December 17
at 10:30 a.m. and will read a story and offer children an opportunity to tell him
what they want for Christmas. Parents will be able to take pictures of their
children with Santa. Those who are searching for the perfect gift for their family
and friends are encouraged to stop by the Friends of the Library bookstore,
Basically Books, one located inside the library and the other in the shopping
center at 23447 Golden Springs Drive (at Diamond Bar Boulevard). People who
purchase books from Basically Books are helping to support the library. Please
check the library website at http:/Icolapublib.org/libs/diamondbar/index.php for
additional programs and events.
Grace Lim Hayes, Hampton Court Homeowners Association, expressed her
gratitude to the City for the improvements to Washington Street which has
dramatically improved residents' sense of security. Another concern is the lack
of parking on Washington Street and the HOA would like the City to consider
marking parking spaces with small notches to make it a more efficient use of
space. Two communities and more than 300 families compete for the space,
especially during the holidays. Parents are very concerned for their young adults
who struggle to find parking close to their homes at night.
DECEMBER 6, 2016 PAGE 4 CITY COUNCIL
4. RESPONSE TO PUBLIC COMMENTS:
CM/DeStefano responded to Ms. Hayes that the City has permitted parking on
public streets in certain locations. There is an example of the notched parking
spaces near Diamond Bar High School where spaces were identified on
Pathfinder Road. Staff has heard similar requests for identified parking spaces
on Washington Street in the past, specifically about perpendicular parking or
diagonal parking. In this case, it is a style staff is familiar with and can
specifically look in that direction to possibly move forward with an action plan
without too much trouble. In speaking briefly with PWD/Liu it sounds like
something the City can do.
5. SCHEDULE OF FUTURE EVENTS:
5.1 Holiday Diamond Ride — November 25, 2016 through January 1, 2017 —
Free shuttle service to and from Diamond Bar Shopping Center for ages
18 and older — Rides can be booked by calling 800-578-6555.
5.2 Traffic and Transportation Commission Meeting — December 8, 2016 —
7:00 p.m., Windmill Community Room, 21810 Copley Drive (Canceled)
5.3 Planning Commission Meeting — December 13, 2016 — 7:00 p.m.,
AQMD/Government Center Auditorium, 21865 Copley Drive (canceled).
5.4 City Council Meeting — December 20, 2016 — 6:30 p.m.,
AQMD/Government Center Auditorium, 21865 Copley Drive
6. CONSENT CALENDAR: C/Lyons moved, C/Tye seconded, to approve
the Consent Calendar as presented with C/Lyons pulling Item 6.10 for separate
consideration. Motion carried by the following Roll Call vote:
AYES:
COUNCIL MEMBERS:
Herrera, Lyons, Tye, VC/Low, M/Lin
NOES:
COUNCIL MEMBERS:
None
ABSENT:
COUNCIL MEMBERS:
None
6.1 WAIVE READING IN FULL OF ALL ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS
AND ADOPT THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
6.2 APPROVED CITY COUNCIL MINUTES — Regular Meeting of November
15, 2016.
6.3 RECEIVED AND FILED PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION
MINUTES — Regular Meeting of October 27, 2016.
DECEMBER 6, 2016 PAGE 5 CITY COUNCIL
6.4 RECEIVED AND FILED TRAFFIC AND TRANSPORTATION
COMMISSION MINUTES:
6.4.1 Regular Meeting of July 14, 2016
6.4.2 Regular Meeting of September 8, 2016.
6.5 RECEIVED AND FILED PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES — Regular
Meeting of October 11, 2016.
6.6 RATIFIED CHECK REGISTER — Dated November 10, 2016 through
November 30, 2016 totaling $2,597,356.20.
6.7 APPROVED TREASURER'S STATEMENT — for Month of October 2016.
6.8 APPROVED ADJOURNING THE DECEMBER 20, 2016 CITY COUNCIL
MEETING TO JANUARY 17, 2017.
6.9 ADOPTED RESOLUTION NO. 2016-40: AMENDING 2016-17 FISCAL
YEAR BUDGET IN THE PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT, ELIMINATING
THE PARK MAINTENANCE INSPECTOR CLASSIFICATION, AND
ESTABLISHING THE FACILITIES AND ASSETS MAINTENANCE
TECHNICIAN AND MAINTENANCE WORKER JOB CLASSIFICATIONS
AND SALARY GRADES EFFECTIVE DECEMBER 10, 2016; AND,
AMENDING RESOLUTION NO. 2016-20.
6.11 APPROVED AUTHORIZATION BY THE CITY COUNCIL FOR
APPROVAL OF EXPENDITURES OF UP TO $60,000 PAYABLE TO
ALLIANT INSURANCE SERVICES FOR THE PURCHASE OF TENANT
USER LIABILITY INSURANCE AND SPECIAL EVENT INSURANCE FOR
FISCAL YEAR 2016-17.
MATTERS WITHDRAWN FROM CONSENT CALENDAR:
6.10 APPROPRIATE $8,507 FROM THE GENERAL FUND RESERVES AND
APPROVE AMENDMENT NO. 8 TO THE CONTRACT WITH
BRIGHTVIEW LANDSCAPE SERVICES, INC. FOR LANDSCAPE
MAINTENANCE AT DIAMOND CANYON PARK FOR THE DECEMBER
3, 2016 THROUGH JUNE 30, 2017 PERIOD IN AN AMOUNT OF
$20,377, FOR A TOTAL CONTRACT AMOUNT OF $428,493 FOR
FISCAL YEAR 2016-17.
C/Lyons asked for clarification on this item. She is concerned about this
because the park is very complex with five different gardens, park
amenities and slopes and wanted to know why staff believes Brightview
would be able to provide these services.
DECEMBER 6, 2016 PAGE 6 CITY COUNCIL
CM/DeStefano stated that through the Council's budget process adopted
in June 2016 all park maintenance has been moved to Engineering and
Public Works. PWD/Liu has been examining all aspects of that new
responsibility and implementing a variety of great changes. Part of the
new responsibility for his shop includes this park for which PWD/Liu will
provide more detail as to why Brightview and what will be done over the
next few months with this particular project. In addition, Council may
recall that the City is going through a process to bid out all of the City's
landscape maintenance services and staff will be coming back to the City
Council in March/April of 2017 for consideration regarding those
maintenance contracts.
PWD/Liu said that this contract runs through June 30, 2017. Brightview is
a full service company and has all of the specialty professionalism in
terms of maintaining the Diamond Bar service levels. As a contract
service city, Diamond Bar relies on a team of consultants using staff
management oversight. With respect to this park, there have been many
closely coordinated meetings between the maintenance contractor and
staff. In addition, three or four months ago staff began coordinating
meetings with the developer's contractor. Lennar hired a contractor to
build the park and staff and Lennar began coordinating those efforts from
the beginning. PWD/Liu said he learned yesterday that within the. next
couple of weeks the contractor who built the new park will be meeting with
Brightview to continue coordinating and maintaining the service level at
the highest possible standards. Staff could have gone out to other
contractors but in accordance with the plan moving forward, RFP's will be
released soon after the new year with the goal of obtaining additional
proposals from other competent contractors who can maintain all of the
parks and facilities at the highest standard. Currently, there are 12 parks
being maintained by Brightview and because of their record working to
maintain the parks as expected, it makes sense to keep the maintenance
with Brightview. There were two other proposals from current providers,
both of which came in higher than Brightview and it did not make sense to
staff to pay $600 or $900 more per month for the same level of service
established with Brightview.
C/Lyons reiterated that her primary concern was about the uniqueness of
the new park and Brightview's ability to provide the level of service the
City expects. Obviously, staff has looked at this and believes that
Brightview has the experience to maintain the different types of gardens
and grass, etc.
PWD/Liu responded "absolutely".
DECEMBER 6, 2016 PAGE 7 CITY COUNCIL
MPT/Low said that in the staff report under financial impact, the last
sentence reads "is requesting an additional appropriation of $8,507 from
developer paid fees to the City from Lennar Homes" and the summary
says this amount is coming from the General Fund Reserves. She asked
if these were the same funds.
PWD/Liu said that as Council knows, various funding sources that go into
the General Fund comes from a variety of different sources including
development projects. In this case, the City received "park fees" from the
developer and similar to traffic mitigation fees and franchise fees that are
collected from this and other developers, etc. go into the General Fund. In
this case, the money is coming out of the General Fund and the original
funding source was the park fees that were collected from the developer.
C/Lyons moved, MPT/Low seconded, to approve Item 6.10. Motion
carried by the following Roll Call vote:
AYES: COUNCIL MEMBERS
NOES: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
ABSENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
7. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING: None.
8. COUNCIL CONSIDERATION: None.
Herrera, Lyons, Tye, VC/Low,
M/Lin
None
None
RECESS: M/Lin recessed the City Council meeting to the annual Public Financing
Authority meeting at 7:23 p.m.
RECONVENE: M/Lin reconvened the City Council meeting at 7:33 p.m.
9. COUNCIL SUBCOMMITTEE REPORTS AND MEETING ATTENDANCE
REPORTS/COUNCIL MEMBER COMMENTS:
C/Lyons reported that along with MPT/Low, she was able to recognize the
Diamond Bar Volunteer Patrol last Thursday evening. She enjoyed meeting the
volunteers and thanked them for their service to the City. The volunteers provide
a very important component of public safety for Diamond Bar. With her
colleagues she participated in the Grand Opening and Ribbon Cutting for the
new Diamond Canyon Park. For those who have not visited the park, there are
places to walk and a couple of playgrounds. She congratulated Diamond Ranch
High School for being recognized as one of the most beautiful high schools in
California. She attended the San Gabriel Valley Regional Chamber of
Commerce Business Awards Dinner with SA/Lopez during which they recognized
local business South Coast Cabinet as the "Green 2016 Business of the Year".
She thanked staff and her colleagues for making her year as Mayor so enjoyable.
DECEMBER 6, 2016 . PAGE 8 CITY COUNCIL
C/Herrera attended the Grand Opening of Diamond Canyon Park which is a very
attractive park. Many attended the event which was very nice and she thanked
staff for their efforts to make the event enjoyable for everyone. She
congratulated new Mayor Jimmy Lin and to new Mayor Pro Tem Ruth Low. She
thanked outgoing Mayor Nancy Lyons who worked very hard during her tenure
attending many events, visiting every restaurant in the City during Restaurant
Week. She did a lot to promote business in the City during the past year. 2017
will be a great year for Diamond Bar.
C/Tye thanked outgoing Mayor Lyons for doing a great job for the City during her
tenure. He appreciated her initiative in getting Restaurant Week going. Years
from now when our kids and grandkids are here during Restaurant Week
everyone will be able to say that happened on her watch. Good job!
Congratulations to newly elected M/Lin and MPT/Low. While he was unable to
attend the Grand Opening, it was wonderful to see the new Diamond Canyon
Park being used. Diamond Bar continues to get the most out of what it has
available. This 3 -acre park is a good use of the space. It turned out very, very
nice and he knows folks in the area will make good use of the new park.
MPT/Low commented that the Volunteer Patrol Holiday Appreciation Dinner was
a very nice event. Several volunteers are present this evening and all have been
so faithful in executing their duties. She thanked them and said she appreciated
them for all they do to add to the quality of life in Diamond Bar. She concurred
with her colleagues that the new Diamond Canyon Park is wonderful, beautiful,
and peaceful, and it gives one a new perspective on being away from the traffic
on Diamond Bar Boulevard. The creation of that park was a great job. On
Monday she attended the swearing-in ceremonies of District Supervisor Janice
Hahn who succeeds Supervisor Don Knabe. She invited Supervisor Hahn to visit
Diamond Bar to see all of the good things happening in the City. A note to
families, the Holidays are ahead and please be vigilant about your safety. Lock
your doors, keep your gifts out of sight and make sure you do not leave
packages on the porch and be safe when driving. She thanked outgoing Mayor
Lyons for her leadership and service to the community during the past year — you
did a fantastic job and MPT/Low appreciates her example and mentorship. She
thanked her colleagues for their friendship, confidence, help and encouragement.
It has been a pleasure to serve on the City Council. She congratulated M/Lin
and said she looked forward to a great year.
M/Lin congratulated PWD/Liu for the beautification award. He expressed his
gratitude to his four colleagues for trusting him to lead the City during 2017 which
is a very big responsibility for anyone to assume. Especially during the past few
years Diamond Bar has been fortunate to have a small elite group of mayors
including Carol Herrera, Steve Tye and Nancy Lyons, all of whom have done a
great job in that capacity. He is committed to carrying forward the City's agenda
and will attempt to do, at the very least, as good a job as his predecessors. In
DECEMBER 6, 2016 PAGE 9 CITY COUNCIL
the coming year issues that will require continuous attention will include
resolution of the SR57/60 traffic improvements. Economic Development will
continue to be his and the entire Council's priority and there will be a continued
effort to redevelop land within the City limits to the best use possible. Public
Safety is always an important concern in Diamond Bar. Potential repercussions
from the recent passage of Prop 57 and Prop 64 legalizing Marijuana are yet to
be seen and the City is and will be ready to combat negative impacts. Diamond
Bar cannot pride itself to be a great City unless it can provide a safe community
for its residents. It is also very fortunate that Diamond Bar is blessed to have a
solid and cohesive City Council so it can continue to get things done instead of
playing politics without accomplishing what it is elected to do — in his case, what
he was "appointed" to do. He is certain that as a group the Council will continue
to march ahead with the same spirit and empowerment of the people. He
thanked everyone for their vote of trust.
ADJOURNMENT: With no further business to conduct, M/Lin adjourned the Regular
City Council Meeting at 7:42 p.m. to January 17, 2017.
Tommye bribbins, City Clerk
The foregoing minutes are hereby approved this 20th day of nenPmhPr 12017.
Jimmy i , Mayor