HomeMy WebLinkAbout09/12/2013 - MINUTES - Regular MeetingCITY OF DIAMOND BAR
MINUTES OF THE TRAFFIC AND TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION MEETING
SEPTEMBER 12, 2013
W-191111fi• •-�
Chairman Mok called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. in the Diamond Bar City Hall Windmill
Community Room, 21810 Copley Drive, Diamond Bar, California 91765.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: Vice Chair Mahlke led the Pledge of Allegiance.
ROLL CALL: Commissioners Ted Carrera, Liana Pincher, Peter
Pirritano, Vice Chair Jen "Fred" Mahlke, Chairman
Kenneth Mok
Also Present: David Liu, Public Works Director; Sterling Mosley,
Assistant Engineer; Christian Malpica, Associate
Engineer (Traffic), * and Marcy Hilario,
Administrative Coordinator.
INTRODUCTION — Sterling Mosley, Assistant Engineer/Public Works Department
PWD/Liu'iniroduced a staff member participating
ng in the meeting. Assistant Engineer/Sterling
Mosley has been with the Public Works Department since May, 2013; however, Mr. Mosley
had assisted the department previous to his employment as a Contract Engineer.
All welcomed Assistant Engineer/Mosley.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
A. Minutes of the August 8, 2013
013 Requl.ar Meeting
C/Carrera moved, C/Pirritano seconded, to approve the Minutes of the August
8, 2013 meeting as presented. Motion carried by the following Roll Call vote:
AYES: COMMISSIONERS
NOES:
COMMISSIONERS:
ABSTAIN:
COMMISSIONERS:
ABSENT:
COMMISSIONERS:
Carrera, Pincher, Pirritano,
Chair/Mok
None
VC/Mahlke
None
SEPTEMBER 12, 2013 PAGE 2 T&T COMMISSION
None Offered.
A. Receive and File Traffic Enforcement Updates for:
1. Citations: June, July and August 2013
2. Collisions: June, July and August 2013
3. Street Sweeping: June, July and August 2013
VC/Mahlke stated she was surprised at how significantly lower the stats were.
PWD/Liu responded that the street sweeping citation information is reflective
of street construction activities thru-out the City, such as the slurry seal road
maintenance project and major Edison infrastructure upgrades in the
neighborhoods. During those instances, we coordinate with the CSO and ask
that citations not be issued. .
C/Carrera asked if street sweeping continues even if citations are not issued.
PWD/Liu responded as long as the street sweeper can gain access, the
sweeper will follow its regular course. Construction debris pickup is the
responsibility of the contractor.
C/Pincher stated that the gardeners that service the condominium complex in
her neighborhood are very diligent and do an excellent job of cleaning up;
therefore, there does not appear to be any conflicts between trash pickup and
street sweeping.
VC/MahIke moved, C/Pincher seconded, to receive and file the Traffic
Enforcement Update reports for June, July and August 2013. Motion carried
by the following Roll Call vote:
AYES: COMMISSIONERS
NOES: COMMISSIONERS:
ABSENT: COMMISSIONERS:
IV. OLD BUSINESS:
Carrera, Pincher, Pirritano,
VC/MahIke, Chair/Mok
None
None
A. Power Point Presentation of Traffic Management Center (TMC) and Traffic
Management System (TMS) Update
PWD/Liu stated that the Traffic Management System has existed since 2008.
The Traffic Management Center was built into the new City Hall in January
2012.
SEPTEMBER 12, 2013 PAGE 3 T&T COMMISSION
The purpose of the Traffic Management System is to provide remote
communication between traffic signals.at major arterials and the City's Traffic
Management System (TMS). This system is operated by managing the TMS,
upgrading the system and managing the demand on the TMS. There are four
major objectives that staff attempts to adhere to: 1) minimize the delays for
residents entering the arterials; 2) maximize traffic flow for the arterials; 3)
maximize safety for pedestrians and motorists that travel through the City and,
4) improve, response times to address signal malfunctions to reduce
maintenance costs.
The TMS allows staff to observe all of the signal operations in real time while
addressing the issues proactively; the system allows staff to review signal
operation history through the diagnostic tools built into the system; make.
changes to the signal timings to accommodate traffic flow based on field
conditions; and, when there are special events or. incidents, the system allows
staff to stay ahead of the -curve.
Housed in the Traffic Management Center is the central computer with
monitors and traffic control software which is the brain that operates the entire
system. In the field are the traffic signal controllers, firmware and cameras
which are all tied back to the TMC through underground
infrastructure/interconnect. All of the components of the system are
interconnected and function as a unit. The system uses closed circuit TV
cameras (CCTV cameras) which have the capability to pan, tilt, and zoom on a
360 degree basis. These are the traffic "eyes" of the system. The system also
uses video detection cameras which are fixed location cameras used for
detection purposes only. There are 16 locations throughout the City- which
include critical intersections that have large traffic volumes or have close
proximity to schools. PWD/Liu explained that 15 years ago when the system
was first contemplated, copper wire was used. In the last few years,- fiber
optics offers have greatly improved capacity and service. The interconnect
system lies under major arterials throughout the City. The cabinets contain TV
monitors under which sits the controller, two tiers of detection centers, the
battery backup system and switches and relays. Battery backup systems are*,
at a total of 19 locations at this time and more are planned. There are 72
signalized intersections in the City, not all of which will have battery backup
systems.
Chair/Mok asked if the entire cabinet has to be replaced in order to retrofit
additional intersections with battery backup. systems. AE/Malpica, explained
that the cabinets that do not have battery backup systems have their own
power unit and space to allow for replacement with a battery backup unit.
Chair/Mok asked if they were proprietary backup systems. PWD/Liu
responded he did not believe they were which is why they can all fit.
SEPTEMBER 12, 2013
PAGE 4 T&T COMMISSION
The TMC also contains a video board with eight video displays/monitors which
were built when City Hall moved to its present location. The purpose is to
facilitate the viewing of the system map, the images coming from the CCTV
cameras or any of the computer programs available.
Daily operations of the TMC include reviewing the system logs to verify the
signal operations in order to respond to timing complaints and operational
issues. Staff wants to be responsive and feols it is best to do so by making
sure that all data is reviewed on a regular basis and that the mitigation makes
sense. Staff is also able to observe traffic flow through CCTV and the video
detection cameras.
Some of the most recent improvements and accomplishments include an
almost seamless move from AQIVID to the newly constructed TMC at City Hall
and the City's ability to connect to the county -wide information exchange
network (IEN), a critical component. By being part of the IEN, the City is able
to exchange/share data with participating agencies to enable county -wide
responses to major events. To date, only about 14 or 15 cities are on the
system and the county hopes to see more cities participate. From the
beginning, staff has worked with the County and the City has taken a very
proactive approach with respect to how it sees itself within the regional picture.
A few weeks ago,.the City received word from MTA that we would receive a
little over $1.4 million in Fiscal Year 2016-17 of the $1.8 million required to
develop and implement an adaptive traffic control system. This is significant
because no other cities the size of Diamond Bar have this technology.
Diamond Bar is unique because it' deals with regional freeway traffic. An
Adaptive Traffic Control System is simply designed to work on auto pilot and
respond instantaneously to changing conditions. As a result, many more
sensors will be required to be placed in the pavements. This system does not
require specific timing plans. it is a "smart" system that monitors everything
second by. second. Diamond Bar has a Traffic Responsive System that will be
implemented by the end of the month which will, through pre -determined
timing plans, provide a view of the City's three corridors, Grand Avenue,
Golden Springs Drive and Diamond Bar Boulevard. Those three corridors will
be divided into five sections so that within any given section, three specific
timing plans will be developed. For example, when a major incident occurs in
the afternoon that closes the freeway and soil ' Is traffic into Diamond Bar, there
will be a surge of traffic going north on Diamond Bar Boulevard. The system
will have established certain thresholds and when those thresholds are met,
signalized intersections along Diamond Bar Boulevard between Brea Canyon
Road and Grand Avenue will have its timing adjusted that favors northbound
traffic which will be given preferential treatment to get through the City.
Residential neighborhoods will suffer during the surge; however, it will provide
a means to more quickly move traffic out of the City and restore residential
traffic flow.
SEPTEMBER 12, 2013 PAGE 5 T&T COMMISSION
In developing the Traffic Responsive System, Diamond Bar Boulevard will be
broken up into two sections; Golden Springs Drive will be broken up into two
sections and Grand Avenue, will have only one Traffic Responsive System
section to balance the traffic volumes. In September, the Traffic Responsive
Plan will be implemented. When it comes to an Adaptive Traffic Control
System, this system is instantaneous and requires only one timing cycle with
each timing change for the Traffic Responsive Plan and once the thresholds
have been met, it will take two or three timing cycles before the timing plans
are implemented.
Some of the ongoing/current improvements to the Traffic Management System
include installation of 16 CCTV's, equipping 19 intersections with Battery
Backup Systems. During this current fiscal year, 15 more locations will be
added. As part of the CIP for this year, traffic signal upgrades will be
implemented such as upgrading the wiring, cable, conduits, etc. As a result of
the Traffic Signal Operation and Maintenance Plan, upgrades will be looked at
very comprehensively so that staff can determine deficiencies and how to
maintain all of the necessary parts of the system. This will ensure the City's
Traffic Management System continues to provide the City continued
assistance and carry on the lifecycle of the City's assets.
Recently, staff was approached by the L.A. County Public Works Department
about working with CHP and the L.A. County's Sheriff's Department to develop
an incident management protocol between cities and the county. There will be
several years of upgrades that will take place. It will take about three years to
replace all of the copper communication lines for a cost of about $1 million.
In summary, the DBTMS enhances the mobility and improves efficiency by
coordinating management of traffic operations and maintenance efforts.
Public safety is a top priority for the City for which this tool has been
implemented. Staff hopes to demonstrate that we take a very proactive
approach to managing and maintaining the City's traffic. We are timely with
our responses to complaints and incidents and implement ongoing efforts to
minimize delays in the City's congestion. We understand that this is a very
serious undertaking that will continue to preserve a good quality of life for the
community. Regional traffic continues to be a major challenge for Diamond
Bar which requires substantial resources and partnering with all stakeholders.
C/Carrera asked if all copper and fiber communication lines were city -owned
and he wondered if there was any advantage over leasing communication
lines. PWD/Liu replied that a lease option was considered; however, the City
felt that the existing conduits owned by other companies do not present the
best interests of the City. Their priorities are different and their work is very
focused. The City decided it wanted to have 100 percent control over the
system and its destiny.
SEPTEMBER 12, 2013 PAGE 6 T&T COMMISSION
C/Carrera asked how long the Adaptive Traffic Control System would take to
implement once the funding is received. AE/Malpica responded about six to
nine months including field work.
RECESS: Chair/Mok recessed the meeting to the Traffic Management Center at
7:57 p.m.
RECONVENE: Chair/Mok reconvened the meeting at 8:02 p.m. in the Traffic
Management Center (TMC)
AE/Malpica presented information regarding the TMC monitors including
CCTV and detection cameras. There are a total of eight (8) monitopsbn the
video wall. He explained that two (2) monitors illustrate an information
exchange network (IEN) with L.A. County. Data can be viewed and
exchanged; however, there is no ability to interact or control the County's
traffic signals. A monitor continuously displays the Sigalert application to
monitor freeway traffic and possible impacts to City streets with traffic overflow.
AE/Malpica gave a demonstration of the camera mobility at an intersection and
showed the various angles that can be viewed. There is also the ability to view
intersections graphically to address any issues that require programming
attention. This enhances the efficiency in adjusting timing and detection. He
explained that timing plans of traffic signals throughout the City are set
according to the time of day. One of the monitors displays the signal mode at
any given time of day. Another feature of the TMC is the ability to generate
reports with a detailed history of timing, failures, and a split logger. The split
logger can run reports for specific dates and time.
Chair/Mok asked if the system records data. AE/Malpica responded that the
system does not record and there is no plan to implement that feature. While
no video images will be stored, reports will be kept for three (3) years to
address any relevant inquiries.
PWD/Liu shared that with certain traffic signal malfunctions, both he and
AE/Malpica receive email messaging alerts on their mobile phones.
Furthermore, he and AE/Malpica have the ability to access the TMC remotely
to apply adjustments, if required.
The Commissioners were very impressed with the TMC and commended staff
for their diligent efforts.
RECESS: Chair/Mok recessed the TMC tour at 8:21 p.m. back to the Regular
Meeting.
RECONVENE: Chair/Mok reconvened the Regular Meeting at 8:25 p.m.
SEPTEMBER 12, 2013 PAGE 7 T&T COMMISSION
C/Carrera moved, C/Pirritano seconded, to Receive and File the Traffic
Management Center and Traffic Management System Update. Motion carried
by the following Roll Call vote:
AYES: COMMISSIONERS:
NOES: COMMISSIONERS:
ABSENT: COMMISSIONERS:
V. NEW BUSINESS: None
Carrera, Pincher, Pirritano,
VC/Mahlke, Chair/Mok
None
None
VI. STATUS OF PREVIOUS ACTION ITEMS: None
VII. ITEMS FROM COMMISSIONERS:
C/Carrera said he was thoroughly impressed with the TMS and the Center. He did
not understand why other cities and entities would not want to participate because it
seems that a problem in one city can affect other cities if they are not part of the
network.
Chair/Mok asked about the eastbound SR -60 exit at Brea Canyon Road that exits
onto Golden Springs Drive. One day last week, he experienced an unusually long
delay exiting onto Golden Springs Drive. He noticed that the signal stayed red for a
long time. AE/Malpica responded that the issue of the signal not performing as it
should be was brought to staff's attention. Once staff was informed about the
problem, the traffic signal contractor was contacted and they replaced the software to
alleviate the problem.
C/Pirritano shared that he was at Lavender Drive and Grand Avenue and experienced
a delay at the signal which seemed to be stuck on red for Lavender Drive traffic and
remained green for Grand Avenue both north and south. He eventually decided to
make a right turn and then a u -turn to go back down Grand Avenue. AE/Malpica
responded that it might be a detection issue. Last month, one of the existing
detection cameras had to be replaced due to a similar issue. AE/Malpica said he
would look into what happened at about 7:00 a.m. on Tuesday morning during the
time C/Pirritano experienced the problem.
Chair/Mok asked if the cameras were cleaned on a regular basis. PWD/Liu
affirmatively responded. That could contribute to the problem as well. AE/Malpica
added that the contract calls for annual cleaning; however, if he notices that the
cameras are dirty, he will ask the technician to jean them. Spider webs can also
interfere; therefore, staff tries to clean the cameras on an as -needed basis.
SEPTEMBER 12, 2013
FA
10.1
C
I
CCTV Project
PAGE 8 T&T COMMISSION
AE/Malpica reported that the consultant was able to make progress this week
by boosting the channels and increasing the bandwidth from five bits to 15 bits
for images from the CCTV cameras along Diamond Bar Boulevard, south of
Grand Avenue. One of our consultants is currently looking at the cameras on
the north side of the City experiencing lower bandwidth issues as well, which
may have something to do with some unplanned power issues.
Median Project at Grand Avenue and Summitridge Drive/Diamond Bar
Boulevard at Silver Hawk Drive
AE/Malpica stated that bids were opened on August 26th
for both median
projects. The scope of work is to retrofit the existing medians by realignment
to improve the line of sight for both directions. Six bids were received with a
low bid submitted by Tyner Paving Company for both projects. The low bid for
Grand Avenue and Summitridge Drive was $28,285.20 (engineer's estimate
$43,000.00) and a low bid for Diamond Bar Boulevard at Silver Hawk Drive
was $35,659.55 (engineer's estimate $36,200.00). Staff received good
feedback information when the contractor's references and license were
checked; therefore, the recommendation will be taken to City Council next
Tuesday to award the contract.
Traffic Signal Operation and Maintenance Master Plan
AE/Malpica reported that staff reviewed the latest report and provided
comments to the consultant. The plan is scheduled to be completed by the
end of September with implementation of recommendations shortly thereafter.
Diamond Bar Traffic Responsive Plan/System
AE/Malpica indicated that the purpose of this system is to address some of the
surge traffic detouring through City streets in the event of any
incidents/accidents or freeway shutdowns. Staff and consultants conducted a
test last week and were able to witness the system in action. The consultant is
working to fine-tune the system at this time in order to retest the system in
sections next week.
E. ACE Fairway Grade Separation Project
AE/Malpica stated that staff submitted the peer review of the project back to
ACE. The consultant's review asks ACE to look into traffic impacts and
recommended mitigation measures that are foreseen within the City's
jurisdiction. Construction is scheduled to begin by the end of 2014.
SEPTEMBER 12, 2013 PAGE 9 T&T COMMISSION
a
Area 1 B/Zone 7 Roadway Maintenance Project
Assistant Engineer/Mosley reported that manhole adjustments are
approaching conclusion with the contractor continuing on the last
neighborhood south of Grand Avenue in the Quail Summit Drive area. The
contractor will continue with striping next week to complete legends, bike
lanes, pavement markers and a second coat of striping.
G. Southern California Edison Infrastructure Upgrades
Assistant Engineer/Mosley stated that International Line Builders (ILB),
Edison's contractor, continues construction of upgrades in the neighborhoods
surrounding Diamond Point Elementary School along Bower Cascade Place,
Minnequa Drive and Del Sol Lane. ILB has completed trenching work in the
public right-of-way and is now entering the restoration project phase. This
work is scheduled to be completed in late September. Once all of the work is
completed in all neighborhoods including Mountain Laurel Way and Sunset
Crossing Road neighborhoods, the contractor will be responsible for restriping
all legends and crosswalks.
Chair/Mok asked if (item F) the Golden Springs Drive area was on -schedule.
Assistant Engineer/Mosley.responded that the pavement restoration has been
completed along Golders Springs. Drive and currently the second coat of
striping is being completed.
VC/Mahlke asked about the application of striping. Assistant Engineer/Mosley
explained that it takes seven (7) days for the first coat to dry and fully cure
before the contractor can come back to apply the second coat of paint.
C/Pincher asked if the City plans to move forward with tree removal on
Morning Canyon Road where the trees are lifting the road. She shared that it
appears the "speed bumps" have been i removed. PWD/Liu responded that a
temporary fix including removal of the bumps in the road was just completed.
The project is budgeted in this year's CIP; however, with any given project, the
plans and specifications have to be developed, which will take time. Staff feels
it would be best to work on that project next summer versus the balance of the
next few months, primarily due to school traffic and traffic in general. In
addition, staff will need to communicate the intent and scope of work with
residents because the project involves removal of a number of trees.
Assistant Engineer/Mosley reiterated this is a temporary fix; however, he is
currently working on an RFP for design services and construction
management services for that project which involves a long-term fix.
SEPTEMBER 12, 2013 PAGE 10 T&T COMMISSION
IX. SCHEDULE OF FUTURE CITY EVENTS:
As stated in the agenda.
ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business to come before the Traffic and
Transportation Commission, Chair/Mok adjourned the meeting at 8:50 p.m.
' -rd
The foregoing minutes are hereby approved this /0 — ._ day of (b-o&,L 2013.
Respectfully,
Davi Liu, Secretary
Attest:
MAI
irman Kenneth Mok