HomeMy WebLinkAbout_RFP Score Sheets (CM)FACTOR
0.2
0.2
0.25
0.2
0.1
0.05
BY:
CONSULTANT: CASC Engineering & Consulting, Inc.
Staff Qualification
Overall experience with Diamond Bar/public agencies
Organizational structure of the project team
Staff experience & knowledge in providing similar service
Firm Qualifications
Experience with similar projects
Responsiveness/demonstrated understanding of the City's needs
Proximity of consultant to the City
Subconsultants
Approach / Methodology
Work program/plan
Format/Content
Scheduling and reporting procedures
Hours - Level of Effort (Staffing commitment and time allocation)
Project manager/engineer
Inspector (if applicable)
Frequency of meetings with City staff
Ability to meet City's schedule and expectations
Relevant References (Record of performance)
Over 30 years of experience
Chages requested to the agreement
Located in Colton
Expensive
Chris M.
WEIGHT
(1 to 3)
3
3
3
Overall Section Total:
3
3
2
1
Overall Section Total:
3
3
2
Overall Section Total:
2
2
1
Overall Section Total:
3
Overall Section Total:
3
Overall Section Total:
GRAND TOTAL:
DATE:
RATING
(1 to 10)
3
3
3
3
3
1
1
3
3
2
2
2
0
3
3
6/1/2023
WEIGHTED
TOTAL
9
9
9
6
9
9
2
1
4.66666666666667
9
9
4
6.875
4
4
0
3.2
9
3
9
1.5
25.2416666666667
FACTOR
0.2
0.2
0.25
0.2
0.1
0.05
BY:
CONSULTANT: Environmental Compliance Specialist
Staff Qualification
Overall experience with Diamond Bar/public agencies
Organizational structure of the project team
Staff experience & knowledge in providing similar service
Firm Qualifications
Experience with similar projects
Responsiveness/demonstrated understanding of the City's needs
Proximity of consultant to the City
Subconsultants
Approach / Methodology
Work program/plan
Format/Content
Scheduling and reporting procedures
Hours - Level of Effort (Staffing commitment and time allocation)
Project manager/engineer
Inspector (if applicable)
Frequency of meetings with City staff
Ability to meet City's schedule and expectations
Relevant References (Record of performance)
Over 15 years of experience
No chages requested to the agreement
Located in San Marcos
Expensive
No experience with LA County agencies
Chris M.
WEIGHT
(1 to 3)
3
3
3
Overall Section Total:
3
3
2
1
Overall Section Total:
3
3
2
Overall Section Total:
2
2
1
Overall Section Total:
3
Overall Section Total:
3
Overall Section Total:
GRAND TOTAL:
DATE:
RATING
(1 to 10)
2
3
3
3
3
1
1
3
3
2
2
2
0
3
3
6/2/2023
WEIGHTED
TOTAL
6
9
9
5.33333333333333
9
9
2
1
4.66666666666667
9
9
4
6.875
4
4
0
3.2
9
3
9
1.5
24.575
FACTOR
0.2
0.2
0.25
0.2
0.1
0.05
BY:
CONSULTANT: John L. Hunter & Associates, Inc.
Staff Qualification
Overall experience with Diamond Bar/public agencies
Organizational structure of the project team
Staff experience & knowledge in providing similar service
Firm Qualifications
Experience with similar projects
Responsiveness/demonstrated understanding of the City's needs
Proximity of consultant to the City
Subconsultants
Approach / Methodology
Work program/plan
Format/Content
Scheduling and reporting procedures
Hours - Level of Effort (Staffing commitment and time allocation)
Project manager/engineer
Inspector (if applicable)
Frequency of meetings with City staff
Ability to meet City's schedule and expectations
Relevant References (Record of performance)
Over 30 years of experience, including 16 of service with the City of
Diamond Bar.
Agreed to the conditions of the agreement
Located in Buena Park
Chris M.
WEIGHT
(1 to 3)
3
3
3
Overall Section Total:
3
3
2
1
Overall Section Total:
3
3
2
Overall Section Total:
2
2
1
Overall Section Total:
3
Overall Section Total:
3
Overall Section Total:
GRAND TOTAL:
DATE:
RATING
(1 to 10)
3
3
3
3
3
2
1
3
3
2
2
2
0
3
3
6/2/2023
WEIGHTED
TOTAL
9
9
9
6
9
9
4
1
5.11111111111111
9
9
4
6.875
4
4
0
3.2
9
3
9
1.5
25.6861111111111
FACTOR
0.2
0.2
0.25
0.2
0.1
0.05
BY:
CONSULTANT: Proactive Engineering Consultants
Staff Qualification
Overall experience with Diamond Bar/public agencies
Organizational structure of the project team
Staff experience & knowledge in providing similar service
Firm Qualifications
Experience with similar projects
Responsiveness/demonstrated understanding of the City's needs
Proximity of consultant to the City
Subconsultants
Approach / Methodology
Work program/plan
Format/Content
Scheduling and reporting procedures
Hours - Level of Effort (Staffing commitment and time allocation)
Project manager/engineer
Inspector (if applicable)
Frequency of meetings with City staff
Ability to meet City's schedule and expectations
Relevant References (Record of performance)
Experience with LA County agencies
No chages requested to the agreement
Located in Corona
Expensive
Chris M.
WEIGHT
(1 to 3)
3
3
3
Overall Section Total:
3
3
2
1
Overall Section Total:
3
3
2
Overall Section Total:
2
2
1
Overall Section Total:
3
Overall Section Total:
3
Overall Section Total:
GRAND TOTAL:
DATE:
RATING
(1 to 10)
2
3
3
3
3
1
1
3
3
2
2
2
0
3
3
6/2/2023
WEIGHTED
TOTAL
6
9
9
5.33333333333333
9
9
2
1
4.66666666666667
9
9
4
6.875
4
4
0
3.2
9
3
9
1.5
24.575
FACTOR
0.2
0.2
0.25
0.2
0.1
0.05
BY:
CONSULTANT: Socal Stormwater Runoff SolutionSvcs
Staff Qualification
Overall experience with Diamond Bar/public agencies
Organizational structure of the project team
Staff experience & knowledge in providing similar service
Firm Qualifications
Experience with similar projects
Responsiveness/demonstrated understanding of the City's needs
Proximity of consultant to the City
Subconsultants
Approach / Methodology
Work program/plan
Format/Content
Scheduling and reporting procedures
Hours - Level of Effort (Staffing commitment and time allocation)
Project manager/engineer
Inspector (if applicable)
Frequency of meetings with City staff
Ability to meet City's schedule and expectations
Relevant References (Record of performance)
Over 10 years of experience
Agreed to the conditions of the agreement
Located in Shermal Oaks
Chris M.
WEIGHT
(1 to 3)
3
3
3
Overall Section Total:
3
3
2
1
Overall Section Total:
3
3
2
Overall Section Total:
2
2
1
Overall Section Total:
3
Overall Section Total:
3
Overall Section Total:
GRAND TOTAL:
DATE:
RATING
(1 to 10)
3
3
3
3
3
2
1
3
3
2
2
2
0
3
3
6/2/2023
WEIGHTED
TOTAL
9
9
9
6
9
9
4
1
5.11111111111111
9
9
4
6.875
4
4
0
3.2
9
3
9
1.5
25.6861111111111