Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCAJA Environmental Services, LLCCAJA EÄò®ÙÊÄÛÄヽ S›Ùò®‘›Ý ¥ÊÙ ƒ 49-UÄ®ã Aãパ«›— ƒÄ— D ›ãƒ‘«›— R›Ý®—›Ä㮃½ C ÊėÊîĮçà PÙʹ›‘ã P ÙÊÖÊ݃½ ãÊ Pٛփٛ CEQA DʑçÛÄãƒã®ÊÄ July 31, 2025CAJA Environmental Services, LLC SubmiƩed by: CAJA Environmental Services 9410 Topanga Canyon Boulevard, Suite 101 Chatsworth, CA 91311 SubmiƩed to: City of Diamond Bar AƩn: Rudy Lopez, Assistant Planner 21810 Copley Drive Diamond Bar, CA 91765 9410 Topanga Canyon Boulevard, Suite 101 Chatsworth, CA 91311 Phone 310-469-6700 www.ceqa-nepa.com City of Diamond Bar Attn: Rudy Lopez, Assistant Planner 21810 Copley Drive Diamond Bar, CA 91765 RE: Proposal to Prepare CEQA Documentation for the 49-Unit Attached/Detached Residential Condominium Project Dear Mr. Lopez: CAJA Environmental Services, LLC (CAJA) is pleased to present our proposal to prepare CEQA documentation for the proposed 49-unit attached/detached residential condominium project (Project) located at 1400 Montefino Avenue (Project Site) in the City of Diamond Bar (City). It is our understanding that the City anticipates the CEQA path for the Project will include preparation of an Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration (IS/MND). CAJA is uniquely qualified to prepare an IS/MND for the Project and to support the City with the CEQA process. With nearly 40 years of experience in preparing CEQA and NEPA documentation for a wide variety of private and public sector projects, CAJA o\ers a full range of environmental services tailored to meet the City’s needs. CAJA’s approach emphasizes thorough technical evaluation, comprehensive and legally defensible environmental analysis, and meticulous preparation of all necessary environmental documents, including Exemptions, Initial Studies, EIRs, MNDs, Response to Comments, and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Programs. Our seasoned project manager, Stacie Henderson, will ensure e\ective supervision of the consultant team, seamless coordination with City sta\, and strict adherence to project timelines. CAJA has teamed with highly qualified technical subconsultants to provide the City with a well-rounded set of services. DKA Planning: Air Quality, Greenhouse Gas Emissions, and Noise experts SWCA: Archaeological/Tribal Cultural Resources, Paleontological Resources, and Biological Resources experts CAJA looks forward to working with the City on this Project. Thank you. Sincerely, Chris Joseph, Owner/President 1 QUALIFICATIONS CAJA is uniquely qualified to support the City with environmental review and CEQA services. With nearly 40 years of experience in preparing and reviewing CEQA and NEPA documentation for a wide variety of private and public sector projects, CAJA oGers a full range of environmental services tailored to meet the City’s needs. Our seasoned project managers ensure eGective supervision of consultant teams, seamless coordination with City staG, and strict adherence to project timelines. CAJA’s approach emphasizes thorough technical evaluation, comprehensive and legally defensible environmental analysis, and meticulous preparation and review of all necessary environmental documents, including Exemptions, Initial Studies, EIRs, MNDs, Response to Comments, and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Programs. We also manage public circulation requirements, ensuring compliance with CEQAnet postings and public notice procedures. Our team is highly experienced in presenting at community meetings and public hearings, responding to stakeholder inquiries with professionalism and clarity. CAJA is committed to delivering high-quality work products on schedule and in full compliance with all applicable federal, state, and local laws, as well as City policies, ensuring that the City’s environmental review process is eGicient, transparent, and legally sound. Project Management • Manage projects from proposal submission to final environmental document adoption or certification. • Oversee consultant teams and subconsultants. • Coordinate closely with the City’s project manager and related staG. Technical Environmental Evaluation • Analyze environmental issues for compliance with CEQA in accordance with state and local requirements. • Ensure environmental documents meet all applicable guidelines. Preparation of Environmental Documents • Prepare all drafts and final versions of: o Notices of Preparations (NOPs) o Initial Studies o Notices of Availability (NOAs) o Responses to Comments o Statements of Overriding Considerations o Findings and Facts 2 o Mitigation Measures and Monitoring Programs o Tribal consultation letters (as needed) Public Review Coordination • Circulate environmental documents for public review. • Publish or record public notices. • Post documents to CEQAnet as required. Public Participation • Attend and participate in community meetings and public hearings. • Prepare and present materials. • Respond to public and stakeholder questions. Timeline Compliance • Ensure all work adheres to City-established project timelines. CAJA STAFF Full resumes for CAJA staG are included in the Appendix. Chris Joseph, Owner/President: Mr. Joseph, Founder and Owner of CAJA, is responsible for management of the firm and for providing leadership, strategy, and direction in the preparation of environmental impact documents for both private development projects and government programs. Over the last 40 years, Mr. Joseph has built the firm around the concept of providing personalized, senior-level professional services to clients. As such, Mr. Joseph maintains an active role with clients and their projects and assures that he and his senior staG will be accessible and involved in successfully guiding projects through the environmental clearance process. Under his direction, and with a hand-selected team of experienced, highly qualified, and specialized environmental professionals, CAJA has earned a reputation for eGiciently providing thorough and conscientious work. For work under contract with the City, Mr. Joseph will provide high-level management of CAJA employees to ensure that the City receives quality service. Stacie Henderson, Vice President/Senior Project Manager: Ms. Henderson, Vice President and Senior Project Manager with 19 years of experience. Ms. Henderson is responsible for all aspects of preparation of environmental review documents and is proficient in drafting all sections of environmental review documents, incorporating technical reports into documents, and personally corresponding with public and private sector clients. Ms. Henderson regularly manages the preparation of high-profile environmental documents pursuant to CEQA and NEPA from the beginning of the process through the public hearings. For work under contract with the City, Ms. Henderson could act as a Project Manager and will prepare some of the environmental analyses 3 needed for the IS/MND. Ms. Henderson will dedicate approximately 50 percent of her weekly time to manage the Project on CAJA’s end. Her contact information is as follows: Stacie Henderson stacie@ceqa-nepa.com 310-469-6703 Seth Wulkan, Senior Project Manager: Mr. Wulkan a Senior Project Manager, has 17 years of experience and is responsible for all aspects of preparation of environmental review documents. He began his career with CAJA in 2007. Mr. Wulkan is proficient in drafting all sections of environmental review documents, incorporating technical reports into documents, and personally corresponding with public and private sector clients. Mr. Wulkan regularly participates in team strategy meetings from the beginning of the environmental review process through the final project hearings. For work under contract with the City, Mr. Wulkan would assist the CAJA Project Manager with preparation of environmental analyses. Kerrie Nicholson, Principal: Ms. Nicholson is a Principal with over 27 yeas of professional experience in environmental writing, planning, and research. She began her career with CAJA as an environmental planner in 1998. She has contributed substantially to the preparation and management of several types of environmental documentation pursuant to CEQA and NEPA, including EIRs, EISs, MNDs, CEs, SCPEs, and SCEAs. Ms. Nicholson’s experience comprises a variety of multi-faceted developments including specific plans, single- and multi-family residential, mixed- use, entertainment/retail, institutional, commercial, industrial, and recreational developments. For work under contract with the City, Ms. Nicholson would assist the CAJA Project Manager with preparation of environmental analyses. Andrea Schultz, Assistant Environmental Planner: Ms. Schultz is an Assistant Environmental Planner who has worked for CAJA in various capacities for 17 years. Guided by senior planning staG, Ms. Schultz works eGiciently independently and as a member of the larger project team to conduct research and assist in the preparation of various environmental documents. She assists by researching and applying local zoning code requirements for project level-analysis and reads and interprets technical studies and site plan information for use, as well as assisting senior staG members make edits and updates to documents. In addition, Ms. Schultz oversees document production for CAJA, including editing, formatting, and physical production of requested documents. In this capacity she also verifies that all documents and production comply with State and local noticing requirements under CEQA. For work under contract with the City, Ms. Schultz would assist the CAJA Project Manager with preparation of CEQA documentation. 4 CAJA REFERENCES City of Los Angeles Milena Zasadzien, Principal City Planner, Major Projects 221 North Figueroa Street, Suite 1350 Los Angeles, CA 90012 (213) 847-3636 milena.azasadzien@lacity.org CAJA has worked on dozens of projects over CAJA’s 40-years of business with the City of Los Angeles, including the Morningstar of Granada Hills EIR (current). City of Torrance Leo Oorts, Planning Manager 3031 Torrance Boulevard Torrance, CA 90503 310-618-5990 LOorts@TorranceCA.Gov CAJA worked with the City of Torrance on the Torrance Del Amo MND (2024) and the 3475 Torrance Boulevard Class 32 Categorical Exemption (2025). City of Carson Saied Naaseh, Community Development Director 701 East Carson Street Carson, CA 90745 (310) 952-1770 snaaseh@carsonca.gov In 2024 and 2025, CAJA prepared two separate Addenda to the City’s General Plan EIR for residential projects in the City of Carson. SUBCONSULTANTS CAJA will act as the primary consultant assisted by the technical subconsultants discussed below. Doug Kim and Associates (DKA) Planning (Air Quality, GHG Emissions, and Noise) DKA Planning was founded in 2006 and provides comprehensive policy and technical analysis services in the areas of transportation, transit, and air quality planning. The company employs four staG members. DKA Planning also performs traGic, air quality, and noise analyses for CEQA and NEPA environmental documents. The company’s services include the following: Air Quality Policy and Analysis • Air quality mitigation plans 5 • Climate Action Plans • Emissions analysis • Climate change analysis • Dispersion modeling • Health Risk Assessments Noise Analysis • Ambient noise monitoring • Noise modeling of transportation sources Transportation Planning and Analysis • Transportation plan • TraGic impact analyses • TraGic mitigation and control plans • Transit needs assessments • Transit restructuring plans • Line-by-line analysis • On-board surveys Environmental Analysis • Preparation of CEQA/NEPA documents • EIR/EIS • Negative Declarations, Mitigated Negative Declarations • Development of Mitigation Monitoring Programs DKA Planning is both a certified Small Business Enterprise (SBE) and a certified Minority-Owned Business Enterprise (MBE). As part of the CAJA Team, DKA will conduct technical analyses related to air quality, GHG emissions, and noise/vibration. CAJA and DKA Planning have worked on dozens of projects together with CAJA as the prime consultant and DKA Planning as the subconsultant. A full resume for Mr. Kim is included in the Appendix 6 SWCA Environmental Consultants (Archaeological/Tribal Cultural Resources, Biological Resources, and Paleontological Resources) SWCA Environmental Consultants (SWCA) is one of the largest environmental consulting companies in the country with a focus solely on environmental science. SWCA would provide technical assistance on the CAJA Team with cultural and biological resources. The financial condition of the company is stable, with no pending bankruptcy, pending litigation, planned oGice closures, or impending mergers. SWCA’s cultural, paleontological, and natural resource experts and planners have diverse experience working for clients in both the public and private sectors. With specialized expertise in NEPA and CEQA compliance, cultural and natural resources management, permitting, and planning, SWCA helps clients achieve their objectives by reconciling potential conflicts between human activities and environmental quality, using sound science to develop creative solutions. Dr. Steven W. Carothers founded SWCA, Inc., in 1981 as a NEPA and environmental science firm. Over the following two decades, SWCA became recognized as a high quality full-service environmental services company, serving public and private clients throughout the United States. SWCA has expanded from a sole proprietorship to a 100% employee-owned corporation with more than 790 employees and 29 oGices in 19 states, including four oGices in California. SWCA is an Engineering News-Record ‘Top 200’ Environmental Firm. SWCA oGers a highly qualified team with the size and stability of a larger company, combined with the focus and responsiveness of a locally based boutique firm. The company has provided comprehensive environmental planning, regulatory compliance, and cultural resource management services to businesses and government clients across California. Cultural and paleontological resources management is one of SWCA’s core services, representing the focus of nearly half of our professional staG. Our qualified staG includes archaeologists, historians, architectural historians, and paleontologists with an in-depth understanding of federal, state, and local regulations, including NEPA and CEQA. SWCA also maintains a diverse group of biologists, ecologists, paleontologists, and other technical experts that address biological, aquatic, terrestrial, and water issues. SWCA biologist specialize in all areas of natural resource management, including planning, mitigation, and permitting that is related to the Endangered Species Act (ESA) and other critical legislation for terrestrial and aquatic species and their habitats. As part of the CAJA Team, SWCA will conduct technical analyses/peer review related to archaeological/tribal cultural resources, biological resources, and paleontological resources. CAJA and SWCA have worked on dozens of projects together with CAJA as the prime consultant and SWCA as the subconsultant. 7 SWCA STAFF Full resumes for SWCA staG are included in the Appendices. Chris Millington is a principal investigator in SWCA’s Pasadena, California, oGice with 20 years of experience in cultural resources management. His responsibilities include technical oversight, research, project management, agency coordination, authoring cultural resources reports, analyzing spatial data, map production, and graphics. Across his career, Chris has contributed to over 700 compliance-driven projects with SWCA in eight states across the western United States. In the last 11 years, he has focused on projects and research primarily within his native Southern California, including both rural and urban settings. Chris has developed expertise in National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) and California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) compliance, urban archaeology, and Los Angeles history. He regularly collaborates with engineers, construction crews, planners, and attorneys, on both the private and public sides, and is experienced in responding to midstream project design changes, public scrutiny, and unanticipated budget and schedule adjustments. Chris has extensive experience supporting public agencies for tribal consultation under Assembly Bill 52 (AB 52) and regularly conducts desktop sensitivity assessments for archaeological and tribal cultural resources. Erin Tomaras has 9 years of experience as a biologist and project manager with a strong background in environmental planning and permitting for energy-related projects in southern and central California. She has managed or supported large-scale utility projects through routing and siting, agency consultation, permitting (including California Environmental Quality Act [CEQA]/National Environmental Policy Act [NEPA] compliance), environmental compliance, and postconstruction restoration. She has prepared numerous environmental impact assessments, biological and aquatic technical reports, aquatic permit applications for the United States (U.S.) Army Corps of Engineers, Regional Water Quality Control Board, and California Department of Fish Wildlife (CDFW), and incidental take permit (ITP) applications for the CDFW and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Heather CliUord is a Senior Paleontological Resources Team Lead with 12 years of experience in the environmental consulting industry, serving variously as project manager, subject matter expert, and team lead in support of projects throughout California. She is a geologist and paleontologist with experience completing and directing paleontology work throughout California and Nevada. She has successfully completed paleontological resource management projects involving paleontological assessments, data recovery, curation preparation, and paleontological eGorts. As a Paleontology Principal Investigator and Subject Matter Expert, she routinely directs paleontological field surveys and inventories, mitigation monitoring of construction, third-party review, preparation of reports and document sections, fossil salvage and collection, laboratory preparation and analysis of micro- and macrofossils, and technical reporting. 8 PROJECT LIST AND SCHEDULE A selection of CAJA’s project experience is included below. Additional examples can be provided upon request. Torrance Del Amo : In 2024, CAJA prepared an IS/MND for the Torrance Del Amo Project in the City of Torrance. The Project includes demolition and removal of all existing uses from the Project Site and development of the site with four residential buildings with a total of 272 multi-family residential dwelling units (including 28 dwelling units set aside for Very Low Income households) over two levels of subterranean parking. Additionally, the Project includes an oG-site sewer line upgrade along the western edge of Crenshaw Boulevard from 230th Street to 233rd Street, approximately 1,200 feet in length, joining the existing 15-inch sewer downstream of 233rd Street. Leo Ooorts, Planning Manager 3031 Torrance Boulevard Torrance, CA 90503 310-618-5990 LOorts@TorranceCA.Gov Morningstar of Granada Hills: CAJA is currently preparing an EIR for an eldercare facility in the City of Los Angeles. CD-MS (Granada Hills) LLC (Applicant) proposes redevelopment of the Project Site with a 98-unit eldercare facility, including 65 assisted living units (AL Units), 30 memory care units (MC units), and 3 independent living units (IL Units). The Project includes demolition of two existing garages and ancillary buildings, preservation of three existing single-family residential structures that would be converted into IL Units, and construction of a 103,873-square-foot building in the central portion of the Project Site to house the 65 AL Units and the 30 MC Units (AL/MC Building). The AL/MC Building would have two stories with a partial third story in the northern half of the building and would reach a maximum building height of 45 feet. The Project would provide 11,904 square feet of open space, including a 6,562-square-foot courtyard for the AL residents, a 3,942-square-foot courtyard for the MC residents, and 1,400 square feet of open space for the IL residents. The Project would provide two driveways on Shoshone Avenue and one on Rinaldi Street, 77 automobile parking spaces in surface parking areas, and 35 bicycle parking spaces, including 12 short-term and 23 long-term spaces. The Project includes six retaining walls to accommodate the siting and development of the AL/MC Building while maintaining the existing single-family residential structures. The Project would require the removal of 129 on-site trees, including 19 protected trees and 50 non-protected trees, while preserving 89 existing on-site trees. In addition, the Project would require the removal of 6 street trees. All removed trees would be replaced in accordance with the City’s tree replacement requirements. Construction of the Project is estimated to take 21 months and would require the export of approximately 5,605 cubic yards of soil. City of Los Angeles More Song, City Planner 221 N. Figueroa Street, Suite 1350 9 Los Angeles, CA 90012 More Song more.song@lacity.org (213) 978-1319 Dyrt Labs, Inc: CAJA recently prepared a Class 32 Categorical Exemption for the Dyrt Labs, Inc. Project in the City of Vernon. The Project includes reuse of the existing industrial building on the Project Site as a within-vessel compost facility, which would use proprietary hardware to convert organic waste to nutrient rich compost. The facility would only accept non-hazardous municipal solid waste - specifically organic waste. The facility would operate 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, and would employ approximately 25 people. The operation would be streamlined for medium-scale urban waste management, with a focus on maintaining minimal traGic and environmental impact. City of Vernon Daniel Wall, P.E. dwall@cityofvernonca.gov (323) 583-8811 x305 6521 S. Sepulveda Boulevard Project: In 2022, CAJA prepared a Sustainable Communities Environmental Assessment (SCEA) for the 6521 S. Sepulveda Boulevard Project in the City of Los Angeles. The Project Site was improved with a single-story, multi-tenant commercial plaza and a single-story, multi-tenant industrial/mixed-use building, containing approximately 22,222 square feet of commercial use and 1,778 square feet of restaurant use, an approximately 7,760-square-foot diner (Dinah’s Family Restaurant), a small locksmith shop, and associated surface parking. With the exception of the existing Dinah’s Family Restaurant building on the Project Site (that would be preserved and renovated in place) and some existing signage, the Project included demolition and removal of all existing structures from the Project Site and development of the site with an eight- story, 362-unit multi-family residential building, with approximately 3,700 square feet of ground-floor restaurant space fronting Sepulveda Boulevard. Of the 362 proposed units, 41 are restricted to Very Low Income households. The new building totaled approximately 365,623 square feet, which along with the existing Dinah’s Family Restaurant, results in a floor area ratio (FAR) of 3.85:1, and reaches 96 feet and 4 inches in height as measured to the top of the elevator structure. The Project retained the majority of the Dinah’s Family Restaurant building, including its character-defining features and materials. The Project required the export of approximately 50,000 cubic yards of soil. 10 SCOPE OF WORK Task 1: Attend Kick-oU Meeting CAJA’s Project Manager will attend a meeting with City staG and the Applicant to discuss data sources and roles and responsibilities and to establish communication protocols. Task 2: Conduct Native American Outreach and Consultation (AB 52) CAJA will initiate the required tribal consultation for the Project-to government consultation in accordance with AB 52. CAJA will use the list of tribes who have requested AB 52 notification from the City, as well as the most current tribal consultation list furnished by the Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC). From this list, CAJA will draft letters and maps for submission to tribal government contacts, as well as provide the City with instructions for successful AB 52 consultation. CAJA’s subconsultant SWCA will be available to provide expert assistant with this task if needed. Task 3: Collect Data/Review Existing Information CAJA will review all existing Project-related information and pertinent documentation. To enable CAJA to proceed with this task, the following information shall be provided by the City to clearly define the Project description and conduct the environmental analysis: • Project plan set • Detailed list of “green” measures that will be incorporated into the Project to ensure that Project would result in a less-than-significant impact related to greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions • Construction information (including grading and excavation quantities, equipment list, proposed construction schedule, and proposed haul route) • Geotechnical Report (subject to City peer review) • Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (and Phase II, if required) • LID Report (subject to City peer review) • SWPPP Report (subject to City peer review) • Hydrology/Hydraulic Report (subject to City peer review) • Sewer Study (subject to City peer review) • Transportation Study (subject to City peer review) • List of Related Projects 11 Task 4: Prepare Project Description Because the Project description is the basis for analyzing the environmental impacts of the Project and identifying appropriate mitigation measures, it is important to prepare the Project description as early in the CEQA process as possible. CAJA will review all relevant Project description materials and will prepare a preliminary version of the Project description that will be used in the IS/MND. The Project description will include the following: • The Project Site’s regional and local setting and location; • Project characteristics, including but not limited to design characteristics, landscaping, access/circulation, infrastructure, grading/excavation, and construction phasing/scheduling; and • Required discretionary actions. CAJA will submit the Project description to the City for one round of review and comment. The revised version will then be incorporated into the Administrative Draft IS/MND. Task 5: Prepare Technical Studies The previously identified CAJA subconsultants will prepare the technical studies outlined below that will be incorporated into the IS/MND. If preferred, the technical studies can first be submitted to the City for review prior to incorporation into the IS/MND. This can be discussed at the kick-oG meeting. Air Quality Task A: Characterize Existing Conditions To establish the existing air quality setting , DKA will provide an overview of the regulatory environment, including City’s 2045 General Plan Resource Conservation Element. The air quality conditions within the South Coast Air Basin and the Project Site area will be disclosed, including State attainment and nonattainment status designations. DKA will compile historical data from the nearest South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMD) monitoring station over the past three years. Sensitive receptors within 1,000 feet of the Project Site will be identified. DKA will estimate existing air quality emissions from the commercial development using the California Emissions Estimator Model (CalEEMod) model. Task B: Assess Cons truction Emissions Impacts DKA will describe short-term construction-based impacts both qualitatively and quantitatively, including: • An estimation of short-term local and regional air quality eGects associated with construction of the Project using the CalEEMod model. • Comparing regional and localized air quality impacts against SCAQMD daily emissions thresholds to determine significance. 12 • Determining the consistency of construction impacts with the 2045 General Plan Resource Conservation Element, SCAQMD Air Quality Management Plan (AQMP), and any relevant air quality plans. • Discussing odors and toxic air contaminants (TAC) qualitatively. The TAC analysis will qualitatively discuss exposure based on the duration of construction activity. This scope of work does not include a health risk assessment for construction emissions. Task C: Assess Operational Emissions Impacts DKA will analyze the Project’s long-term direct and indirect impacts related to air quality. This will include: • Quantifying stationary source, area source, and mobile source emissions and comparing the amount of these emissions against the SCAQMD’s thresholds of significance to determine impacts on localized and regional air quality. • Qualitatively addressing localized concentrations of carbon monoxide along key roadways from Project traGic. • Qualitatively assessing the Project’s impact on odors and TAC emissions. Archaeological Resources SWCA will prepare requests for searches of the Sacred Lands File (SLF) and California Historical Resources Information System (CHRIS). The request for the SLF search will be submitted to the NAHC. The CHRIS records search will be conducted by SWCA at the South Central Coastal Information System (SCCIC), which maintains records for Los Angeles County. The CHRIS search will be conducted for the Project Site plus a 0.5-mile radius. SWCA will conduct basic background research specific to the assessment of archaeological resources. The research will include more specific attention to the potential for as-yet unidentified historical archaeological resources (not aGiliated with Native Americans) to be present within the Project Site, also known as a sensitivity assessment. SWCA will conduct this research using archival information already on-file and obtained through publicly available sources. To the extent they are available, SWCA will also incorporate data from other technical reports prepared for the Project (e.g., geotechnical investigation and Phase I Environmental Assessment). Upon completion of the records searches and background research, SWCA will prepare the results in a technical memorandum (memo). The technical memo will summarize the following: Project description; regulatory framework; research methodology; limited environmental and cultural setting; results of the CHRIS and SLF searches; results of archival research; and the sensitivity assessment. The technical memo will conclude with a finding of the proposed Project’s potential to impact archaeological resources, specifically whether there are any new or substantially more severe significant impacts from the Project compared with the findings from the Project. 13 SWCA will address up to one round of comprehensive comments to the administrative draft. Additional rounds of review and revision to address information submitted by the tribe or comments by the City could require an additional fee. Biological Resources SWCA will assess the Project Site for the presence or potential occurrence of biological resources. To accomplish this task, SWCA will 1) conduct background research and a literature review ; 2) perform a biological field survey; and 3) complete a biological resources technical report. The following descriptions provide more detail for each of these components: Desktop Biological Resources Analysis SWCA will conduct a comprehensive desktop-based review of database and literature resources to identify sensitive biological resources that could occur on or in the immediate vicinity of the project, including special-status plant and animal species. The literature and database search will include, but not be limited to the following resources: • California Natural Diversity Database (CNDDB) • California Native Plant Society Inventory of Rare and Endangered Plants • Consortium of California Herbaria records • U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) critical habitat mapper • USFWS Information for Planning and Consultation website • Aerial imagery • Wildlife occurrence databases Biological Field Survey Based on the results of the database and literature search, a qualified SWCA biologist familiar with the flora and fauna of the area will conduct a reconnaissance-level field survey to document existing conditions, identify natural resources (plants, animals, and vegetation) within and adjacent to the project site, and record the presence of special-status species or suitable habitat present at the time of survey. All botanical and wildlife species observed on site, including direct and indirect wildlife observations (e.g., scat, tracks, or calls), vegetation communities, and jurisdictional aquatic features, if present, will be recorded and mapped. Biological Resources Technical Report SWCA will prepare a Biological Resources Technical Report (BRTR) that details the findings of the desktop review and field survey and includes the information needed to fulfill CEQA review requirements. The report will focus on the natural resources within the project site, as well as any adjacent resources that could be aGected by project implementation. The report will include: • Introduction, describing the project location and environmental setting • Methods used in the background research, field survey, and assessment of the potential for special-status species 14 • Results of the database and literature searches, vegetation/habitat mapping, and habitat assessments • Discussion of the distribution of natural features within and immediately adjacent to the project site, including vegetation communities, wildlife habitats, potential jurisdictional wetlands, and sensitive plant and wildlife populations • An assessment of the potential for federally listed, state listed or otherwise sensitive species to occur • An environmental evaluation of the significance of biological impacts consistent with Appendix G of the State CEQA guidelines • An analysis of potential impacts to sensitive biological resources that may be anticipated from project activities and required mitigation measures to oGset impacts • Recommendations for avoiding and minimizing impacts to sensitive resources SWCA will address up to one round of comprehensive comments from the project team on the administrative draft BRTR. SWCA will then prepare a revised draft to submit to the City (if requested), and address one round of comprehensive comments before finalizing the BRTR. Paleontological Resources SWCA will conduct a desktop paleontological resources assessment. The assessment will include a review of the most recent geologic mapping and scientific literature, and a records search obtained from the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County (NHMLA), who maintains a record of previously recorded fossil localities in the Project vicinity. SWCA will request a records search from the NHMLA. SWCA assumes that no paleontological reconnaissance survey would be required for the Project since the site has been previously developed (i.e., disturbed) at the surface, and no new information pertinent to paleontological potential could be gathered by a site visit. The results of the literature review and records search will be used to identify areas of paleontological sensitivity in conformance with the standards of the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology (SVP). Upon completion of the background research tasks, SWCA will prepare the results in a technical memo. The memo will comply with industry standards as described by the SVP, applicable local regulations, and published best practices in mitigation paleontology. The report will discuss the regulatory framework, research methodology, geologic settings, relevant scientific literature, museum records search results, and references cited. In addition, the report will discuss the proposed Project’s potential to adversely impact scientifically significant paleontological resources in accordance with CEQA Appendix G Guidelines and will provide mitigation recommendations as appropriate to reduce potential impacts to less-than-significant levels, pursuant to CEQA and local regulations. SWCA will address up to one round of consolidated comments by the project team on the draft technical report. SWCA will then prepare a final technical report for submittal to the City (if requested). The technical report will be delivered electronically. 15 GHG Emissions Task A: Characterize Existing Conditions The regulatory environment will be summarized, including policies from the State’s 2022 Scoping Plan, the 2024 Draft Priority Climate Action Plan, Southern California Association of Governments (SCAG) 2024 Regional Transportation Plan/Sustainable Communities Strategy (RTP/SCS), and City’s Climate Action Plan 2040. Task B: Assess Cons truction GHG Emissions Impacts Direct and indirect GHG emissions during construction activities will be estimated and disclosed. Emissions would be amortized over a 30-year period for inclusion in the operational analysis. Consistency with federal, State, regional, and City’s Climate Action Plan 2040.would be analyzed. Ta sk C: Assess Operational GHG Emissions Impacts Direct and indirect GHG emissions during long-term operation will be qualitatively assessed and disclosed and will include an assessment of the consistency of the Project with relevant State, region, and local plans, including federal, State, regional, and City’s Climate Action Plan 2040. Noise Task A: Characterize Exis ting Conditions The following will be included to establish the existing noise setting: • A discussion of the regulatory environment, including relevant policies from the City’s General Plan Public Safety Element and the municipal code • Identification of oG-site sensitive receptors within 1,000 feet of the Project Site as the basis for evaluating short-term construction and long-term operational impacts • The results of 15-minute noise readings at up to four receptor locations using a Quest Technologies Sound Examiner SE-400 Sound Level Meter to establish Leq noise levels near the Project Site • Identification of the 24-hour CNEL noise levels using guidance from the Federal Transit Administration • Description of noise generated by the existing commercial uses • Identification of existing sources of groundborne vibration at near the Project Site Task B: Assess Construction Noise and Vibration DKA will evaluate the Project’s short-term noise and vibration impacts on the environment, which will include the following: • An estimation of Project-generated noise levels at oG-site sensitive receptors using the ISO 9613-2 noise attenuation methodologies using the SoundPLAN Essential noise model (version 5.1). 16 • An assessment of oG-site noise levels from on-site construction activities based on the Project’s potential to increase traGic volumes on local streets. To determine oG-site noise impacts from construction truck noise, the number of construction truck trips and worker commute trips will be estimated to determine the change in roadway traGic noise levels. • An evaluation of the Project’s impacts against noise-level standards and other criteria. • An assessment of potential impacts of Project construction related to groundborne vibration near the Project Site. Task C: Assess Operational Noise and Vibration Impacts DKA Planning will evaluate direct and indirect operational noise impacts, which will include the following: • An assessment of approximate noise levels from the Project’s mechanical equipment • An assessment of whether Project traGic could significantly elevate oG-site noise levels • An assessment potential impacts of Project operations related to groundborne vibration near the Project Site Task 6: Prepare and Revise Administrative Draft IS/MND The IS/MND consists of a checklist that is used to identify areas where the Project could potentially result in significant environmental impacts as well as areas where the Project has no potential to result in impacts. CAJA will prepare an administrative version of the Administrative Draft IS/MND for the Project using the City’s Initial Study Checklist form. The IS/MND will include the Project Description prepared in Task 4 that will be used to assess the potential environmental eGects of Project implementation and to identify appropriate mitigation measures where necessary. CAJA will assemble all pertinent data provided by the City essential for preparation of the environmental documentation, as well as any other appropriate informational documents prepared for projects in the vicinity. The IS/MND will contain all applicable environmental components required by CEQA, including Introduction, Project Description/Characteristics and Discretionary Approvals, Setting, Impact Analysis, Mitigation Measures and Level of Significance After Mitigation, and mandatory CEQA findings. Analyses will be prepared based on site plans and studies, design information (e.g., site plans, Project description materials, technical studies, etc.), collection of photographic data, and other technical data. Preparation of the IS/MND will include development of detailed responses to all questions on the Initial Study Checklist and development of significance thresholds as required by the CEQA Guidelines. CAJA will submit an electronic version of the Administrative Draft IS/MND to the City for review and comment. It is assumed that the comments made by the City will be submitted to CAJA staG in one consolidated set. 17 (Note: Any changes to the Project Description made during this review could require changes to the analysis in the IS/MND and could require amendments to the proposed scope of work and budget.) Task 7: Prepare and Revise Screencheck Draft IS/MND CAJA will make the necessary changes to the IS/MND based on City staG comments and will prepare and submit the Screencheck Draft IS/MND so that the City can confirm that all requested changes have been made. It is assumed that the comments made by City staG will be submitted to CAJA in one consolidated set. (Note: Any changes to the Project Description made during this review could require changes to the analysis in the IS/MND that would require amendments to the proposed scope of work and budget.) Task 8: Prepare Mitigation Monitoring and R eporting Plan (MMRP) CAJA will prepare the MMRP for the Project that lists the mitigation measures (if any) identified in the IS/MND and lists the City departments or agency responsible for enforcing the mitigation measures and the timing of implementation. Task 9: Publish and Circulate IS/MND Once the City has approved the Screencheck Draft IS/MND, CAJA will print and deliver the required number of copies of the IS/MND package to the City within one week. CAJA will also provide the entire IS/MND package to the City in electronic PDF format, including all graphics and appendices. Additionally, CAJA will coordinate with the City in providing web-ready documents for publication on the City’s website, if needed. CAJA will prepare the Notice of Intent to Adopt an MND. This proposal assumes that the City will be responsible for the circulation of the IS/MND, as well as preparation and circulation of the Notice of Intent to Adopt an MND. Public Review Period There will be a public review period of not less than 20 days pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15105. Task 10: Prepare Responses to Agency/Public Comments (Optional Task) After the public review period, CAJA staG will be available to prepare responses to comments received on the IS/MND. Once all the comments have been reviewed, CAJA will prepare a strategy for responding to diGerent issues. CAJA will respond to comments either individually or grouped by topic, depending on which is more appropriate; track comments for cross-referencing and ensuring that all topics are addressed; and prepare an approach to answer comments on issues that are more philosophical than technical. 18 CAJA’s objectives for the responses to comments are to: 1) Assign responsibilities to technical and legal members of the Project Team in order to maintain the schedule and minimize later revisions; 2) Prepare a document that is well organized and usable by all parties, including the public; and 3) Thoroughly respond to all comments. Although the focus of the responses will be those comments that are subject to CEQA review, CAJA will also endeavor to answer all questions informatively. Task 11: Project Coordination and Meetings/Hearings Successful preparation of the IS/MND will require eGective communication between City staG and CAJA staG. Our experience in managing other projects has shown that meetings combined with “telecommuting” and status reports provide this type of communication. The CAJA Project Manager will be available to attend two meetings in addition to the kick-oG meeting and two public hearings. Attendance at additional meetings and public hearings will be subject to the Client’s written approval and will be billed on a time-and-materials basis in accordance with our billing rates schedule, which is provided at the end of this proposal. The CAJA Project Manager will serve as the day-to-day contact with the City representative and will be responsible for coordinating with all Project Team members in the preparation of the IS/MND. CAJA assumes that the majority of Project Team communication would be through emails. CAJA assumes that, in addition to the hearings identified herein, there would be up to four hours of conference calls. Task 12: Prepare and File Notice of Determination This proposal assumes that the City will prepare and file the Notice of Determination (NOD) after the IS/MND has been adopted and the Project has been approved, although CAJA is available to assist with this task. 19 ESTIMATED BUDGET A table detailing the estimated budget based on the above Scope of Work is included on the next page. Chris Stacie Seth Kerrie Andrea Graphics Subconsultant CAJA Staff Rate:$250 $200 $190 $190 $190 $100 NA Total Task 1: Attend Kick-off Meeting $0 $800 $0 $0 $0 $0 NA $800 Task 2: Conduct AB 52 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $3,730 $3,730 Task 3: Collect Data/Review Existing Information $0 $1,600 $380 $380 $380 $0 NA $2,740 Task 4: Prepare Project Description $0 $2,400 $0 $0 $0 $1,200 NA $3,600 Task 5: Prepare Technical Studies -Air Quality Study $0 $0 $380 $0 $0 $0 $2,500 $2,880 -Archaeological Resources Report $0 $400 $0 $0 $0 $0 $8,792 $9,192 -Biological Resources Study $0 $0 $0 $570 $0 $0 $13,041 $13,611 -GHG Emissions Report $0 $0 $0 $0 $380 $0 $2,500 $2,880 -Paleontological Assessment $0 $200 $0 $0 $0 $0 $5,702 $5,902 -Noise Study $0 $0 $380 $0 $0 $400 $3,500 $4,280 Task 6: Prepare and Revise Administrative Draft IS/MND $2,000 $6,400 $3,040 $3,040 $3,040 $800 NA $18,320 Task 7: Prepare and Revise Screencheck Draft IS/MND $500 $1,600 $760 $760 $760 $400 $0 $4,780 Task 8: Prepare MMRP $0 $0 $0 $0 $760 $0 -$760 Task 9: Publish and Circulate IS/MND $0 $1,200 $0 $0 $1,520 $800 -$3,520 Task 10: Prepare Responses to Comments (Optional Task)*$500 $2,400 $0 $0 $0 $400 NA $3,300 Task 11: Project Coordination and Meetings/Hearings $1,500 $3,200 $0 $0 $0 $0 NA $4,700 Task 12: Prepare and File NOD $0 $200 $0 $0 $760 $400 NA $1,360 Direct Costs $3,000 $86,055 $89,355 *The number and substantive nature of comments on the IS/MND cannot be predicted. The budget presented here is an estimate only. A more accurate budget would be determined after review of the comments. Total without Optional Task CAJA's ESTIMATED BUDGET Total with Optional Task 21 ACCEPTANCE OF CONDITIONS CAJA accepts all the conditions listed in the RFP. APPENDIX CAJA and Subconsultant Sta\ Resumes CCHHRRIISS JJOOSSEEPPHH President/Principal Experience Summary Mr. Chris Joseph, founder and owner of CAJA, is responsible for management of the firm and for providing leadership, strategy, and direction in the preparation of environmental impact documents for both private development projects and government programs. Mr. Joseph has built the firm around the concept of providing personalized, senior-level professional services to clients. As such, Mr. Joseph maintains an active role with clients and their projects, and assures that he and his senior staff will be accessible and involved in successfully guiding projects through the environmental clearance process. Under his direction, and with a hand-selected team of experienced, highly qualified, and specialized environmental professionals, CAJA has earned a reputation for efficiently providing thorough and conscientious work. Project Experience •Martin Expo Town Center •Santa Susana Estates EIR •Jefferson and La Cienega EIR •Weingart 6th and San Pedro SCEA •Noho West EIR •Stark Menifee Initial Study •Los Angeles Coliseum EIR •Ventura Parking Structure MND •Millennium Hollywood EIR •Hollywood Forever Cemetery CE •Casden Sepulveda EIR •Valley Charter School CE •Inglewood Football Stadium EIR •Park Pointe Encino MND •Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum Project EIR •Flintridge Sacred Heart Academy Specific Plan EIR •Sunset and Everett Mixed-Use EIR •Verdugo Hills Golf Course Project EIR •Malibu Racquet Club Expansion MND •Metro Universal Project EIR Educational Background and Professional Affiliations M.A. in Administration in Environmental Management-University of California, Riverside B.A. in Geography-California State University, Northridge Association of Environmental Professionals (AEP) American Planning Association (APA) Urban Land Institute (ULI) SSTTAACCIIEE HHEENNDDEERRSSOONN Vice President Experience Summary Ms. Stacie Henderson is a Senior Project Manager with over 19 years of experience. Ms. Henderson is responsible for all aspects of preparation of environmental review documents and is proficient in drafting all sections of environmental review documents; incorporating technical reports into documents; and personally corresponding with public and private sector clients. Ms. Henderson regularly manages the preparation of high-profile environmental documents pursuant to CEQA and NEPA from the beginning of the process through the public hearings. Ms. Henderson received a B.A. in Political Science from the University of California, Berkeley, a law degree from Loyola Law School, and is a member of the State Bar of California. Project Experience •999 Town & Country Orange IS/MND •Inglewood Football Stadium Report to Council •1001 Olympic (Olympia) EIR •Lane Ranch Town Center EIR •1212 Flower Street IS/MND •Martin Expo Town Center EIR •3003 Runyon Canyon EIR •Maubert Project SCPE •5850 Jeffeson EIR Addendum •Noho West EIR •11416 Burbank CE •Otis College IS/MND •Adobe at Glassell Park EIR •Paseo Plaza Hollywood EIR and Addendum •Bellwood Condos EIR •Picerne Lomita Apartments EIR •Branch West Orange IS/MND •Selma Hotel MND Addendum •Calabasas Village EIR Addendum •Southern California Flower Market EIR •Campbell Hall IS/MND •Tehachapi Walmart EIR •Cerritos Artesia Apartments IS/MND •Tierra Luna Marketplace EIR •Community Recycling and Resource Recovery EIR •Valley Charter School CE •Flower Market EIR •Venice and Fairfax IS/MND •GALS School CE •Waste Resources IS •Green Hollow Square EIR •Wilshire/Crescent Heights EIR •Hollywood Park EIR and Addendum •Yucca St Condos EIR Educational Background and Professional Affiliations J.D. – Loyola Law School B.A. in Political Science – University of California, Berkeley KKEERRRRIIEE NNIICCHHOOLLSSOONN Principal Experience Summary Ms. Kerrie Nicholson is a Principal at CAJA with over 27 years of professional experience in environmental writing, planning, and research. She began her career with CAJA as an environmental planner in 1998. She has contributed substantially to the preparation and management of several types of environmental documentation pursuant to CEQA and NEPA, including EIRs, EISs, MNDs, CEs, SCPEs, and SCEAs. Ms. Nicholson's experience comprises a variety of multi-faceted developments including specific plans, single- and multi-family residential, mixed-use, entertainment/retail, institutional, commercial, industrial, and recreational developments. Project Experience •Oakdale Estates MND •Brentwood Town Green EIR •1201 N. Gower Street SCEA •Ponte Vista EIR •Casden Sepulveda Project EIR •Taylor Yard Transit Village MND •3751 S. Delmas Terrace Apartments CE •Junction at Menifee Valley FEIR •SunWest Project EIR •Casden Sepulveda EIR •AVB Commons MND •Beverly and Fairfax Mixed-Use Project EIR •Los Angeles Country Club MND •Museum of Tolerance FEIR •Ramona Creek Specific Plan EIR •Santa Fe Springs Townlots Housing EIR •6399 Wilshire Blvd Project CE •Commerce Point EIR •Equity Residential Mixed-Use Project SCEA • Napa Valley College Master Plan EIR •Mt. Washington Residential Project MND •Kisco Park Plaza memory Care Facility MND •West Hollywood Gateway EIR •USC McHenry Library Expansion EIR •Belle Terre Specific Plan EIR •Monterey Park Crossing Project EIR/EIS •Town Center Specific Plan EIR •Deer Creek Plaza EIR •Santa Monica Open Space Element EIR •Self-Realization Fellowship Church EIR •Luxe @ Colfax Project EIR •Mammoth View Hotel MND •Weingart 6th and San Pedro SCEA •Flintridge Sacred Heart Academy Specific Plan EIR •Willows Community School Plan MND •Universal City Vision Plan EIR •900 N. Alvarado Street CE •Golden Valley Parkway Precise Plan Alignment MND •Olympic Tower EIR •Moorpark Street Residential MND •Menifee Town Center Specific Plan EIR •1346 N. Fairfax Avenue CE •Oxford Apartments CE •Hillcrest Christian School & Church Expansion EIR Educational Background and Professional Affiliations B.A. in Geography-California State University, Northridge Association of Environmental Professionals (AEP) SSEETTHH WWUULLKKAANN Project Manager Experience Summary Mr. Seth Wulkan has 17 years of experience and is responsible for all aspects of preparation of environmental review documents. He began his career with CAJA in 2007. Mr. Wulkan is proficient in drafting all sections of environmental review documents; incorporating technical reports into documents; and personally corresponding with public and private sector clients. Mr. Wulkan regularly participates in team strategy meetings from the beginning of the environmental review process through the final project hearings. Mr. Wulkan graduated with college honors from UCLA and completed a Certificate Program in Sustainability at UCLA Extension. Project Experience •Hollywood Center Studios MND •Hollywood Gower EIR •Sunswept Place CE •800 Western Koreatown MND •Millennium Hollywood EIR •Bay Street Arts District EIR •715 Hudson CE •Wilshire Crescent Heights EIR •Abbott Kinney Venice MND and EIR •11600 Santa Monica CE •Hollywood and Cherokee MND •925 La Brea Hollywood MND •520 La Fayette Park CE •4090 Del Rey MND •SeaBreeze Apartments Southbay EIR •Western and 24th CE •1330 Sunset CE •La Tijera Westchester MND •5777 Pico CE •1855 Westwood MND •Los Angeles New Community Plans EIR •2972 Santa Monica CE •5th and Hill Downtown LA EIR •904 La Brea Hollywood MND •Green Hollow Square EIR •200 Vermont CE •Garland and 8th MND •1035 Crenshaw CE •Sears Boyle Heights MND •Alhambra Storage CE •Bel Air Presbyterian Church Preschool EIR •Valley Dale Housing MND •Verdugo Hills Golf Course EIR •8521 Horner Project CE •825 Holt CE •1401 Vermont CE •Highland Selma Hollywood MND •755 Sand Point Shade Shadow •Panorama Mall MND •Ocean Front Walk Venice Air Quality Educational Background and Professional Affiliations B.A. in Geography/Environmental Studies and History – University of California, Los Angeles Certificate in Global Sustainability (Environmental Law and Policy) – UCLA Extension AANNDDRREEAA SSCCHHUULLTTZZ Assistant Environmental Planner Experience Summary Andrea Schultz is an Assistant Environmental Planner who has worked for CAJA in various capacities for more than 17 years. Guided by senior planning staff, Ms. Schultz works efficiently independently and as a member of the larger project team to conduct research and assist in the preparation of various environmental documents. She assists by researching and applying local zoning code requirements for project level-analysis and also reads and interprets technical studies and site plan information for use, as well as assisting senior staff members make edits and updates to documents. In addition, Ms. Schultz oversees document production for CAJA, including editing, formatting, and physical production of requested documents. In this capacity she also verifies that all documents and production comply with State and local noticing requirements under CEQA. Project Experience •Weingart 6th and San Pedro SCEA •Inglewood Football Stadium Report to Council •Southern California Flower Market EIR •GALS School CE •Martin Expo Town Center EIR •Valley Charter School CE •3003 Runyon Canyon EIR •Maubert Project SCPE •Kisco Park Plaza memory Care Facility MND •Noho West EIR •Picerne Lomita Apartments EIR •Flower Market EIR Educational Background and Professional Affiliations B.F.A. – Washington State University Douglas Kim, AICP Principal Education B.A., Economics and City & Regional Planning, University of California, Berkeley, CA Experience and Current Responsibilities Mr. Kim serves as a project manager and technical analyst for a variety of transportation, environmental, land use, and air quality projects. He has over 34 years of experience managing technical and policy assessments, including the preparation and review of traffic and parking analyses for major land use and transportation projects throughout California. This includes analysis of roadways, intersections, and signal warrants, along with traffic analysis peer review. He has served as a bench consultant to the City of West Hollywood and prepared numerous traffic and parking analyses for development projects throughout the Westside. He has policy and technical experience in developing long- and short-range multi-modal transportation plans, including development of performance measures, performing alternatives analyses, and managing technical modeling. Mr. Kim prepared and reviewed CEQA and NEPA documents for major land use and transportation projects and has authored guidance documents on how to perform transportation and circulation studies and air quality analyses. He has over twenty years of policy and technical experience in developing long- and short- range multi-modal transportation plans, including development of performance measures, performing alternatives analyses, and managing technical modeling. He has comprehensive experience with air quality regulatory agencies. This includes the entire spectrum of air quality policy, regulatory, and permitting issues. He has managed preparation of air quality plans, developed air quality regulations, and ensured regulatory compliance for a variety of facilities. Mr. Kim prepared guidance for the South Coast Air Quality Management District and Monterey Bay Unified Air Pollution Control District on regulatory compliance with air district and CEQA requirements. In turn, he has managed permit applications and modifications to existing permits, permitting of air pollution control equipment, compliance audits, emissions trading through the RECLAIM program, and emissions trading of mobile source emission credits (SCAQMD Regulation XVI). Mr. Kim has extensive technical modeling skills, including air quality dispersion modeling of point, area, and line sources of emissions, as well as toxic risk assessment. Mr. Kim is active in professional, community and cultural organizations. He is a certified planner with the American Institute of Certified Planners and is active on land use and transportation issues as a member of the Planning Commission for the City of Redondo Beach. He also has served as a member of the City of Redondo Beach Green Task Force. Mr. Kim is also an active member of the non-profit community, serving as a member of the Board of Directors for the Court Appointed Special Advocates for Los Angeles County, as well as the Japanese Douglas Kim, AICP Principal Page 2 American Citizens’ League. He is also a graduate of the Network of Korean American Leaders (NetKAL) through the University of Southern California. Relevant Project Experience: Air Quality, Noise, and Vibration § City of Cerritos, College Square Project. Mr. Kim prepared the air quality, GHG, and noise analyses for a drive-through restaurant project at 10900 Alondra Boulevard. Issues included noise from drive-through operations and speaker boxes. § City of Cerritos, 12651 Artesia Boulevard Project. Mr. Kim prepared the air quality, GHG, and noise analyses for a residential project near the 91 freeway. Issues included noise and air quality emissions from development adjacent to a freeway. § City of Cerritos, Best Plaza Project. Mr. Kim prepared the vibration analyses for a mixed-use project. § City of Cerritos, Via Piazzo Project. Mr. Kim prepared the air quality, GHG, and noise analyses for a mixed-use project at 12601 Artesia Boulevard. § City of Santa Fe Springs, 11811 Florence Avenue. Mr. Kim prepared the noise and vibration analysis for the reuse of a warehouse and distribution center. Issues included 24-hour impacts during long-term operation.. § City of La Mirada, 13525 Beach Boulevard Project. Mr. Kim prepared the air quality, GHG, and noise analyses for a mixed-use project. § South Coast Air Quality Management District, Regulatory Permitting – Mr. Kim has ensured regulatory compliance for private and public sector clients. This includes compliance with stationary source and mobile source rules and regulations, including the development of complete inventory of detailed equipment and engines to be permitted, emissions calculations, assessment of regulatory compliance, emission offset requirements through use of emission reduction credits or RECLAIM trading credits, and use of Best Available Control Technologies. § County of San Luis Obispo, Greenhouse Gas Inventory – Mr. Kim assisted in the comprehensive assessment of greenhouse gases in the unincorporated county jurisdiction. This included assessment of motor vehicle emissions from current development patterns, as well as GHG emissions from motor vehicles, land use, energy consumption, water consumption, and solid waste-related activities. Douglas Kim, AICP Principal Page 3 § City of San Carlos, Climate Action Plan – Mr. Kim helped develop the technical protocols for analyzing the motor vehicle and other area source GHG emissions inventory for the City. He also provided guidance on the development of CAP policies for motor vehicles, land use, energy consumption, water conservation, solid waste reduction programs, and other strategies designed to reduce the City’s carbon footprint over time. § Sonoma County Transportation Authority, Comprehensive Transportation Plan EIR – Mr. Kim is managing the development of the Sonoma County Transportation Authority’s Program-Level EIR for the 2009 Comprehensive Transportation Plan. This document will assess the direct and indirect environmental impacts of a 25-year multi-modal transportation plan that includes roadway and transit capital improvements, funding for roadway, transit, and non-motorized programs, funding alternatives, and smart growth scenarios. Key issues of concern include the impacts of the CTP on global climate change. § City of Ceres, Mitchell Ranch Wal-Mart Supercenter, Air Quality Analysis. Mr. Kim oversaw the climate change impact analysis for the proposed 229,135 square foot Supercenter. Key issues included the project-level threshold of significance and the quantitative methodologies for estimating CO2e emissions from the various source categories associated with a larger warehouse retail facility. § City of Paso Robles, Golden Hills Plaza Project, Air Quality Analysis. Mr. Kim prepared the air quality analysis for the Golden Hills Plaza project, which includes over 300,000 square feet of commercial retail, restaurant, and other uses in San Luis Obispo County. Analysis included use of URBEMIS and EMFAC on- road emission factors to project project-related emissions. § County of San Luis Obispo, Conservation Element and EIR. Mr. Kim is overseeing the development of the air quality policies for the San Luis Obispo County General Plan Conservation Element update and the air quality analysis for the associated EIR. Mr. Kim’s work on this project involves the development of progressive land use-related policies that are intended to reduce criteria pollutant emissions and reduce the County’s impact on climate change by reducing its carbon footprint. § South Coast Air Quality Management District, Air Quality Handbook. Mr, Kim served as co-authored of AQMD's landmark CEQA Guidelines that provide guidance for performing air quality and transportation impact analyses for environmental studies. This included screening guidance for CO analysis and detailed CALINE modeling protocols. § Monterey Bay Unified Air Pollution Control District, Air Quality Guidelines. Mr. Kim authored the District’s CEQA Guidelines for environmental review in the three-county North Central Coast, managed Douglas Kim, AICP Principal Page 4 CEQA environmental analyses for District regulations and air quality analyses throughout the air basin, and developed the agency's transportation/air quality conformity regulations for Monterey, Santa Cruz, and San Benito Counties. He also served on a CAPCOA Statewide committee that developed the Air Resources Board’s URBEMIS model for estimating air quality impacts of land use projects. § City of Cloverdale, General Plan EIR. Mr. Kim is developing an EIR air quality analysis for the comprehensive update of Cloverdale’s General Plan, an urbanizing community in northern Sonoma County. This includes an analysis of construction emissions expected from representative construction of land use and transportation projects. § City of Los Angeles, Trizec Hahn Office Development, EIR. Mr. Kim managed the air quality analysis of a 68,000 square-foot office and retail building in the Warner Center area of Los Angeles. Air quality modeling of CO impacts near major north-south and east-west arterials in the West San Fernando Valley was performed using CALINE. Project emissions were calculated using EMFAC and URBEMIS models. Relevant Project Experience: Air Quality § Southern California Association of Governments, Regional Transportation Plan EIR. Mr. Kim has helped develop and review the pending Program EIR for the 2008 Regional Transportation Plan. This analysis includes the assessment of air quality and climate change impacts from the implementation of a multi-billion dollar multi-modal transportation system in Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, Ventura, Imperial, and San Bernardino counties. § Southern California Association of Governments, Regional Comprehensive Plan. Mr. Kim has managed the development of SCAG’s Regional Comprehensive Plan (RCP). The RCP presents a vision of how Southern California can balance resource conservation, economic vitality, and quality of life and serves as a blueprint to approach growth and infrastructure challenges in an integrated and comprehensive way. Mr. Kim oversees manages the staff effort to develop the Plan, directs the public outreach efforts with public and private sector stakeholders, and serves as liaison to the RCP Task Force. § County of San Luis Obispo, Conservation Element and EIR. Mr. Kim is overseeing the development of the Conservation Element policies for San Luis Obispo County’s General Plan update and the air quality analysis for the associated EIR. Mr. Kim’s work on this project involves the development of progressive land use-related policies that are intended to reduce criteria pollutant emissions and reduce the County’s impact on climate change by reducing its carbon footprint. Douglas Kim, AICP Principal Page 5 § City of Laguna Beach, Aliso Creek Redevelopment EIR. Mr. Kim is overseing the air quality analysis for the prosposed redevelopment of a 62-room resort hotel and golf course. He is also managing the peer review of a traffic and parking study for consistency with city and Congestion Management Plan requirements. § City of Cloverdale, General Plan EIR- Assisting development of an EIR air quality analysis for the comprehensive update of Cloverdale’s General Plan, an urbanizing community in northern Sonoma County. Relevant Project Experience: Major Infrastructure Environmental Clearance § North Hollywood to Pasadena Bus Rapid Transit, Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority. Mr. Kim prepared the noise and vibration analysis for Metro’s transit service over an 18-mile corridor connecting the North Hollywood Metro B/G Line station on the west to Pasadena City College on the east. The Environmental Impact Report on the proposed project includes noise modeling of operational impacts from center-running and side-running coaches, as well as construction noise impacts from sidewalk and center median-based stations. § Anaheim Rapid Connection’ Fixed-Guideway Rail Project Management Consultant, City of Anaheim, Anaheim, CA (2009-Ongoing) – Mr. Kim serves as the day-to-day project coordinator for the alternatives analysis, environmental review, and engineering for a 3.3 mile fixed-guideway transit service linking the proposed ARTIC transit center with the City’s Platinum Triangle and Anaheim Resort. In his capacity with the Project Management Consultant team, he is coordinating with the Orange County Transportation Authority and Federal Transit Administration to oversee the analysis of three rail alignments and two bus rapid transit alternatives that use fixed-guideway, exclusive right-of-way for at least a portion of the corridor. The project will help enhance Metrolink commuter ridership to the Anaheim area, while also allowing regional transit riders that use future High Speed Rail to access local destinations in Anaheim. § Peninsula Corridor Rail Electrification Project, San Francisco (2014) – Mr. Kim oversaw the environmental clearance for the capital and operational improvements to commuter rail service connecting San Francsico to San Jose. This included the air quality and noise impacts from the replacement of diesel-powered rolling stock with electrified service. Issues included the installation of caternary structures, traction power substations, and switching stations. Douglas Kim, AICP Principal Page 6 Relevant Project Experience: Traffic Studies • City of San Jose, East Santa Clara Street Student Housing Project. Mr. Kim is preparing the traffic impact analysis for student housing project serving San Jose State University. • City of West Hollywood, 9200 Sunset Boulevard Traffic Impact Analysis. Mr. Kim prepared a traffic impact analysis for proposed commercial development in the City of West Hollywood. The analysis included traffic modeling and analysis of roadway, transit, and non-motorized impacts from construction of office space and a high-end restaurant. • County of Imperial, McCabe Ranch II Traffic Impact Analysis. Mr. Kim prepared the traffic analysis for a 443-unit residential development on 468 acres located within the Heber Specific Plan Area of Imperial County. The project includes seven vehicular access points into the project area, regional connections to SR 86 and other arterials. Local roads provide circulation within the project area, with an option for the use of private roads within the gated community. • County of Imperial, 101 Ranch Peer Review. Mr. Kim performed a traffic analysis peer review for a proposed 6,986 residential unit development on 1,897 acres north of the Mesquite Lake Specific Plan Area. The project includes five schools, 13.8-acres of mixed commercial/institutional/residential, 245 acres of parks, recreation centers, and 141 acres of major roads. • County of Imperial, 101 Ranch Specific Plan. Project included 6,986 residences at a density of 5.4 du/ac, located within 73 residential planning areas over 1,303 acres. Non-residential uses included 68 acres of four elementary schools; 20-acre junior high school; 13 acres of mixed commercial, institutional, and residential uses; and 195 acres of parks; 12 acres for RV storage; 144 acres of stormwater retention facilities; and 159 acres of roads. • County of Imperial, Coyote Wells Wind Zero Project. Mr. Kim prepared the traffic impact analysis for a proposed project outside of Ocotillo in Imperial County. The analysis looked at the direct and indirect traffic impacts of the proposed General Store/Storage, RV Park, Clubhouse, Motel, Emergency Vehicle Operations Training Center, Highway Driving Track, Kart Area, and Gun Ranges. The analysis utilized the HCM2000, CMA Circular 212, or any appropriate methodology preferred by the County of Imperial. The analysis will include the following: Douglas Kim, AICP Principal Page 7 § Imperial Valley Association of Governments, Strategic Transportation Plan for the I-8 Corridor. Mr. Kim is overseeing Mr. Kim’s work with IVAG, San Diego Association of Governments, and CalTrans District 11 to identify multi-modal transportation improvements along the I-8 highway corridor. The study analyzes transit service, growth forecasts, unmet transit needs, and initial recommendations, including both short-term commuter bus transit service and longer-term fixed guideway services. § City of West Hollywood, Luckman Development Traffic Impact Analysis. Mr. Kim oversaw the traffic impact analysis for the redevelopment of the Luckman Plaza, an existing mixed-use development. The project included 20,000 square feet of new restaurant and commercial office space and an off-site parking structure. The traffic impact analysis addressed traffic impacts to surrounding signalized and unsignalized intersections, neighborhood street impacts, off-site parking issues. § City of West Hollywood, Soho House Traffic Study. Mr. Kim managed the traffic and parking analysis for an 18,388 sq. ft. restaurant and club. The project included analysis of special event facilities that would generate unique travel demand characteristics, as well as parking and traffic impacts due to the prevalence of valet parking for visitors. § City of West Hollywood, La Peer Hotel Traffic Analysis. Mr. Kim managed the parking and traffic analysis of a mixed-use facility in West Hollywood, including 8 residential condominiums, 69 hotel rooms, a 2,680 sq. ft. restaurant, and 1,750 sq. ft of retail. § City of West Hollywood, 630 North La Cienega Boulevard Parking Analysis. Mr. Kim managed the parking and traffic analysis of a 22,770 sq. ft. retail and restaurant facility. The project included several levels of parking in an underground and above-ground garage, including 270 spaces, 190 beyond the required off- street parking for the project. The parking analysis was unique given the prevalence of preferential parking zones in the vicinity of the project and the inclusion of 190 parking spaces that would be leased to other local businesses. § City of West Hollywood, 8501 Melrose Avenue Parking Analysis. Mr. Kim managed the parking and traffic analysis of a 13,500 sq. ft. facility. The project included several levels of parking in an above-ground garage. The parking analysis was unique given the prevalence of preferential parking zones in the vicinity of the project. § City of Santa Monica, 1223 16th Street Medical Outpatient Center Traffic Study. Mr. Kim managed the traffic study for a 45,000 square-foot medical outpatient facility in Santa Monica’s Hospital Area Specific Plan area. Using the TRAFFIX model, Mr. Kim performed the analysis of transportation impacts at 23 Douglas Kim, AICP Principal Page 8 intersections and four neighborhood roadway segments. The analysis also looked at signal warrant issues associated with unsignalized intersections. § City of Santa Monica, 1131 Arizona Avenue Traffic Study. Mr. Kim managed the analysis of a three-story, 26,796 square-foot skilled nursing facility. The facility would consist of 44 guest rooms accommodating 65 to 69 beds. As shown in Figure 2-10, three types of guest rooms are proposed. The single-occupant private special care rooms would be approximately 304 square feet each; the single occupant private rooms would be available in two floor plans of 245 and 270 square feet, respectively; and the double-occupant semi- private guest rooms would be available in two floor plans of 323 and 394 square feet, respectively. § City of Laguna Beach, Aliso Creek Redevelopment Plan Peer Review. Mr. Kim managed the peer review of a traffic and parking study for proposed redevelopment of a 62-room resort hotel and golf course in the City of Laguna Beach. The project site is challenged by limited ingress/egress from Pacific Coast Highway. Resume Page | 1 ERIN TOMARAS, M.E.M., NATURAL RESOURCE LEAD/PROJECT MANAGER Erin Tomaras has 9 years of experience as a biologist and project manager with a strong background in environmental planning and permitting for energy-related projects in southern and central California. She has managed or supported large-scale utility projects through routing and siting, agency consultation, permitting (including California Environmental Quality Act [CEQA]/National Environmental Policy Act [NEPA] compliance), environmental compliance, and postconstruction restoration. She has prepared numerous environmental impact assessments, biological and aquatic technical reports, aquatic permit applications for the United States (U.S.) Army Corps of Engineers, Regional Water Quality Control Board, and California Department of Fish Wildlife (CDFW), and incidental take permit (ITP) applications for the CDFW and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. SELECTED PROJECT EXPERIENCE (∗ denotes project experience prior to SWCA) ∗Hesperia Phelan; Au Energy; Hesperia, California. This project involved preparation of an Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration (IS/MND) for constructing a vehicle fueling station and convenience store, as well as an ITP application pursuant to the Western Joshua Tree Conservation Act. Role: Project Director. Provided technical guidance and final sign-off for the preparation of the IS/MND and ITP application. ∗Sycamore Canyon 230-kilovolt Loop-In to Suncrest Project; San Diego Gas & Electric Company; San Diego, California. This project involved preparation of an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) and associated technical studies for the installation of a double-circuit 230-kilovolt transmission line and modifications to two existing substations. Role: Project Manager. Oversaw environmental review of the routing study, various biological surveys, and preparation of the draft EIR sections. ∗On-Call Biological Services; San Diego Gas & Electric Company; San Diego County, California. On-call services included conducting biological surveys and monitoring for electrical distribution and gas pipeline projects. Role: Biological Resources Program Manager. Oversaw staffing for biological, aquatic, and nesting bird surveys and biological and aquatic monitoring activities and preparation of associated survey reports. ∗Cleveland National Forest Power Line Replacement Projects; San Diego Gas & Electric Company; San Diego County, California. This project involved preconstruction, construction, and postconstruction tasks associated with wood-to-steel conversion, line relocation, undergrounding, and reconductoring of approximately 150 miles of five 69-kilovolt transmission and six 12-kilovolt distribution lines within and around the Cleveland National Forest. Role: Assistant Project Manager/Biologist. Ensured compliance with mitigation measures and permitting conditions. Prepared aquatic permit applications, preconstruction mitigation compliance plans, and a compensatory mitigation report. Reviewed biological resource reports and managed postconstruction biological surveys and report preparation. ∗Line 85 Elk Hills Road to Lake Station Replacement Project; Southern California Gas Company; Kern County, California. This project involved permitting for the replacement of an approximately 10-mile-long section of an existing natural gas transmission pipeline. Role: Project Manager. Managed the preparation of a Habitat Conservation Plan, CDFW ITP application, and aquatic permitting. ∗Line 85 Lake Station to Grapevine Replacement Project; Southern California Gas Company; Kern County, California. This project involved permitting for the removal of approximately 25 miles of an existing natural gas transmission pipeline and replacement with approximately 21 miles of new pipeline. Role: Project Manager. Oversaw biological and aquatic resource surveys and preparation of associated technical reports. Oversaw the preparation of a Focused High-Level Review, Detailed Environmental Review, and permitting strategy. YEARS OF EXPERIENCE 9 EXPERTISE Routing, siting, and feasibility studies Permitting strategy development Environmental impact assessments Natural resource project and program management Compliance monitoring and management CEQA/NEPA compliance Biological resources reports Wildlife and aquatic permitting EDUCATION M.E.M., Master of Environmental Management; Coastal Environmental Management; Duke University; 2016 B.A., Environmental Studies; m: Marine Biology; University of Washington; 2012 Resume Page | 1 CHRIS MILLINGTON, M.A., RPA, ARCHAEOLOGY PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR Chris Millington is a principal investigator in SWCA’s Pasadena, California, office with 20 years of experience in cultural resources management. His responsibilities include technical oversight, research, project management, agency coordination, authoring cultural resources reports, analyzing spatial data, map production, and graphics. Across his career, Chris has contributed to over 700 compliance-driven projects with SWCA in eight states across the western United States. In the last 11 years, he has focused on projects and research primarily within his native Southern California, including both rural and urban settings. Chris has developed expertise in National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) and California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) compliance, urban archaeology, and Los Angeles history. He regularly collaborates with engineers, construction crews, planners, and attorneys, on both the private and public sides, and is experienced in responding to midstream project design changes, public scrutiny, and unanticipated budget and schedule adjustments. Chris has extensive experience supporting public agencies for tribal consultation under Assembly Bill 52 (AB 52) and regularly conducts desktop sensitivity assessments for archaeological and tribal cultural resources. SELECTED PROJECT EXPERIENCE On-Call Specialty Environmental Services; Los Angeles Department of Public Works (LADPW), Bureau of Engineering (BOE); Los Angeles, California. SWCA has held an on- call specialty environmental services contract with the LADPW BOE since 2006. To date, SWCA has successfully completed 40 projects requiring a range of cultural resources services including historic property surveys, historic structures reports, HABS/HAER, and historic monument nominations; and archaeological surveys, sampling, excavation, monitoring, and analysis. These studies have been conducted for Caltrans local assistance projects, the secondary sewer renewal program, pool and bathhouse renovations, and streetscape improvement projects. Role: Lead Archaeologist and Project Manager. San Bernardino County General Plan; Placeworks; San Bernardino County, California. SWCA conducted cultural and paleontological resources studies supporting Placeworks in their development of a web-based Countywide Plan and preparation of a Program Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for the County of San Bernardino. SWCA provided Native American consultation support, conducted records searches for cultural and paleontological resources to summarize the existing conditions and inform a sensitivity analysis for the plan area. Role: Cultural Resources Specialist. Phase I Archaeological and/or Tribal Cultural Resource Assessment Studies; Private Clients; Los Angeles County, California. SWCA has prepared technical reports assessing archaeological and/or tribal cultural resources on a variety of land development projects within various jurisdictions in Los Angeles County, including the Cities of Los Angeles, Lomita, Lancaster, Palmdale, and Santa Monica. The projects include single-family home remodeling, mixed-use, and multifamily residential projects in suburban neighborhoods, industrial developments, and high-rise tower construction in dense urban settings. The technical studies were conducted by SWCA to inform various types of regulatory compliance documents, primarily pursuant to CEQA, but also supporting due diligence efforts where a project was found to meet CEQA exemption criteria. Each of the Phase I technical studies prepared included extensive archival research, ethnographic literature review, a cultural resources records search of the California Historical Resources Information System, and a Sacred Lands File search, which were used to establish whether an archaeological or tribal cultural resource is present or the likelihood such a resource may be present within a given project site. SWCA has completed studies for over 50 individual projects since 2017. Role: Project Manager and author/co-author. YEARS OF EXPERIENCE 20 EXPERTISE Southern California history and archaeology NEPA, NHPA, and CEQA compliance Tribal consultation, AB 52 compliance Archival research Predictive modeling, data analytics, graphic design, cartography EDUCATION M.A., Archaeology; University of New Mexico; 2006 B.A., summa cum laude, Anthropology; University of New Mexico; 2004 REGISTRATION / CERTIFICATIONS Registered Prof. Archaeologist No. 32790536; 2015 Meets and exceeds requirements in the Secretary of the Interior’s Professional Qualification Standards in Archeology and Historic Archeology BLM Permit, Field Director; CA, CO, ND, SD, WY, UT Resume Page | 1 HEATHER CLIFFORD, M.S. PALEONTOLOGY SUBJECT MATTER EXPERT / PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR / TEAM LEAD Heather Clifford is a Senior Paleontological Resources Team Lead with 12 years of experience in the environmental consulting industry, serving variously as project manager, subject matter expert, and team lead in support of projects throughout California. She is a geologist and paleontologist with experience completing and directing paleontology work throughout California and Nevada. She has successfully completed paleontological resource management projects involving paleontological assessments, data recovery, curation preparation, and paleontological efforts. As a Paleontology Principal Investigator and Subject Matter Expert, she routinely directs paleontological field surveys and inventories, mitigation monitoring of construction, third-party review, preparation of reports and document sections, fossil salvage and collection, laboratory preparation and analysis of micro- and macrofossils, and technical reporting. SELECTED PROJECT EXPERIENCE 12500 Riverside Drive Project, 12500 Riverside Drive, LLC, Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, California. The project proposes to construct a new 5- story building for residential and commercial uses and includes two levels of subterranean parking. Role: Paleontologist. Evaluating project impacts on paleontological resources in accordance with CEQA. Conducted the appropriate background research, including reviewing the plans for the project, looking at geologic maps, poring through paleontological and geologic literature, reviewing the results of a fossil locality search through the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County, and finally making mitigation recommendations. SRM Westchester Project, SRMWestchester, LLC, Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, California. The project proposes to construct two new residential buildings as part of a senior citizen housing facility. Role: Paleontologist. Evaluating project impacts on paleontological resources in accordance with CEQA. Conducted the appropriate background research, including reviewing the plans for the project, looking at geologic maps, poring through paleontological and geologic literature, reviewing the results of a fossil locality search through the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County, and finally making mitigation recommendations. Wilshire and Barrington Land Development Project, Century Investments, LLC, Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, California. The project proposes to demolish the existing surface parking lot and strip mall and replace it with a new high-rise building and two levels of subterranean parking. Role: Paleontologist. Evaluating project impacts on paleontological resources in accordance with CEQA. Conducted the appropriate background research, including reviewing the plans for the project, looking at geologic maps, poring through paleontological and geologic literature, reviewing the results of a fossil locality search through the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County, and finally making mitigation recommendations. Wilmington Greening Project; City of Los Angeles Department of Public Works Bureau of Engineering; City of Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, California. Provided senior oversight and quality control for the paleontological resources technical report prepared in support for the project. Role: Senior Paleontologist. La Brea Tar Pits Master Plan EIR; Los Angeles County Museum of Natural History; Los Angeles County, California. SWCA is preparing an EIR addressing the environmental impacts of significant improvements to this iconic fossiliferous site in central Los Angeles. Role: Senior Paleontology Team Lead. Provided paleontological scope review and updates. YEARS OF EXPERIENCE 12 EXPERTISE CEQA compliance Project management Paleontological resources Geology of California EDUCATION B.A., Art, San Francisco State University M.S., Geology, California State University, Los Angeles BLM PERMITS Principal Investigator, California Statewide BLM Paleontological Permit MEMBERSHIPS Member, Geological Society of America