HomeMy WebLinkAbout05/09/1994Cit (
COAA,tcl AGENDA
Monday., May 9, 1994
6:00 P.M.
Adjourned Regular Meeting
South Coast Air Quality Management District
Auditorium
21865 East Copley Drive
Diamond Bar, California
Mayor
Mayor Pro Tem
Council Member
Council Member
Counci t Member
City Manager
Interim City Attorney
City Clerk
Gary H. Werner
Clair W. Harmony
Eileen R. Ansari
Phyllis E. Papen
Gary G. Miller
Terrence L. Belanger
Michael Montgomery
Lynda Burgess
of staff reports, or other written documentation relating to agendate safile ag nda office
of the
Copies Po inspection. If you have quregarding
City Clerk, and are available for public insp
please contact the City Clerk at (909) 860-2489 during regular business hours.
In an effort to comply with the requirements of Title II of the Americans
with
Disabilities equipment, assistance of an� or
the City of Diamond Bar requires that any person in need of any type must inform the City Clerk
accommodation(s) in order to communicate at a City public meeting,
a .minimum of 72 hours prior to the scheduled meeting.
Please refrain from smoking, eating or drinking
in the Council Chambers.
The City of Diamond Bar uses rec sled paper
and encourages you to do the same.
1.
r7.1
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Next Resolution No. 94-21
Next Ordinance No. 03(1994)
CALL TO ORDER: 6:00 p.m.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: Mayor Werner
ROLL CALL: Council Members Ansari, Papen,
Miller, Mayor Pro Tem Harmony
and Mayor Werner
SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS, PROCLAMATIONS,
CERTIFICATES, ETC.:
CLOS
PUBLIC COMMENTS: CLOSED
COUNCIL COMMENTS: CLOSED
SCHEDULE OF FUTURE EVENTS: CLOSED
CONSENT CALENDAR: CLOSED
PUBLIC HEARINGS: NONE
OLD BUSINESS:
8.1 SECOND READING OF ORDINANCE NO. 02(1994): AN ORDINANCE
OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DIAMOND BAR AMENDING
TITLE 22 OF THE LOS ANGELES CODE BY ADDING NEW CHAPTER
22.54 AND ESTABLISHING PROPERTY MAINTENANCE STANDARDS -
On April 19, 1994, the City Council held a public
and
hearing, received testimony, waived full reading,
approved as amended, Ordinance No. 02(1994). Continued
from May 3, 1994.
Recommended Action: It is recommended that the City
Council approve for second reading and adopt Ordinance
No. 02(1994).
Requested by: Community Development Director
8.2 ENGINEERING SERVICES CONTRACT FOR THE DEVELOPMENT AND
IMPLEMENTATION OF A PAVEMENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM - In
accordance with the requirements of Prop. 111 for State
Gas Tax Fund and the criteria stipulated by the Prop. C
Local Return Guidelines, local jurisdictions must certify
that it has in place a pavement management system (PMS).
This is to foster the cost-effective use of public funds
prior to expending Prop. C funds. The system needs to
provide an overview of the condition of the total street
MAY 9, 1994 PAGE 2
system, a means of documenting street maintenance/
rehabilitation needs, and a means of rationally
prioritizing street improvement projects in terms of
needs and cost-effectiveness. To accomplish this work,
it is necessary to retain the services of a qualified
engineering firm. In response to the City's Request
for Proposal, the Selection Committee received and
evaluated four (4) proposals.
Recommended Action: It is recommended that the City
Council award a professional engineering services
contract to Dwight French and Associates in an amount not
to exceed $37,020.00, plus a contingency amount of
$3,000.
Requested by: City Engineer
8.3 DISCUSSION RE: COUNCIL SUB -COMMITTEE FOR LIBRARY
SERVICES - Continued from May 3, 1994.
Recommended Action: It is recommended that the Mayor
appoint a Library Services sub -committee of the City
Council, comprised of two members of the Council.
Requested by: Councilwoman Ansari
8.4 MATTER OF REQUEST FOR INFORMATION FROM FORMER CITY
ATTORNEY - Continued from May 3, 1994.
Requested by: Mayor Pro Tem Harmony
9. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING/CITY COUNCIL & PLANNING COMMISSION
JOINT MEETING - 7:00 P.M.
9.1 DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT NOS. 92-1 AND 2; VESTING TENTATIVE
TRACT MAP NO. 514071 CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-8;
AND OAK TREE PERMIT NO. 92-8; VESTING TENTATIVE TRACT MAP
32400, CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 91-5, AND OAK TREE
PERMIT NO. 91-2; TENTATIVE TRACT MAP NO. 51253 AND
CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-12; OAK TREE PERMIT NO.
92-9; THE SOUTH POINTE MASTER PLAN; AND ENVIRONMENTAL
IMPACT REPORT NO. 92-1 - This is a joint public hearing
of the City Council and Planning Commission to consider
a request for approval of a mixed use project, known as
South Pointe Master Plan, consisting of land uses which
include residential, commercial, park, open space and
school facilities. The project site is approximately 171
acres in size and is located north of Pathfinder Rd.,
west of Brea Canyon Rd., east of Morning Sun Dr., and
south of Rapid View Dr. The project proposes to develop
30 acres of commercial retail/office space of 290,000 sq.
ft.; approximately 200 single-family detached residential
dwelling units, a 28 acre neighborhood park; and the
construction of a middle school. Continued from May 2,
1994.
MAY 9, 1994 PAGE 3
1994.
Recommended Action: It is recommended that the City
Council and Planning Commission receive a presentation
from City Staff and project developers; open the public
hearing; receive testimony; and take appropriate action.
Requested by: M/Werner
10. ANNOUNCEMENTS:
11. ADJOURNMENT:
CITY OF DIAMOND BAR
AGENDA REPORT AGENDA NO.
TO: Terrence L. Belanger, City Manager
MEETING DATE: May 3, 1994 REPORT DATE: April 26, 1994
FROM: James DeStefano, Community Development Director
TITLE: Second Reading of Ordinance No. 2 (1994), an ordinance amending Title 22 of the Los Angeles
County Code by adding a new Chapter 22.54 and establishing property maintenance standards (Zone Code
Amendment No. 93-3).
SUMMARY: On April 19, 1994, the City Council held a public hearing, received testimony, waived first
reading, and approved as amended, Ordinance No. 2 (1994).
RECOMMENDATION: It is recommended that the City Council approve second reading and adopt Ordinance
No. 2 (1994) entitled: AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DIAMOND BAR
AMENDING TITLE 22 OF THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY CODE BY ADDING A NEW CHAPTER 22.54
AND ESTABLISHING PROPERTY MAINTENANCE STANDARDS.
LIST OF ATTACHMENTS:_ Staff Report
Resolution(s)
X Ordinances(s)
Agreement(s)
Other
EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION: None
_ Public Hearing Notification
_ Bid Specification (on file in City Clerk's Office)
SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST:
1.
Has the resolution, ordinance or agreement been reviewed
X Yes _ No
by the City Attorney?
2.
Does the report require a majority or 4/5 vote?
MAJORITY
3.
Has environmental impact been assessed?
X Yes _ No
4.
Has the report been reviewed by a Commission?
_ Yes X No
Which Commission?
5.
Are other departments affected by the report?
_ Yes X No
Report discussed with the following affected departments:
EWED B
Terrence L. Belanger Frank Usher es DeStefano
City Manager Assistant City Manager Community Devel pment Director
PLANNING
COMMISSION
AGENDA
MAY 99 1994
7:00 P.M.
South Coast Air Quality Management District
Auditorium
21865 East Copley. Drive
Diamond Bar, California
Chairman
Vice Chairwoman
Commissioner
Commissioner
Commissioner
David Meyer
Lydia Plunk
Bruce Flamenbaum
Don Schad
Franklin Fong
Copies of staff reports or other written documentation relating to agenda items are on file in the Community
Development Office, located at 21660 E. Copley Drive, Suite 190, and are available for public inspection.
If you have questions regarding an agenda item, please call (909) 396-5676 during regular business hours.
In an effort to comply with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, the
City of Diamond Bar requires that any person in need of any type of special equipment, assistance or
accomodation(s) in order to communicate at a City public meeting must inform the Community
Development Department at (909) 396-5676 a minimum of 72 hours prior to the scheduled meeting.
Please refrain from smoking, eating or drinJ
in the Auditorium
'he City of Diamond Bar uses recycled paper
and encourages you to do the same.
CITY OF DIAMOND BAR
PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA Next Resolution No. 94-5
March A 1994
CALL TO ORDER: 7:00 P.M.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
COMMISSIONERS: Chairman David Meyer,
ROLL CALL: Vice Chairwoman
Lydia Plunk, Bruce Flamenbaum, Don Schad and Franklin Fong
MATTERS FROM THE AUDIENCE/PUBLIC COMMENTS:
lace for the general public to address the members of the Planning Commis -
This is the time and pOpportunityto speak on
sion on any item that is within their jurisdiction, msacomnlete a public Card for the recordin
non-public hearing and non -agenda i r ve m n„te maximum time limit
The e is a f
Len addressin the Plannin Commission.
sidered
CONSENT CALENDAR: The following items listed on the consentde removed from
routine and are approved by single iotionlyConsent Galen
the agenda by request of
1. Minutes of March 14, 1994
OLD BUSINESS: None
NEW BUSINESS: None
CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING:
Zone Change N.92-2, Vesting Tentative Map
an Environmental
2. ConditionalUse
oPermit No. 92-3, Oak Tree Permit No. 9 ,
Report No. 92-2. Continued from December 13, 1993.
ily
The proposed project is a request for applocated at the southeasterly troval of a 13 unit single erminous
subdivision proposed on a 20 acre site 1 ro osed project is located
of Blaze Trail Drive within "The iCountry". ihehnorthernmo p portion of Signif-
adjacent to Tonner Canyon a
icant Ecological Area No. 15. The application requests involve a Zone
1
Planning Commission Agenda
March 28, 1994
Page Two
Change from A-2-2, Heavy Agriculture to R-1-40,000, Single Family Resi-
dential, one acre minimum lot size, a subdivision of the site into 14 lots (13
dwelling units and a common lot for a sewer pump station), an Oak Tree
Permit for the removal of one oak tree, a Conditional Use Permit for devel-
opment in a hillside management area, and a Draft Environmental Impact
Report which has been prepared to evaluate the impacts the project may
have upon the environment and identification of mitigation measures to
reduce the effects of any negative impacts.
Property Owner and Applicant: Unionwide, Inc., 2130 Rockridge Ct.,
Fullerton, CA. 92631
RECOMMENDATION:
continued for 30-45 days.
PLANNING COMMISSION ITEMS:
Staff recommends that the public hearing be
INFORMATIONAL ITEMS: Verbal report on General Plan Advisory Committee progress.
ADJOURNMENT: April 11, 1994
DATE 05-09_94
INVALID
MILLER YES
HARMONY NO
ANSARI YES
PAPEN YES
WERNER No
INVALID
INVALID
INVALID
INVALID
INVALID
TOTALS ,
TIME 17:48:22 AGENDA ITEM if
THIS AGENDA ITEM HAS -
(MOTION)
INVALID
3 2 0
L
Qt d, a
BOARD MEETINGL- �
Maker-
Second-
3
akerSecond:
L
DATE 05-09-94 TIME 17:57:33 AGENDA ITEM # 8.1- drh q r dm e Oct 40
INVALID
INVALID
MILLER YES
HARMONY NO
ANSARI YES
PAPEN NO
WERNER YES
INVALID
INVALID
INVALID
INVALID
INVALID
TOTALS . . . . . . . 3 2 0
BOARD MEETING: S/9/9
Maker. r /
Second: a,�ef- /lam
THIS AGENDA ITEM HAS ------------- P --ss
ed -
(MOTION)
L
DATE 05--09-94 _ TIME 18:19:00 AGENDA ITEM g2 i1 `
� Yle-&�t- t rL� � ��Q
�
INVALID 0 rt
INVALID
MILLER YES
HARMONY YES
ANSARI YES
PAPEN YES
WERNER YES
INVALID
INVALID
INVALID
INVALID
INVALID
TOTALS . 5 0 0
THIS AGENDA ITEM HAS -------------'>
(MOTION)
BOARD MEETING: -5j5fq �I
Maker.__
Second: r n n ca
DATE 05-09-94
INVALID
L
TIME 18:20:12 AGENDA ITEM # p4f -6
MILLER YES
HARMONY YES
ANSARI YES
PAPEN YES
WERNER YES
INVALID
INVALID
INVALID
INVALID
INVALID
TOTALS . . . . . . .
INVALID
BOARD MEETING::—,.:!--,/
5 0 0
Maker:�Q r
Second: 9�-D�
(4-1-3 S elot-
THIS AGENDA ITEM HAS ------------- QED
(MOTION)
,sic, /q 4
�a,y"R - 3,=)- 1 i ��.
-10�
7Wal 3
6,
� F,
- �J
5 -DL -
e
tea. 1h -para -
�I
TO:
FROM:
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
CITY CLERK
� DATE:
-/ PHONE: S g�S S3
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Signature
NOTE: ALL PERSONS MAY ATTEND MEETINGS AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL. THIS FORM IS
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda ite
name and address as written above.
m. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
D
TO:
FROM:
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION:
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
CITY CLERK
DATE:
PHONE:
j
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect m
name and address as written above.
J-
Sign ure
Y I_I J-1 ___ �.__. _____ 1 .:;J I'1 1 . I'1 _____J... v __ u �_ •-__
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PER CINI DES RING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upcn recognition from -:he Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
aroceed to commen': upon the age -da item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote the Mayor will re--ognize eny member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welccrme to attend all City C_:ouncil meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
Those who wish to speak on agenda subjects scheduled as public hearings or
discussions may complete voluntary Speaker's Cards at the desk of the City Clerk.
Council rules call for each speaker to limit remarks to five (5) minutes.
The audience is requested to be seated in the Council Chambers. Standing or
obstructing of aisles is prohibited.
Thank you
D
TO:
FROM:
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
CITY CLERK
LARRY L�2�1� 1 NC E(L DATE:
2 M 14 9q
PHONE: F6/ -x( }03
WRLNvT- VAc c.r= i ll ►NI FrD SC Hc7O� (�rs%72(t7�
�L
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Signature
_hel =L Y _ J
DRESS THE
MINUUS
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon Irecognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address a')d
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to audiendcie who wishes togspeak onlothe suubjectn and r, 1-c. a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO: CITY CLERK 4
DATE:
2
FROM: x'133 4
ADDRESS:
RU/1 lid PHONE:
ORGANIZATION:
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
flect my
I ex ect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes re
p
name and address as written above.
4gn ature
NOTE: ALL PERSONS MAY ATTEND MEETINGS AND ADDRESS THE CITY
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRES.;_THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUT1=;i.
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and addre�;s ;and
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior Ic a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public busir esE
is appreciated.
VOLUNTARY REQUE
ST TO ADDRESS THE CITY CU �, �j ., , -
DI*
TO
FROM'
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION:
AGENDA #ISUBJECT
CITY CLERK
[)ATE
PHONE 9G
subject agenda item. Please
have the Council Minutes reteCt mY
i expect to add ereCouncil on the
as Written above.
name and addres
Signature
NOTE ALL PERSONS MAY ATTEND MEETINGS AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL THIS FORM IS
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welcome to atLend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO: CITY CLERK
FROM: ati� �i��2 / L DATE:
ADDRESS: z7�� �%iy� �— PHONE:
ORGANIZATION:
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
I expect to address the Council on the s sect ag nda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Sig
-- ----- — ` — o - H'W•-) ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL. THIS FORM IS
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR' IN _ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PERSON DESIRIN TO ADDRESS_THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recognition from the Mayor, p ease %va c to the microphone and state your name and address and
proceed to comment upon the agenda iterr you wis" to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any riemoer ;)1: the Eudience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
Those who wish to speak on agenda subjects scheduled as public hearings or
discussions may complete voluntary Speaker's Cards at the desk of the City Clerk.
Council rules call for each speaker to lirnit,remarks to five (5) minutes.
The audience is requested to be seated in the Council Chambers. Standing or
obstructing of aisles is prohibited.
Thank you
�79
TO:
FROM:
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION:
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
CITY CLERK n
DATE:
PHONE: 909 714
V
AGENDA #/SUBJECT: � f�.c�
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Aw/-�
Signature
NOTE: ALL PERSONS MAY ATTEND MEETINGS �a �_ ��--- - -
TOAPERS N
THE MAYOR IN ENSURING "_HAr ALL LING OF NAME
N N THE MINUTE—SI^
INTENDED RECOGNIZED AND TO EIRE �P-RECT SPE
COUNCIL ARE
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO yUDRE`.�S T_y COUNCIL
lease walk to tl i�� microphone and state your name oand n and prior tc► a
ss vid
Upon recognition from the Mayor, p discuss
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you of the i, ,h to discu who w shes tospeakon the subject.
vote, the Mayor will recognize any mem
berYou are welcome to attend all City Council meetincl:; anci your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
Those who wish to speak on agenda subjects s chCaedslaathe desk oftf
11 discussions may complete voluntary Spea
Council rules call for each speaker to limit remarks to five (5) minutes
The
audience is requested to be seated in the Council Chambers. Sti
obstructing of aisles is prohibited,
Thank you
D
TO:
FROM:
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION:
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
rck tD mom.
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Signalure
NOTE ALL PERSONS MAY ATTEND MEETINGS AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL. THIS FORM IS
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
'TO: CITY CLERK
FROM:ti�' c� C DATE:
ADDRESS: 13.z t5",X,-
PHONE:Cp%
ORGANIZATION:
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Signature
HIV T F I >>vv. • ---
and
Upon recognitionand
s. Following
from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state y°discuss on and prior to a
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to discus
vote, the Mayor
will recognize any member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
r�
TO:
FROM:
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION:
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
CITY CLERK f
c,\_ \ DATE: 5 C
lit �v��� PHONE: -S-(I'
Zl�%
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Si ature
NOTE: ALL PERSONS MAY ATTEND MEETINGS AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL. THIS FORM IS
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
TO:
FROM:
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION:
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
CITY CLERK
of
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
DATE:
L'P— PHONE: ((t4f- )%:
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Signature
NOTE: ALL PERSONS MAY ATTEND MEETINGS AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL. THIS FORM IS
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the audience who wis,hes to speak on the subject.
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
es call for each speak
or
r 'Clerk.'
The audience is requested to be seated in the Council>Chambers. Standing or
obstructing of aisles is prohibited.
Thank you
To:
FRC .4:
ADC iE:SS:
ORC ftZATION:
AGE DA #/SUBJECT:
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
CITY CLERK
DATE:
I expe:;t to address the Council on the subject agenda item
name end address as written above.
Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
Signature
_T_1=LADED TO ASSIST THE MAYORrIN t�iV,�URING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHI
�(S AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL. THIS FORM I;
ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO EIVSiJ_IJE C RRECT SPELLING nF NennEc IN THE MINUTES
ANY PERSON [)ES1iNCJ TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recognition from the Mayor, pl&ase vrE IN: to the microphone and state your name and address and
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
p
vore, the Mayor will recognize any mern:�E r of the audience who wishes to speak on
You are welcome to attend all City Council rr-E�,� the subject.
is appreciated. tangs and your interest in the conduct of public business
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO:
FROM:
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION:
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
CITY CLERK
n DATE:
PHONE:
r
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Signature
NOTE: ALL PERSONS MAY ATTEND MEETINGS AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL. THIS FORM IS
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
Those who wish to speak on agenda subjects schedc
discussions may complete voluntary Speaker's Cards'
rk'.
I T TO ADDRESS VOLUNTARY REQUEST ESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO: CITY CLERK
FROM:
co
DATE:
Ll -
ADDRESS: `
�' �' �44
� PHONE:
ORGANIZATION:
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect m
name and address as written above. y
i��'Sign
NOTE: ALL PERSONS MAY ATTEND MEETINGS AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL. THIS FORM IS
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO:
FROM:
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION:
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
CITY CLERK
DATE:
r7"P✓1 t<1E D 2 PHONE:o
17 < rt-- 12 16 10 AJ F -Em VA. L
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Signature
ANY PER ON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
U on recognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
P
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish ie die who wishes to speak on the sablectr prioo a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the and
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO: CITY CLERK
FROM: C A e) -m) DATE: —`O 9
ADDRESS: ���� L::nSJ �e.� PHONE: ly"
ORGANIZATION:eS;�@r
AGENDA WSUBJECT: til
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
ignature
NOTE• ALL PERSONS MAY ATTEND MEETINGS AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL. THIS FORM IS
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES..
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
Those who wish to 'speak on agenda subjects scheduled as public hearings or
discussions may completevoluntary' Speaker's Cards at the desk of the City Clerk.
Council rules call for each speaker to limit remarks to five (5) minutes,
The audience is requested to be seated in the Council Chambers. 'Standing or°
obstructing ofaisles is prohibited.
Thank you
To
FROM:
ADE. RESS:
ORCiANIZATION:
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
CITY CLERK
DATE:
<
PHONE: 8G p
A /6,
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
'---'= U ASSIST THE MAYORrIN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WI
_%'',35 AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL. THIS FORM I;
COUNCIL Q 4E RECOGNIZED QND T ENSURE C RRECT SPEL
IN OF NAM A?JINN HE M N ul IV ESS THI
ANY PERSON DESi_R!Nc i TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUN UTES.
r on recognition from the Mayor, please vial to the microphone CIL
proca,?tl .�, cDmment upon the agenda itern you wish to discuss.
P e and state your name and address and
vote, -fie Ma vor will recognize an cuss. Following discussion and prior to a
y member c f the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are "IE-lco�me to attend all City Council -neetin s
is appreciatec 9 and your interest in the conduct of public business
r
TO:
FROM:
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION:
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
CITY CLERK
DATE:
PHONE:
AGENDA #/SUBJECT: [,�'. I !� a `j :� `� A' i i CN
-e iT C, v/4
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Signature
N
ANY PERSON DESI"►►�u our name and address and
hone and state y prior to a
lease walk to the microphone discussion and
recognition from the Mayor, p you wish to discuss. Following subject.
Upon recog agenda item Y
proceed to comment upon the a9 ember of the audience who wishes to speak on the subl
pro recognize any m
vote, the Mayor will recog public business
City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of
You are welcome to attend all C y
is appreciated.
)t VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO CITY CLERK
FROM: DATE:
--------------
/kDE,RE.-'SS:
ORCIANIZATION: PHONE:
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council
name and address as written above. Minutes reflect my
Sig ature
\
ANY PERSON �� �our name and address and
lease walk to the microphone and state discussion and prior to a
Upon recognition from the Mayor, p You wish to discuss. Following
proceed to comment upon the agenda item
member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
vote, the Mayor will recognize any
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your in
in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO:
CITY CLERK
FRC
ADC ESS: DATE:
OR& NIZATION.- L PHONE:/
AGED, DA #/SUBJECT:
I expec, to address the Council on the subject agenda item
name and address as written above.
Please have the Council Minutes reflect ,
NOTE: ALL PERSONS MAY ATTEND MEETINGS AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL. THIS FORM IS
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO
FROM:
ADI )RESS:
OR( aANIZATION:
AGE NDA #/SUBJECT:
CITY CLERK
DATE: — _ l 4
PHONE±/ _3 (5- �
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
namf� and address as written above.
nature
S()NS WISHING TO ADDRESS T
NC OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PER a3ON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE Q --Q CO_ UNCIL
discussion and prior to a
Upon recognition from
the Mayor, please walk to the microphone ;ani state your name and address an
r of the audience who W shes to speak on the subject.
proceed to comment upon the agenda itee You wish to discuss. F of own
P member vote, the Mayor will recognize any public business
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interCit in the conduct of p
is appreciated.
he desk of the City Clerk.
who wish to speak on agenda subjects sched� ladt s public hearings or
Those vv complete voluntary, Speakers Card
discussions may comp
limit remarks t,-, five (5) minutes.
Council rules call for each speaker to
d in the Council Chambers. Standing or
The audience is requested to be seate
obstructing of aisles is prohibited.
Thank you
4*VOLUNTARYREQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO CITY CLERK
FR( M: Gl� ' /l U-
y� b LAI DATE.ADC RE=SS: ���-k% 1� JDIIC�rp, PHONE: —L440
OR, �ANIZATION:
AGE NDA #/SUBJECT:
I exPect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
S ature
NOTE: ALL PERSONS MAY ATTEND MEETINGS AND AQvr E66 ____.._ 1 -+ - = y
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PEFI:iONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE RECOGNIZED AND TO ENSURE C_ RRRECT SPELLIN-" OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDREaS-THE -1 -Y _OUNCII_
Upon recognition from the Mayor, please walk to the microphone end stEle your name and address and
proceed to comment upon the agenda item you wish to clisc:uss. F ollo sling disc, assion and prior to a
vote, the Mayor will recognize any member of the audience who nrishe:; to speak. on the subject.
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and yon interE!st in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
Those who wish to speak on agenda subjects scheduled as public hearings or
discussions may complete voluntary Speaker's Cards'i3t the desk' of the City Clerk.
Council rules call for each speaker to limit remarks to five 451 minutes.
The audience is requested to be seated in the Counc;il Chambers: Standing or
obstructing ofaisles is prohibited.
Thank you
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO: CITY CLERK
DATE:
FROM:
PHONE: Y6,0
ADDRE
ORGANIZATION: —
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
n �
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Signature
NOTE: ALL PERSO Na DA 7 '"' ' "'— IN THE MINUTES.
INTENDED TO ASSIST THE MAYLING
TO ENSURE ENSURING ORRECT SPELLING OF NAME
CO NCIL ARE RE OGNIZE�
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNC�_l, dress and
narne and
m the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state Y°discussion and prior to a
Upon recognition
from ou wish to discuss. Following
proceed to comment upon the agenda item y
any member of the audience who wishes to spea< on the subject.
vote, the Mayor will recognize
all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
You are welcome to attend
is appreciated.
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO: CITY CLERK
n �
DATE: 3 r
FROM:�-------------
>
PHONE:
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION:
AGENDA #/SUBJECT:
p
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
------------
Signature
- ::- - =.=-- r A ___�J MEETINGS AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL THIS FORM IS
INTENDED TO_-fkSSI!;T THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE_EiECCOOZED Nil) TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES
AIJY PER-;QI\I DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upor reccc!n t c from the Mayr, pl=ase walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
p,oceed to cO r meat upon the aciE,nda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the !Vlayo- veil recognize any rnember of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You are welco-ne to attend all Ci-), Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated,
Those \nrho wish to speak on agenda subjects scheduled as public hearings or
discussions may complete voluntary' Speaker's Cards at the desk of the City Clerk.
Co„ncil rules call for each speaker to limit remarks to five (5) minutes.
The aud'ence is requested to be seated in the Council Chambers. Standing or
obstructinc of aisles is prohibited.
Thank you
ARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
TO:
7y CLERK
FARC /l:
ADC iESS: / DATE:
CRG +NIZATION:
AGE[ DA #/SUBJECT: --�
I expe( t to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please
have the Council Minutes reflect my
name rind address as written above.
C%
_.__ _ Signature
I __: MAY ATTEND MEETINGS AND ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL. THIS FORM IS
INTI_NDEU TO ASSIST THE MAYOR IN ENSURING THAT ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
UOUNCIL ARE_ET OGNIZED AND TO ENSURE CORRECT SPELLING OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PERSON DESIRING TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
Upon recocn t.cn frorn the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state your name and address and
procE!ed to c orrment upon the agenda item you wish to discuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the N a,ror will recognize any member of the audience who wishes to speak on the subject.
You ere we come to attend all City Council meetings and your interest in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
/l / ///� G��
��j_/� Y
! ,7
// V ��'� � //��.w' p/// (JT/✓
���l/W � / , ���
���' +
��'����z ��
To
f=Rom.-
ADDRESS:
ORGANIZATION:
AGENDA #/SUBJECT.
VOLUNTARY REQUEST TO ADDRESS THE CITY COUNCIL
CITY CLERK
DATE: S— Z CI
Z!� o
PHONE: 6-6' o? /Z c
I expect to address the Council on the subject agenda item. Please
have the Council Minutes reflect my
name and address as written above.
Signature .
NOTE: A-- '_-i6U %o a Ar A --z � �' V z ��jo A 1_' 0-►.'.1-,zoo - _ r „ � - --') =-=°-=
_NTENDED TC_4SS ST THE MAVCIP= IIV _ENSURING THAT NLI_ PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE
COUNCIL ARE_RECZIGNIZED AND TO E N-SLIFIE COl3RECT SWELLING_ OF NAMES IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PER'31_ Pl _=)E c RING TO p,l_1DRl:—'SS :THE I1 -Y (,_OUNCtlI,
Upon recognition'rom Jie Mayor, plessE� wNE!k to th3 mic�cph:)ne and state your rarre and address and
oroceed to commen" upon the Ei(je, da iteri you wish to c iscuss. Following discussion and prior to a
vote, the MEyor vr�ll re--ognize E:ri), ITIff-ter of the ,3udieice who wishes to spea< on the subject.
You are welccrie to attend all City 1::ouncil nlCetings and YOU' interes`: in the conduct of public business
is appreciated.
Those who wish :c spl3a< on agenda s-bjec:ts scheduled as public hearings or
discussions may complete vo untary Speak pr's Cards at the desk of the City Clerk.
Council rules call fa~EAcn speaker to irnit re-na-ks to five (5)minutes.
The audience is requested to be seated in tha Council Chambers. Standing or
obstructing of aisles is porn bited.
Thank ycu
I�
TO CITY CLERK
c- z5x�, \ DATE:
ADORE -SS: PHONE: U /—lY�O.►
ORUANI TION:
AGE # U BJ EPT:
I expect to ess the Council on th se ubject--age.Ada item. Please havet e Ooafr-il_Minutes reflect my
name and address above. --
Signature
)NS WIIS HIN TO ADDRESS T
OF NAME IN THE MINUTES.
ANY PERSON DESIRING T ADDRESS THE C`:fr name and Y GOUN IL address and
Upon recognition from
the Mayor, please walk to the microphone and state yodiscuss on and prior to a
r of the audience who w shE:s to speak on the subject.
proceed to comment upon the agenda itbe you wish to discuss. Fof c,win
vote, the Mayor will recognize any mem public business
You are welcome to attend all City Council meetings and your interE:st in the conduct of
is appreciated.
desk' of the City Clerk.
' ish to speak on agenda subjects scheduled he public hearings or
Those who vv Baker s Cards a
discussions may complete voluntary Sp
C;ounc
it rules call for each speaker to limit remarks to five 151 minutes.`
d to be seated in the Council Chambers. Standing or
The audience is requeste
obstructing of aisles is prohibited.
Thank you
ORDINANCE NO. 2 (1994)
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY
OF DIAMOND BAR AMENDING TITLE 22 OF THE LOS
ANGELES COUNTY CODE BY ADDING A NEW CHAPTER
22.54 AND ESTABLISHING PROPERTY MAINTENANCE
STANDARDS.
A. Recitals.
(i) On April 18, 1989, the City of Diamond Bar was
established as a duly organized municipal corporation of the
State of California and, on that date, the City Council adopted,
by reference, the Los Angeles County Code as the ordinances of
the City, including Title 22 thereof, pertaining to Planning and
Zoning Regulations for the City of Diamond Bar.
(ii) The Planning Commission of the City of Diamond
Bar has heretofore conducted and concluded a duly noticed public
hearing, as required by law, and has recommended the adoption of
the Ordinance set forth below.
(iii) The City Council of the City of Diamond Bar has
heretofore conducted and concluded a duly noticed public hearing,
as required by law, with respect to the adoption of this
Ordinance.
(iv) All legal prerequisites to the adoption of this
Ordinance have occurred.
B. Ordinance.
The City of Diamond Bar does ordain as follows:
Section 1. In all respects as set forth in the
Recitals, part A, of this Ordinance.
May 2, 1994
Changes appear as follows:
StriketAs from 4119M City Couneil Meeting
Additions from 4119194 CYty Council Meeting
Seams n 2. The City Council hereby finds and
teg
orically
determines that the adoption of this Ordinance is ca
exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental
Quality Act of 1970, as amended, and the Guidelines promulgated
thereunder pursuant to Section 15305 of Division 6 of Title 14 of
the California Code of Regulations. added to
Section 3. A new Chapter 22.54 is hereby
Title 22
of the Los Angeles County Code as amended & adopted by
the City, to read, in words and figures, as follows:
"Chapter 22.54
pROpERTY MAINTENANCE STANDARDS
Parts:
I.
purpose and Intent
2.
Definitions Standards
Single -Family
3.
4.
Multifamily Standards
5.
Commercial Standards
6.
Industrial Standards
7.
Abatement Procedures
Part 1
pURPOSE AND INTENT
Sections:
22.54.010 Purpose and Intent
The lack of property maintenance contributes to the
deterioration of residential, commercial and industrial
properties, including structures, landscaping
and improvements
thereon, and a resulting decline in property values within the
t of Diamond Bar. Such deterioration may lead to an overall
Ci y
decline of aesthetic quality within the City including the
quality of the appearance of residential, commercial and
conditions of
industrial neighborhoods. Further, deteriorating
2
May 2, 1994
property may contribute to the creation of conditions adverse to
the public health, safety and welfare.
Establishing property maintenance standards,
through the adoption of this Ordinance,
will serve to preserve
and improve the overall condition of properties and structures in
the City of Diamond Bar, and will further serve to minimize the
creation of conditions which pose a risk to the public health,
safety and welfare.
It is the intent of the City Council of the City of
Diamond Bar, in adopting this ordinance,
to be sensitive to
the needs of financially and/or physically disadvantaged
residents, while concurrently providing a useful property
maintenance enforcement tool to be utilized when notification of
responsible parties and attempts to prevent or eliminate the
conditions described herein have proven ineffective.
Part 2
DEFINITIONS
sections:
22.54.020 Purpose
22.54.030 Nuisances in General
22.54.040 Public Nuisance
22.54.050 Nuisance Per Se
22.54.060 Commercial Vehicles
22.54.070 Driveway
22.54.080 Yard
22.54.020 Purpose
For the purposes of this chapter, and in addition to
the definitions set forth in the previous chapters of this code,
certain terms, phrases and words and their derivatives shall be
3
May 2, 1994
defined as set out in this section. Words used in the singular
include the plural and vice versa.
22.54.030 Nuisances in General ��anything which
State law defines a "nuisance" as being
injurious to health, or is indecent, or offensive to the
is 7 so as to
senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, as t
interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property-"
Cal. Civ. Code §370 (1992); Cal. Penal Code § 3479-
22.54.040 Public Nuisance
A public nuisance affects an entire community or same
t the
neighborhood, or any considerable number of persons a
ance or damage inflicted
time, although the extent of the annoy
upon individuals may p, public
be unequal. Cal. Civ.
Code § 3480.
nuisance is an act or omission which interferes with the
interests of the community or eawr_ } Baa.
interferes with the public health,
fare
safety, and wel.
22.54.050 Nuisance Per Ss
Examples of activities that are nuisances per se
include water pollution by discharge, structures which amount to
a fire hazard, noise, air pollution, weeds, rubbish and refuse,
junkyards, earth movement and illegal signs -
4
May 2, 1994
22.54.060 commercial Vehicles
(a) A "commercial vehicle" is a vehicle of a type
required to be registered under the Vehicle Code used or
maintained for the transportation of persons for hire,
compensation, or profit or designed, used, or maintained
primarily for the transportation of property.
(b) Passenger vehicles which are not used for the
transportation of persons for hire, compensation, or profit and
housecars are not commercial vehicles.
(c) Any vanpool vehicle is not a commercial vehicle.
22.54.070 Driveway
(a) That approach portion of the road right of way
where motor vehicles enter or leave the highway onto private
property.
(b) A private roadway providing access to a street,
highway or off-street parking facilities.
22.54.080 Yard
(a) "Front yard" means a yard extending across the
full width of a lot between the front lot line and any main
building, including the projection of the main building to the
side lot lines.(See Diagram A)
(b) "side yard" means a yard extending from the front
yard to the rear yard between the side lot line and any main or
accessory building. In the case of a side yard abutting a street,
the side yard is considered as extending from the front yard to
the rear lot line.(See Diagram A)
5
May 2, 1994
��Rear yard means a yard extending across the full
(cot between in building,
width of a 1 the rear lot line and any mato the side lot
including the projections of the main building
lines except as noted in 2 above. (See Diagram A)
22.54.090 Code Enforcement Official
Manager
Code Enforcement Official shall mean the City ao
or any person authorized or designated by the City Manager
enforce the provisions of this Ordinance.
Part 3
SINGLE-FAMILY STANDARDS
Sections:
22.54.100 Scope -
e --Front yard/side yard abutting a
22.54.110 Storag
street. le parking.
22.54.120 Motor vehic.nance.
22.54.130 Building
22.54.140 Landscape maintenance.
22.54.150 Fence and wall maintenance.
22.54.100 SCOPE
The standards specified in Part 2 shall apply to
lots or pCity designated as single-
allparcels within the less
family, and shall govern over any inconsistent,
stringent provisions contained in this Code.
22.54.110
Storage --Front yard/side yard abutting a
street-
A. The entire front yard, and side yard visible from
an adjacent street or sidewalk,
shall be kept and
maintained free and clear of all construction and automotive
6
May 2, 1994
materials or parts, trash, refuse, debris, trash storage
receptacles, inoperative motor vehicles, dismounted camper
shells, discarded or broken materials, appliances,
furniture, junk, equipment or similar materials.
B. Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection A of
this section, emergency or minor repairs of a motor vehicle owned
by a person residing upon the lot or parcel may be conducted on
an otherwise operative motor vehicle upon a paved driveway or
paved parking area; provided, however, that such emergency or
minor repair shall be concluded within ten (10) consecutive days
of the commencement thereof or up to thirty (30) days at the
discretion of the hearing officer.
C. Notwithstanding the provisions of subsections A
and B of this section, a side yard abutting a street shall be
screened by an approved, view -obscuring wall or fence.
22.54.120 Motor Vehicle Parking
A. All parking of motor vehicles, including
recreational vehicles, on a single-family lot or parcel shall
occur within a garage, or carport, or upon a driveway or other
paved parking area which is in compliance with all applicable
codes. If parked on a side yard, an open pedestrian walkway of
a width of not less than 36" shall be maintained on one side yard
for public safety access purposes.
B. No person shall park or store any commercial
vehicle, commercial trailer or related commercial equipment for
any period in excess of 72 hours provided that no more than two
May 2, 1994 7
such permitted vehicles may be parked on any such lot or parcel
at any one time.
22.54.130 Building Maintenance
All buildings, structures and paved areas within any
lot or parcel designated as single-family shall be kept and
maintained in a manner so as not to constitute a public nuisance
or a nuisance per se. All such buildings, structures and paved
areas shall be deemed substandard and in violation of this
section when any or all of the same display evidence of exterior
dilapidated conditions.
22.54.140 Landscape maintenance
All landscaped areas within the front yard of any
developed lot or parcel designated as single-family shall be kept
and maintained in a manner so as not to constitute a public
nuisance or nuisance per se.
Landscaped areas shall be kept in a neat and clean
condition, substantially free of debris and dead, diseased or
dying vegetation, and broken or defective decorative elements of
the landscaped area. Foliage in landscaped areas shall be mowed,
groomed, trimmed, pruned and adequately watered so as to keep the
same in a healthy growing condition. Irrigation systems shall be
maintained in such a manner as to prevent public health or safety
hazards.
22.54.150 Fence and wall maintenance
May 2, 1994 8
A. All fences and walls upon any lot or parcel
designated as single-family shall be kept and maintained in
compliance with all applicable codes and in a manner so as not to
constitute a public nuisance or nuisance per se and to protect
the health, safety and welfare of the user, occupant and the
general public.
B. All fences and walls utilized for screening
purposes as required by this Part, shall be constructed of such
material, as permitted by applicable law.
Part 4
MULTIFAMILY STANDARDS
Sections:
22.54.160 Scope.
22.54.170 Storage-Yards
and carports
22.54.180 storage -Garages
22.54.190 Motor vehicle parking
22.54.200 Building maintenance
22.54.210 Landscape maintenance
22.54.220 Fence and wall maintenance
similar areas
22.54.230 Maintenance of parking
22.54.160 Scope
ied in Part 4 shall apply to all
The standards specif
lots or parcels within the City designated as multi -family,
and
shall govern over any inconsistent, less stringent provisions
contained in this Code.
22.54.170 storage --Yards
A. The entire front yard and side yard abutting a
street shall be kept and maintained free and clear of all
construction and automotive materials or parts, trash, refuse,
9
May 2, 1994
debris, trash storage receptacles, inoperative motor vehicles,
boats, camper shells, discarded or broken materials, appliances,
furniture, junk, equipment or similar materials. All rubbish,
trash and debris shall only be kept within approved trash
enclosure(s).
B. "Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection A of
this section, emergency or minor repairs of a motor vehicle owned
by a person residing upon the lot or parcel may be conducted on
an otherwise operative motor vehicle upon a paved driveway or
paved parking area; provided, however, that such emergency or
minor repair shall be concluded within ten (10) consecutive days
of the commencement thereof or a maximum of thirty (30) days as
approved by the hearing officer.
22.54.180 Storage --Garage and carports
No storage of materials, including, but not limited to,
trash and trash receptacles, newspapers, building and automotive
materials, landscape maintenance tools, equipment, debris,
inoperative motor vehicles, camper shell not mounted on motor
vehicles or boats and trailers shall be permitted within any
garage or carport so as to restrict the parking of an operative
motor vehicle in the required parking spaces.
22.54.190 Motor vehicle parking
A. All parking of motor vehicles on a multifamily lot
or parcel shall occur within a garage, or carport, or upon a
driveway or other paved parking area which is in compliance with
all applicable codes. If parked on a yard, an open pedestrian
May 2, 1994 10
walkway of a width of not less than 36" shall be maintained on
one side yard for public safety access purposes.
B. No person shall park or store any commercial
vehicle, trailer or related equipment for any period in excess of
72 hours provided that no more than two such permitted vehicles
may be parked on any such lot or parcel at any one time.
22.54.200 Building maintenance
All buildings, structures and paved areas within any
lot or parcel designated as multifamily shall be kept and
maintained in a manner so as not to constitute a public nuisance
or nuisance per se. All such buildings, structures and paved
areas shall be deemed substandard and in violation of this
section when any or all of the same display evidence of exterior
dilapidated conditions.
22.54.210 Landscape maintenance
All landscaped areas within the front yard of any lot
or parcel designated as multifamily shall be kept and maintained
in a manner so as not to constitute a public nuisance or nuisance
per se. Landscaped areas shall be kept in a neat and clean
condition, substantially free of debris and dead, diseased or
dying vegetation, and broken or defective decorative elements of
the landscaped area. Foliage in landscaped areas shall be mowed,
groomed, trimmed, pruned and watered as to keep the same in a
healthy growing condition. Irrigation systems shall be
maintained in such a manner as to prevent public health or safety
hazards.
May 2, 1994 11
22.54.220 Fence and wall maintenance
A. All fences and walls upon any lot or parcel
designated as single-family shall be kept and maintained in
compliance with all applicable codes and in a manner so as not to
constitute a public nuisance or nuisance per se and to protect
the health, safety and welfare of the user, occupant and the
general public.
B. All fences and walls utilized for screening
purposes as required by this Part, shall be constructed of such
materials, as permitted by applicable law.
22.54.230
Maintenance of parking and similar areas
All parking, loading, storage, driveway and vehicle
maneuvering areas within any lot or parcel designated as
multifamily shall be kept and maintained so as not to detract
hborhood and to protect
from the appearance of the immediate neig
the health, safety and welfare of the user, occupant and general
public. such areas shall be kept in a neat and clean condition,
free of trash, debris or rubbish,
and free of potholes,
sinkholes, standing water, cracks and/or broken areas. parking
space delineation, pavement striping and related features and
signs shall be repainted,
refurbished and/or replaced when the
same become faded, damaged or destroyed to such an extent as to
no longer be effective. such areas shall be periodically
resurfaced or sealed in order to minimize seepage of water
through such areas into the ground below.
12
May 2, 1994
part 5
COMMERCIAL STANDARDS
sections:
22.54.240 Scope'
22.54.250 Storage in yards.
parking -
22.54.260 Moto
r vehaint nance.
22.54.270 Building maintenance.
22.54.280 Landscape
22.54.290 Fence and wall maintenance
similar
22.54.300 Maintenance of parking and
areas.
22.54.240 Scope -
The standards specified in Part 5 shall apply to all
lots or parcels within the City designated as commercial,
and
11 overn over any inconsistent, less stringent provisions
sha g
contained in this Code -
Storage in yards.
22.54.250 roved
All storage within front and side yard areas app
b the City or permitted by the zoning ordinance shall be
Y
ntained in a neat and orderly fashion and shall contain only
mai or owned by the
items and/or vehicles incidental to the business,
business or owner of the business.
22.54.260
Motor vehicle parking
A, All parking of motor vehicles on a commercial lot
or parcel shall occur upon a paved parking area which is in
compliance with all applicable codes. If parked on one side
en pedestrian walkway of a width of not less than 36"
yard, an o p
shall be maintained for public safety access purposes.
13
May 2, 1994
B. No person shall park or store any commercial
vehicle, trailer or related equipment for any period in excess of
ch permitted vehicles
72 hours provided that no more than two su
may be parked on any such lot or parcel at any one time.
22.54.270 Building Maintenance
All buildings, structures and paved areas within any
lot or parcel designated as commercial shall be kept and
hborhood
maintained in a manner so as not to detract from the neig
and to protect the health, safety and welfare of the user,
occupant and general Public. All such buildings, structures and
paved areas shall be deemed substandard and in violation of this
section when any or all of the same display evidence of exterior
dilapidated conditions.
22.54.280 Landscape maintenance
All landscaped areas within the front yard of any lot
or parcel designated as commercial shall be kept and maintained
in a manner so as not to detract from the appearance of the
immediate neighborhood and to protect the health, safety and
welfare of the user,
occupant and general public.
Landscaped areas shall be kept in a neat and clean
free of weeds, debris and dead,
diseased
condition, substantially
d ing vegetation, and broken or defective decorative elements
or y
areas shall e
Foliage in landscaped
of the landscaped area. the same
mowed, groomed, trimmed, pruned and watered as to keep
in a
healthy growing condition. Irrigation systems shall be kept
in good working condition to prevent public health hazards.
14
May 2, 1994
22.54.290 pence and wall maintenance
A. All fences and walls upon any lot or parcel
designated as commercial shall be kept and maintained in
compliance with all applicable codes and in a manner so as not to
constitute a public nuisance or nuisance per se and to protect
the health, safety and welfare of the user, occupant and the
general public.
lls utilized for screening
B. All fences and wa
purposes as required by this Part, shall be constructed of such
materials, as permitted by applicable law.
22.54.300
Maintenance of parking and similar areas
All parking, loading, storage, driveway and vehicle
maneuvering areas within any
lot or parcel designated as
commercial shall be kept and maintained so as to not detract from
the appearance of the immediate neighborhood and to protect the
health, safety and welfare of the user, occupant and general
public. Such areas shall be kept in a neat and clean condition,
free of trash, debris or rubbish, and free of potholes,
sinkholes, standing water, cracks and/or broken areas. Parking
space delineation, pavement striping and related features and
signs shall be repainted, refurbished and/or replaced when the
same become faded, damaged or destroyed to such an extent as to
no longer be effective. Such areas shall be periodically
resurfaced or sealed in order to minimize seepage of water
through such areas into the ground below. The provisions
contained within this Section shall apply to private property
open to the public.
15
May 2, 1994
Part 6
Industrial standards
Sections:
22.54.310 Scope -
22.54.320 Storage
22.54.330 Motor vehicle parking.
22.54.340 Building maintenance.
22.54.350 Landscape maintenance.30 Fence and.
arking and similar areas
22.544.370 Maintenanceaof paintenanc .
22.5
22.54.310 to all
The standards specified in Part 6 shall apply
is or parcels within the city designated as industrial,
and
to stringent provisions
shall govern over any inconsistent, less
contained in this code.
Storage in yards
22.54.320 the City or
All storage within yard areas approved by
b the zoning ordinance shall be maintained in a neat
permitted Y items and/or vehicles
and orderly fashion and shall contain only
incidental
to the business, or owned by the business or owner of
the business.
22.54.330
Motor vehicle parking
A. All parking of motor vehicles on an industrial lot
paved area which is in compliance
or parcel shall occur upon a roved by the
with all applicable codes, unless otherwise app
planning C
ommission and/or City Councione side
l. If parked on
11
en pedestrian walkway of a width of not less than 36
o
yard, an P
shall be maintained for public safety access purposes.
16
May 2, 1994
22.54.340 Building Maintenance
All buildings, structures and paved areas within any
lot or parcel designated as industrial shall be kept and
maintained in a manner so as not to constitute a public nuisance
or nuisance per se. All such buildings, structures and paved
areas shall be deemed substandard and in violation of this
section when any or all of the same display evidence of exterior
dilapidated conditions.
22.54.350 Landscape maintenance
All landscaped areas within the front yard of any lot
or parcel designated as industrial shall be kept and maintained
in a manner so as not to constitute a public nuisance or nuisance
per se Landscaped areas shall be kept in a neat and clean
condition, substantially free of debris and dead, diseased or
dying vegetation, and broken or defective decorative elements of
the landscaped area. Foliage in landscaped areas shall be mowed,
groomed, trimmed, pruned and watered as to keep the same in a
healthy growing condition. Irrigation systems shall be
maintained in such a manner so as to prevent public health or
safety hazards.
22.54.360 Fence and wall maintenance
17
May 2, 1994
A. All fences and walls upon any lot or parcel
designated as industrial shall be kept and maintained in
compliance with all applicable codes and in a manner so as not to
constitute a public nuisance or nuisance per se and to protect
the health, safety and welfare of the user, occupant and the
general public.
1. sagging, broken, rotted or defective support posts
or other structural or decorative member;
2. Missing fence boards;
3. Damaged or missing blocks from a block wall.
4. Substantial areas of deterioration including dry
rot, broken or missing pieces of stucco, holes, or
warped or leaning fence or wall areas;
5. Chain link fence material which is damaged or
broken.
B. All fences and walls utilized for screening
purposes as required by this Part, shall be constructed of such
materials, as permitted by applicable law.
22.54.370 Maintenance of parking and similar areas
All parking, loading, storage, driveway and vehicle
maneuvering areas within any lot or parcel designated as
industrial shall be kept and maintained so as to not detract from
the appearance of the immediate neighborhood and to protect the
health, safety and welfare of the user, occupant and general
public. such areas shall be kept in a neat and clean condition,
free of trash, debris or rubbish, and free of potholes,
sinkholes, standing water, cracks and/or broken areas. Parking
18
May 2, 1994
space delineation, pavement striping and related features and
signs shall be repainted, refurbished and/or replaced when the
same become faded, damaged or destroyed to such an extent as to
no longer be effective. Such areas shall be periodically
resurfaced or sealed in order to minimize seepage of water
through such areas into the ground below. The provisions
contained within this Section shall apply to private property
open to the public.
DIAGRAM A
ILLUSTRATION OF LOT LINE
AND YARD DESIGNATIONS
Street (Curb face)
May 2, 1994 19
U
�_ Front Lot Line
• .
rA
i FRONT YARD
a.r
' — — — — — — — — — — — —
— — —
•
• � � � 1riL'111r �
I w I BUILDING '
� �
q
'
i
I
W
' REAR YARD
i o
Rear Lot Line �4
May 2, 1994 19
U
Part 7
ABATEMBN'r PROCEDURES
Sections:
22.54.400 Procedures for Abatement of Public Nuisances
22.54.410 Appealsthe City
22.54.420 Abatement of Public Nuisance by oas Public
22.54.430 �isancet of Imminently
Danger
unt of Abatement
22.54.440 AccoSpcialCosts Assessment
ent.
22.54.450 Procedure forrposed Assessment Abatem
22.54.460 Hearing on Prop
22.54.470 Contest of Assessment Taxes
22.54.480 Notice of Lien alar
tion with Reg
22.54.490 Procedures for
rivateeParties
22.54.500 Remedies
22.54.510 Right of Entry
Violations
22.54.530 PenaltY 22.54.520 Continuifor Violation
22.54.540 Injunction
22.54.550 Severability ublic nuisance;
22.54.400 Procedures for abatement of
or nuisances Be.
whenever the City Manager or designee has inspected or
caused to be inspected any property and has determined that an
1 condition constituting a public nuisance or nuisance per
unlawfu use the
se exists thereon, the Code Enforcement Official may
procedures set forth in this section for the abatement of such e
ublic nuisan
public nuisance; provided, however, that if the p
is determined to be imminently dangerous to life or adjacent
ir or isolation►
ert and to require immediate removal, repa
prop Y be used by the
the procedures set forth in this ordinance may
Code Enforcement Official.
(A) HEARING NOTICE
1, where the Code Enforcement Official determines that e
public nuisance or nuisance per se exists, he shall so advise
20
May 2, 1994
agent, lessee, occupant or
orally the affected party, (owner(s ),
person(s) in possession of the affected properties as shown on
P and shall give not less
the latest equalized tax assessment role)
tha
n 7 days written notice by mailing the same to the owner's
and further, within the same time
address as indicated thereon, property,
period, by conspicuously posting on the affected pro P
building or structure a copy of the notice.
2. Both the oral and written notice shall indicate the
ed nuisance, the description of the property
nature of the alleged lace of the
involved, and the designation of the time and p
and
hearing to determine whether the same constitutes a nuisance to, be a
the manner of its proposed abatement if the same is found
nuisance.
order of abatement shall be
3, The written notice and and certified mai
served to the affected party by regular ,
the failure of any person to receive a notice shall not
however, ter.
affect the validity of any proceedings under this chap
(B) CONDUCT
1. The hearings to determine whether a nuisance exists
shall be conducted by
the City Manager or his duly authorized
Off icer. The
representative, who shall act as the Hearing
in Off icer is authorized to take testimony and in the course
Hear, g
of so doing is authorized to administer oaths or affirmations
pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure Section 2093(a)
2, Prior to the taking
of testimony, the Hearing
Officearty. If
shall offer a mediation procedure to the affected p
mediation is refused, or is unsuccessful in alleviating the
unlawful condition, then the matter shall proceed to hearings -
21
May 2, 1994
In no event shall the mediation process delay
the hearing process
for more than 30 days from the date initially set for hearing.
3. At the hearings, the Hearing Officer shall consider all
relevant evidence, including but not limited to applicable staff
reports. He shall give an interested person a reasonable
opportunity to be heard in conjunction therewith.
All witnesses
are subject to cross examination. Based upon the evidence so
presented, the Hearing Officer shall determine whether a nuisance
within the meaning
of this chapter exists.
4. The decision of the Hearing Officer shall be final and
conclusive in the absence of an appeal as provided in this
chapter.
(C) ORDER OF ABATEMENT
within five working days of the
The.Hearing officer shall,
itten notice of his decision by
hearing, give a copy of the wr
regular and certified mail to the owner(s ) and a copy to any
other person requesting the same. The decision shall contain an
order of abatement, if a nuisance is determined to exist,
or the person
directed to the owner(s) of the affected property
in the control and/or charge of the property, and shall set forth
the nature of the nuisance, its location, and the time and manner
tice of the period of limitation for
for its abatement. No
judicial review, as prescribed in §2,
Shall be provided in the
(See exhibit A for a sample form of note.)
notice and decision.
(D) EXTENSION OF TIME TO PERFORM WORK.
upon receipt of a written request from any person required
to comply with the notice and order, the Hearing officer may
grant an extension of time within which to complete the
22
May 2, 1994
abatement, if the Hearing Officer determines that such an
extension of time will not create a situation imminently
angerous to life or property.
The Hearing officer shall have
the authority to place reasonable conditions on any
such
extension. The Hearing officer may take into account economic
hardship and/or physical disability
on the part of the affecte
party when granting such an extension.
The hearing officer shall
have
discretionary approval to extend the length of time for the
abatement proceeding based upon findings of fact such as
(1) A determination that special circumstances or
exceptional characteristics exist applicable to the property
involved, such as size, shape, topography,
location, or
surroundings that are not generally applicable to other
erties in the same vicinity and under identical zoning
Pro p
classification.
b) A determination that an extension of time is necesfart
( e
rty right o
for the preservation of a substantial prope
applicant, such as that possessed by owners of other
property
or in the same vicinity and zone -
(c)
c) A determination that an extension of time would not be
terially detrimental to the public welfare or be injure
ous
ma
to other property or improvements in the same vicinity an
zone.
23
May 2, 1994
Exhibit "A"
Example of Notice
"NOTICE AND ORDER TO ABATE A PUBLIC NUISANCE
TO THE OWNER(S), AGENT OF THE OWNERE CRI, OCCUPANT, OR PERSON IN
POSSESSION OF THE PROPERTY HEREINAFTER
ated in
ity
The building, structure, improvement, or property which is the subject of hisBe C
OCKTRACT and
of Diamond Bar, Los Angeles County, California, on premises described as LOT_,
commonly known as
YOUR ATTENTION IS HEREBY DIRECTED to the provisions of- of the Municipal Code of the
City of Diamond Bar, California on file in the office of the City Clerk in the City Hall.
Pursuant to the provisions of _, you are hereby notified that thviolations consist of---
NS
(DESCRIPTION OF UNLAWFUL
'fled and ordered to abate the above specified conditions by taking the following actions (s):
You are further note
DESCRIPTION NLAACTIONS WFUL CONDITIONSRY (TOO ABATE
)
Such action(s) must be completed within (insert time period) days from the date of your receipt es this
e property free of any of the unlawful conditions described
notice and order, and thereafter you must
maintain
tpermits and to dispose of any material or materials
above. It is your responsibility to obtain all appropriate
involved in the pubic nuisance in a legal manner.
the undersigned shall
In the event you fail to complete such work within the time hereinabove mentioned, ill be a lien upon the property
cause the appropriate action a be taken and completed, the chges therefor w
the P ublic right-of-way or sidewalk in the event the public
or upon the lot or parcel of land adjoining and abutting
right-of-way or sidewalk is to be cleaned or otherwise protected.
holdin record title or having any interest in the property may appeal
You are advised that any person(s) g
from this notice and order, or any determination of the Hearing Written noCAof such hcer to e appeal must ust belffiled n the Office of
days from the date of service of this notice and order. le Drive, Suite 190, Diamond Bar, CA
the Planning Commission Secretary n the City Hall at , the toE. Copley n the Office of
5. If no appeal is filed within the time prescribed, the may
be determinationofag theHearing officerpshall be final.
91765.P
You are further advised that this notice and order may be
the County Recorder.
DATED
This day of 19_ -
Hearing Officer
24
May 2, 1994
22.54.410 Appeals.
Within ten days after the date of service of the notice and
order described above, the owner(s), agent of the owner, lessee,
occupant, or person in possession of the
property who may have been
served with a notice and order, or any person interested in the pro ert
affected by such notice and order P y
may appeal to the Planning Commission,
or the City Council, if applicable
as to the requirements of such notice
and order. Such appeals shall be in writing, shall state the objections
Of the person filing the appeal, shall be filed with the Planning
Commission Secretarywithin the time specified herein
P
Presented to the PlanningCommission b � and shall be
y the Planning Commission Secretary
at its next regular meeting. The Planning Commission shall thereu o
proceed to hear and act upon appeal. P on the a ealn
The Planning Commission shall,
by resolution, determine whether the Code Enforcement Official shall.
proceed in accordance with the notice and order as given, or as modified
by the Planning Commission, or not at all, and its decision thereon
be final and conclusive. shall
The hearing may be continued by the Planning
Commission from time to time as it deems necessary. The action of the
Planning Commission may be appealed to the City Council in accordance
with the procedures followed for an appeal
The Planning Commission decision is fnalto the Planning Commission.
unless appealed within 10 days.
Limitation of filing judicial action. Any owner(s) or other
interested person having an objection to the final decision o
Council in ordering the abatement of an f the City
y public nuisance or nuisance per
se under the provisions of this Chapter must bring an action to contest
such decision within ninety (90) days after the date of such decision
of
May 2, 1994
25
the Planning Commission, or City Council, if applicable. Otherwise, all
objections to such decision shall be deemed waived.
22.54.420 Abatement of public nuisances by the city.
(A) If the owner(s), agent of the owner, lessee, occupant, entity,
or person in possession of the property who may be served with a notice
and order shall fail to take action as required by the notice and order
within the time therein specified, or as extended by the Planning
Commission, or City Council, if applicable, and in accordance with the
provisions of this Chapter, the City Manager shall take action as
specified in the notice and order to abate the public nuisance existing
on the property.
(B) Abatement of the public nuisance may, at the discretion of the
City Manager be performed by city forces or the City prosecutor or by a
private contractor engaged by the city pursuant to the provisions of this
code.
(C) Notwithstanding compliance with the notice and order, the
owner(s), and any other persons having an interest in the property
described in the notice, shall in all events be jointly and severally
liable for all costs incurred by the city in securing such compliance.
Moneys due the city pursuant to this subsection may be recovered in an
appropriate court in the same manner that abatement costs are recovered
pursuant to this Chapter.
22.54.430 Abatement of imminently dan erousublic nuisances.
Whenever the City Manager or his duly authorized representative
determines that a public nuisance is so imminently dangerous to life or
adjacent property that such condition must be immediately removed,
May 2, 1994 26
repaired or isolated, the City Manager shall notify all appropriate
public safety agencies and implement the following procedures:
(A) Notice. The City Manager shall attempt to make contact through
a personal interview, or by telephone, with the owner(s)
of the property
or the person, if any, occupying or otherwise in real or apparent charge
and control thereof. In the event such contact is made, the City Manager
shall notify such person, or persons, of the danger involved and require
that such condition be immediately removed, repaired or isolated so as to
preclude harm to any person or property.
(B) Abatement. If the City Manager is unable to make contact as
herein above noted, or if the appropriate persons, after notification by
the City Manager or his/her designee do not take action within such time
as may be specified by such official, then the City Manager may take all
actions deemed necessary to remove, repair, or isolate such dangerous
condition or conditions, with the use of City or other public or private
forces or a city prosecutor or contractor engaged pursuant to the
provisions of this Code.
22.54.440 Account of abatement costs.
(A) The City Manager in conjunction with the finance director,
shall keep an itemized account of all costs incurred by the city in the
abatement of any public nuisance under this chapter. Such costs may
include, but are not limited to, any and all direct costs and expenses
related to such items as investigation, boundary determination,
measurement, personnel salaries and benefits, operational overhead, fees
for experts or consultants, legal costs or expenses, including attorney's
fees, claims against the city arising as a consequence of the public
27
May 2, 1994
nuisance, clerical and administrative cost, and procedures associated
with collecting moneys due hereunder.
(B) Upon completion of the abatement work, the City Manager or
his/her designee shall prepare a report specifying the work done, the
itemized costs of the work necessary to abate the public nuisance, a
description of the property involved, and the names and addresses of the
persons entitled to notice pursuant to this Chapter. Any such report may
include costs on any number of properties, whether or not contiguous to
each other, and whether or not under the same ownership. The report
shall be filed with the City Clerk.
22.54.450 Procedure for s ecial assessment
(A) Hearing Notice. Within ten days after the filing of the report
referred to herein, the Planning Commission Secretary shall fix a time
and place for hearing and passing upon the report. The City Clerk shall
cause notice of the proposed assessment, as set forth in the report, to
be given to the owner(s) in the manner specified herein. Such notice
shall contain a description of the property sufficient to enable the
persons served to identify it, and shall specify the day, hour, and place
when the Planning Commission will hear and pass upon the report, together
with any objections or protests which may be raised by any persons liable
to be assessed for the costs of such abatement. Notice of the hearing
shall be given not less than fifteen (15) days prior to time fixed by the
City Clerk for the hearing, and shall also be published once, at least
fifteen days prior to the date of the hearing, in a newspaper of general
circulation published in the community.
28
May 2, 1994
(g) Protests. Any interested person may file a written protest with
on the
Cit Clerk at any time prior to the time set for the hearing
the Y
City Manager. Each such protest shall contain a
report of the signing the protest is
in which the person sig
description of the property Clerk shall endorse
interested and the grounds of such protest. The City
on every such protest the date and time of filing,
and shall present such
protest to
the Planning Commission, or City Council, if applicable, at
the time set for hearing -
22.54.460 Hearin on ro osed s ec'al assessment hearing, the Planning
Upon the day and hour fixed for the
Commission
shall consider the report of the Code Enforcement Official,
ether with any protests which have been filed with the Planning
tog make such revisions,
Commission Secretary. The Planning Commission may and when
corrections, or modifications in the report as it maY
deem just,
in Commission is satisfied with the correctness of the r as
the Planning ssment, as submitted, o
assessment, the report and the proposed asse
revised, corrected, or modified, shall be confirmed by resolution. The
decision of the Planning Commission, or City Council, if applicable, on
and the assessment and on all protests shall be final and
the report Commission
conclusive, unless appealed to the City
Council. The Planning
ma continue the hearing from time to time as it deems necessary.
Y
22.54.470 Contest of s ecial assessment. provisions of
The validity of any assessment levied under the p
action or proceeding unless
this Chapter shall not be contested in any days after the
such action or proceeding is commenced within thirty
assessment
is confirmed by resolution of the Planning Commision. All
s
29
May 2, 1994
interested persons shall be given notice of the final determination and
the time limitation for judicial review.
22.54.480 Noti a of lien --- Forts and contents
(A) Notice of Lien. Immediately upon confirmation of the
assessment by the Planning Commission, the City Clerk shall execute and
file in the office of the Los Angeles County Recorder a certificate in
substantially the following form set forth in Exhibit B.
30
May 2, 1994
Exhibit B
Example of Notice
"NOTICE OF LIEN
e City Manager by the Provisions of
of the
Pursuant to the authority vested in th
19_1 abated the public nuisance upon the
Diamond Bar Municipal Code, on or about the _day Of by taking the following actions (s):
dress
real property commonly
known as (ad
ran art thereof, and the City of Diamond Bar does hereby claim a lien on the
The same has not been paid no y P
ro for the net expense of the doing of the abatement in the amount of $, and this amount
real Property , with interest at the rate of six percent
shall be a lien upon the real property until the sum of $
19_, has been Paid in full and discharged of record.
(6%) per annum from is that certain parcel of land
ert herein before mentioned, and upon which a lien is claimed,
The real propertY all described as follows:
in the City of Diamond Bar, County of Los Angeles, State of California, and legally
Dated: this . day of
(DESCRIPTION)
FINANCE MANAGER, CITY OF DIAMOND BAR
(ACKNOWLEDGEMENTY
31
May 2, 1994
(B) Recordation. Immediately upon the recording
Of the notice
of -lien the assessment shall constitute a lien on the real property
assessed.
xes
22.54.490 Procedures for collection with re lar Finance Director
(p,) Assessment Book. After recording,
the
eles County,
shall deliver the notice of lien to the auditor of Los k o osite the
who shall enter the amount on the county assessment bo be colected
description of the particular property, and the amount shall
together with all other taxes against the property.
(B) Collection. The amount set forth in the notice of lien as
shall thereafter be collected as the same time and in the same maner me
ordinary city taxes are collected,
and shall be subject to the s
penalties and interest and to the same procedure under foreclosure and
sale in case of delinquency to the levy, collection and enforcement o
city taxes are made applicable to such assessment.
(C) Refunds. The Planning
Commission may recommend a refund
of all or part of the assessment paid pursuant to this Chapter if it
finds that all or part of the assessment was erroneously
levied. An
assessment or part thereof shall not be refunded unless a claim is filed
with the Planning Commission Secretary within six months after the
assessment became due and payable. The claim shall be verified by the
person who paid the assessment, or the legal representative of such
person.
22.54.500 Remedies of rivate arties
The provisions of this Chapter shall in no manner adversely
affect the right of the owner(s), lessee, or occupant of any such
32
May 2, 1994
property to recover all costs and expenses imposed by this Chapter from
responsible for creating or maintaining the public nuisance.
res
any person P
22.54.510 Right of entry
tate and Federal law.
(A) Shall be governed by all applicable Sincluding an owner(s),
(g) It shall be unlawful for any person(s),
agent of the owner(s), lessee or anyone in possession of any
property
within the City to refuse to allow the Code Enforcement
Official,
or a contractor engaged by the city, consistent with this
to enter upon the property erty at any time during the hours
ordinance, ublic nuisance or
of daylight for the purpose of the abatement of a P
obstruct, impede or interfere in any manner with the Code
to the city, in any
or a contractor engaged by
Enforcement Official, ter.
work undertaken pursuant to the provisions of this Chap
22.54.520 Continuin
violations.
it shall constitute a continuing
and
until the violation is abated and shall be punished
violation unless
accordingly.
22.54.530 Penalt for violation 1 with any provision or
No person shall violate or fail to comply
Code. Any person who shall violate or fail to comply
requirement of thisuilty of a
with any provision or requirement of this Code shall be g
33
May 2, 1994
misdemeanor. However, any provision of this Code may be prosecuted as an
infraction at the discretion of the Prosecuting Attorney.
22.54.540 Injunction
The provisions of this Chapter may be enforced by an injunction
issued by any court having jurisdiction over the suit or the owner(s) or
occupant of any real property affected by such violations or prospective
violation."
22.54.550 Severability.
If any section, subsection, subdivision, sentence, clause or
phrase of this ordinance is for any reason held to be unconstitutional or
otherwise invalid, such decision shall not affect the validity of the
remaining portions of this ordinance. The City Council hereby declares
that it would have passed this ordinance and each section, subsection,
subdivision, sentence, clause and phrase thereof, irrespective of the
fact that any one or more sections, subsections, subdivisions, sentences,
clauses or phrases be declared unconstitutional."
The City Clerk shall certify to the passage of this Ordinance
and shall cause the same to be posted in three (3) public places within
the City of Diamond Bar pursuant to Resolution No. 89-6.
ADOPTED AND APPROVED THIS DAY OF
1994.
Mayor
34
May 2, 1994
I, LYNDA BURGESS, City Clerk of the City of Diamond Bar, do
hereby certify that the foregoing Ordinance was introduced at a regular
meeting of the City Council of the City of Diamond Bar held on the
day of
1994 and was finally passed at a regular
meeting of the City Council.
City Clerk
35
May 2, 1994
MISSION STATEMENT
The City Council meeting is the forum established to
conduct the business of the City of Diamond Bar, its
citizens, property owners, and businesses. The City
Council has chosen to conduct its business meetings in a
televised, open forum. This has been done to assure that
all community members are kept informed as to the status of
City business. It is the Council's objective to conclude
the business stated on the evening's agenda by a reasonable
hour, which is 11:00 p.m. To accomplish tonight's
objectives, the City Council requests that:
1. Public comments may be directed to Consent
Calendar items or matters of interest to the
public, which are not on this evening's agenda.
2. Public comments on scheduled matters will be
heard in conjunction with the respective
agendized subject.
3. There are to be no personal attacks toward
individual members of the City Council. Such
comments are viewed as personal attacks against
the entire City Council and will not be
tolerated.
4. There are to be no personal attacks from an
individual Council member. Such are viewed as
personal attacks from the entire City Council,
which are not conducive to a positive business
meeting environment; and, will not be tolerated.
The Diamond Bar City Coun it appr iates your cooperation.
Clair W. Harmony
Mayor Pro Tem
Ic
� ice " -
Eileen R. Ansari
Councilwoman
Phyllis E. Papen
council o
ry G. Mill
Councilman
CITY OF DIAMOND BAR
MINUTES OF THE PARKS & RECREATION COMMISSION
FEBRUARY 24, 1994
CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Schey called the meeting to order at 7:18 p.m.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
The audience was led in the Pledge of Allegiance by Chairm<
BOLL CALL
Present: Chairman Schey, Commissioners: Ruzicka and Goldenberg
Vice Chairman Johnson arrived at 7:45 p.m.
Staff: Community Services Director Bob Rose; Administrative
Assistant Sandy Barlow; Recreation Supervisor Marla
Pearlman; Recording Secretary Liz Myers
Absent: Commissioner Medina (excused)
MATTERS FROM THE AUDIENCE - None
MINUTES
1. Minutes of January 27, 1994.3
C/Ruzicka requested that the minutes of January 27, 1994 be amended on
page 5, fourth paragraph, to replace the word "mediate" with "mitigate"; and
on page 9, under Announcements, to reword the third paragraph, to read,
"C/Ruzicka suggested that there be some consideration to having Mr.
Armentrout, the City's Emergency Coordinator, attend the Parks and Recreation
Commission meeting to provide suggestions regarding the use of parks for
refuge in emergency situations.
Moved by C/Goldenberg, seconded by C/Ruzicka and carried unanimously to
approve the minutes of January 27, 1994, as amended.
February 24, 1994 Page 2
NEW BUSINESS
2. Disaster Preparedness
Mr. Armentrout, the City's Emergency Coordinator,
He seated that main
n on the
Parks and Recreation's role in disasterpreparedness.
responsibility for Parks & Recreation) Dsp aremand shelteents, or r mmunity He explained that,
Services
Departments, in most cities in Califo
in a time of crisis, the Department Head would contact the Red Cross, which
has already redesignated the High School and sand e Middle
i ting up the shelters shelters
If
and assist in organizing the distribution of food
those predesignated shelters are damaged,
then the City Council and the City
Manager would need to declare a local emergency
that She et the the Parks nation & aRecaeatioon
set up tents in the parks. He suggested
Commission could encourage the public to volunteer to assist in the area of
care and shelter.
C/Ruzicka suggested that it may be beneficial if Mr. Armentrout was able to
provide a similar presentation to all of the City's Commissions, perhaps on an
annual basis, and provide an update on the Disaster Plan.
Parks and
Mr. Armentrout offered to come eback isastern Plan with the Commission,
Commission meeting to review th
highlighting the sections relating to the Parkrs& Recreation
Depa t sent. the
He
then reiterated the importance of seeking ore
Disaster program.
C/Goldenberg suggested that perhaps its should be
r recommmber ended
ded to the from City
Council to create a subcommittee consisting
of ach
Commission, and volunteers from the general public, to discuss needs and ways
to continue planning for an emergency.
Moved by C/Goldenberg, seconded by C/eachcka of tnd he carried
Comm ss ons form to
recommend to the City Council thatwith
subcommittee for disaster preparedness that
ill met on a Phe arks regular
and basis tion
the Emergency Services Coordinator -
and Recre
Department Head, to bring back suggestions to each respective Commission
has to how that Commission could assist in disaster preparedness.
C/Ruzicka volunteered to be on that subcommittee if it is formed.
February 24, 1994 Page 3
OLD BUSINESS
3. Priorities Matrix
CSD/Rose reported that the finalized list of priorities projects will be forwarded
to the City Manager and City Council for consideration for the 1994/95 fiscal
year budget.
VC/Johnson, a member of the Commission's subcommittee, explained that the
list includes more than just the top ten projects so that all projects are
addressed as money becomes available. He then stated that item #18 should
be amended to indicate "physically and developmentally challenged."
CSD/Rose stated that item #5 should be modified to indicate,"Installation of
Top Soil/Drainage at Peterson Park" because standing water in the playing fields
of the park remains a problem. He suggested that the Commission may want
to consider placing this item before item 4, "Install Ball Field Lights at Peterson
Park", because it will be difficult to increase playing capacity if the fields are in
poorcondition. He explained that much of the drainage problems at the park
is a result grading, the lack of drains, and the lack of top soil during
development of the park.
C/Ruzicka questioned how much of the park becomes unusable because of the
top soil problem in comparison to how much of the park will become usable as
a result of the installation of additional lights.
VC/Johnson pointed out that installing lights, which is a CIP project, increases
the City's ability to develop adult programs that would play after dusk. He
expressed concern with delaying an opportunity to expand the City's recreation
program. He inquired how much each of the projects would cost.
CSD/Rose stated that the ball field lights are estimated at a cost of $140,000,
and the top soil is estimated at a cost of $300,000.
Chair/Schey pointed out it is not known how long it will take to modify the
drainage system and improve the turf condition; however, the lights can be
installed now, which increases the playability of the park. He noted that there
are fairly inexpensive drainage systems that can be utilized in specific areas
without disrupting the playability of the fields.
February 24, 1994
Page 4
It was the consensus of the Commission to leave items #4 & 5 in their present
order in the Priorities List. budgeted to
CIG
oldenberg requested staff to review which items are currently
be funded. Complete
items that are budgeted: item 43, Comp
CSD/Rose reviewed the following an; item #8, Shade
ment of Pantera Park; item #4, Install Ball Fiel Lig is at Peterson Park;
Develop rounds at Ronaldparks; item
item #6, Install Drainage in playgrounds , Retro -fit County ns at City
Structure at Peterson Parkitem
Canyon Road at Heritage Park; item ac Retro-
fitSecurity Lights along compliance; and item #17, Rep
fit Parks/Playgrounds for ADA comp
Basketball Nets with Nylon Nets.
by VC/Johnson, seconded by C/Ruzicka and carried unanimously
be
Moved for the list of prioritized projects
recommend to the City Council that funding item #5 to indicate Top
#18 to indicate "physically and developmentally
included in the 1994/95 fiscal year budget, amending
Soil/Drainage; and item
challenged."
4, Commission Handbook draft COPY of the
received
CSD/Rose reported that the CO mmsl oa
n Handbook for review and for any
revised parks and Recreation CommISS
additional input.
e noted that the titles, locations, and dates throughout the document
Chair/Sch Y
should be updated.
to
Moved by
C/Ruzicka, seconded by VC/Johnson and carried unanimously les,
the Parks and Recreation Commen ° andap resenting adrevl sed COPY
accept
locations, a�dss on at the ates throughout ext meet ng um
to the Com
INFORMATIONAL ITEMS
5. 1990 Census Information
February 24, 1994
A
VA
0
Page 5
CSD/Rose stated that the 1990 census information, as requested by C/Ruzicka,
breaks down the various ages of youth, compares the youth population with
other age groups, and classifies the population by age, race and sex.
n is
en the
es
The Commission noted a verifies eheat thajority of the need to expand the'�ecreationeprogram gby
of 30 and 50, which
providing night time and weekend activities.
Chair/Schey declared the information as considered received and filed.
Arbor Day Celebration - 3/13/94
CSD/Rose reported that, as part of the Route 60 Freeway Environmental
Enhancement Project, 95 fifteen gallon and 24 inch box trees will be planted
around the parameter of Peterson Park, to be paid for by the State. He stated
that a number of volunteer groups will be assisting staff in planting the trees on
Sunday, March 13, 1994 at10:00 �a m. He then stated that smaller trees to be planted oDn�he slopes at
n Schad has
volunteered to donate additional
Peterson Park.
5th Anniversary Celebration - 4/17/94
AA/Barlow reported that the theme for the 5th Anniversary Celebration is to
celebrate the cultural aspect of the City. She stated that the event will be
called Diamond Bar's Passport
othe ted to se� up„booths, havethe
gamese anred
community/cultural groups w be inv
perform at the event.
Recreation Program Up -date
a. Athletics/Recreation Classes
RS/Pearlman presented the staff report reviewing the success of the
Contract Classes. She reported that the Youth, Track & Field Meet has
been rescheduled for April 23, 1994, and that youth Baseball registration
has been scheduled for May7,
for 1994
9non-residents.o00 a.m. to noon for
residents and from noon to 0
VC/Johnson inquired if there is an Adult Country Line Danding .class
offered.
February 24, 1994 Page 6
RS/Pearlman stated that a beginning and intermediate adult class is
offered at Diamond Point Elementary on Wednesdays.
b. Tiny Tots/Adult Excursions
AA/Barlow reported that the Tiny Tot program is doing well.
AA/Barlow reported on the following scheduled Adult Excursions: the
Orchid Show, scheduled in March of 1994 in Santa Barbara, is full; the
Richard Nixon Library trip is coming up; and the Mammoth Weekend trip
is scheduled for April 8, 1994.
C. Senior Citizens
CSD/Rose reported that Waste Management trash haulers will be
donating a 26' x 8' storage container for the Heritage Park Community
Center to store chairs, disaster preparedness supplies, and food that will
be distributed later that same day.
EMERGENCY AGENDA ITEMS
Moved by VC/Johnson, seconded by C/Ruzicka and carried unanimously to place an
additional item on the agenda for discussion.
9. CSD/Rose reported that staff received letters from two non-profit service
organizations seeking waiver of fees for use of Heritage Park Community Center
for fundraiser activities. He expressed concern that giving prime time hours to
non-profit groups for fundraisers takes away from the City's ability to collect
the funds necessary to maintain the building. He stated that, after reviewing
the facility use policy, staff is recommending that the facility use policy be
amended as indicated int he staff report, allowing a waiver of room rental fees
one time per calendar year, equivalent to eight hours of use.
Moved by C/Ruzicka, seconded by C/Goldenberg and carried unanimously to
approve the modification to the facility use policy as recommended by staff.
ANNOUNCEMENTS
VC/Johnson stated that he received a request for benches outside of the Heritage Park
Community Center.
February 24, 1994 Page 7
t staff is currently investigating
that possibility. He explained that
CSD/Rose stated tha
Subcommittee of the City Council had also received the same
a member of the Senior
request.
nced that the CalFest Conference is scheduled in San Luis Obispo.
VC/Johnson annou Preparedness
CI
Ruzlcka reiterated his desire to volunteer on the Emergency
Subcommittee, if it is formed.
CSD/Rose suggested that the meeting be adjourned to March 17, 1994 for the Pantera
Workshop.
Chair/Schey stated that there will be a reorganization of the Commission at the next
Regular Commission meeting. in ceremony for in -coming
City Council meeting,
CSD/Rose reported that theas well as presenting City Tiles for
y will be a swearing -
commissioners at the nextC
to out -going commissioners.
ADJOURNMENT to adjourn
Moved by C/J
ohnson, seconded by C/Goldenberg and carried unanimously
the meeting at 9:11 p•m•
Respectfully Submitted,
Bob Rose
Secretary
Attest:
David Schey
Chairman
CITY OF DIAMOND BAR AGENDA NO. L -2 --
AGENDA
2 -
AGENDA REPORT
TO:
Terrence L. Belanger, City Manager PORT DATE: April 28, 1994
MEETING DATE: May 3, 1994
Frank M. Usher, Assistant City Manager
FROM: David G. Liu, Senior Engineer
TITLE: Engineering Services
Contract For the Development and Implementation of a Pavement
Management System
requirements of Proposition 111 for State Gases tha d has and �in place a
SUMMARY: In aCCOr�"ce e criteria
with the R rn Guidelines, local jurisdiction must certify
e fY prior to expending
stipulated by the Proposition C Local public funds p stem, a
pavement management system (PMS) This is to foster the cost-effective use of P the street
pavem system needs to provide an overview of the condition of the prioritizing
o street gsy
Proposition C funds. The Y and a means of rationally p
sand cost-effectiveness. To accomplish this work, it is the e� on
means of documentinto
g street maintenance/ rehabilitation needs, Request for Proposal,
improvement projects in terms firm. In response to the City s eq
retain the services of a qualified engineering
Committee received and evaluated four (4) proposals for said services•
rofessional engineering services
amount not -to -exceed $37,020.00, plus a contingency amount
RECOMMENDATION: It is recommendedin thatthe City Council awaynhat a P
contract to Dwight French and Associates
of $3,000• Notification
s of
X Staff Report _Public Hearing Clerk'
LIST OF ATTACHMENTS:_ office)
Bid Specifications (on file in City
_ Resolution(s) X Other: (ATTACHMENTS 1-2)
Ordinances(s) —
X Agreement(s)
EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION:
SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST:
Has the resolution, ordinance or agreement been reviewed
by the City Attorney?
Does the report require a majority or 4/5 vote?
Has environmental impact been assessed?
Has the report been reviewed by a Commission?
Which Commission? the report?
Are other departments affected by Po
Report discussed with the following affected departments:
1.
2.
3.
4.
741
REVIEWED BY:
]anger Frank M. Usher
JMWenc"eL. Assistant City Manager
City Manager
C:\WPW\LINDAyAY\AGF3NDA-9\PMS .503
X Yes _ No
Majority Yes
X No
YX No
Yes
X Yes _ No
f David lu
Senior Engineer
CITY COUNCIL REPORT
AGENDA NO.
W-CrMG DATE: May 3, 1994
TO:
Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
Terrence L. Belanger, City Manager
FROM: lementation of a Pavement
Engineering Services Contract For the Development and In
SUCT'
Management System
ISSUE STATEMENT: management system. To accomplish this work,
The City desires to development and implement a pavement
it is necessary to retain the services of a qualified engineering firm
RECOWVVg1,4DATION't to Dwight French
Professional engineering services contras
It is recommended that the City
Council award a P jus a contingency amount of $3,000.
and Associates in an amount not -to -exceed $37,020.00, P
FINANCIAL SUMMARY :
Proposition
C Fund has been budgeted for the development and implementation of
For FY 1993-94, $0�ys opo
a pavement management
BACKGROUND'DISCUSSION: stipulated
at it has in place a Pavement
ents of Proposition 111 for State Gas Tax Fend and the criteria
In conformance with the requirements local jurisdiction must cern Y
by the Proposition C Local Return Guidelines,
ublic funds prior to expending
ent System (PMS) • This is to foster the ocn t�eeetheavuse used by public transit or on bikeways.
Managem Y
Proposition C funds for street repair and maintenan Proposition 111 (Streets & Highways Code
uirement for a PMS is consistent with the PMS required by Po
This req criteria:
Section 2108.1) and must meet the following arterial and collector routes, reviewed and
1 • Inventory of existing pavements including, as a minimum,
updated biennially. biennially -
2. bikeways (Bike Path), reviewed and updated
2. Inventory of existing class I
CITY OF DIAMOND BAR
ES
PAV
EMENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM ENGINEERING SERVIC
PAGE 2
nt conditions including, asa, minimum, arterial and collector routes,
3. Assessment/ biennially
of pavement
reviewed and updated biennially.
replacement -
4. of all sections of pavement needing rehabilitation or rep
4 Pavement for
needs for rehabilitation or replacement of deficient sections of
5 , Determination of budgetiennial periods)
current and following
r -based pavement management system will provide the following:
As can be expected, a compute
A means of documenting street maintenance/rehabilitation needs and a basis for organizingand Planning
•
the City's street maintenance/rehabilitation program -
stem. stem.
• An overview of the condition of the total street sy ment projects
in terms of needs and cost-
• A means of rationally prioritizing the street improve P
effectiveness.
In Attachment 1, staff has identified the goals and objectives of implementing a pavement management system
for the City. P � retain an engineering firm to develop and
request for proposal (RF) 4 Proposals
were received
On February 2, 1994, staff initiated nt system- In response to the RFP, a total of four () P p°
implement a pavement Man ag
and evaluated by the Selection Committee.
staff members, Frank Usher and David Liu, and Commisinvited
sioner
The Selection Committee consisted of two (2) Ws, the Committee Todd Chavers. Based on the pT°p°1994 and April 11, 1994•
of the Traffic and Transportation Commission,
all four (4) firms for interview/presentation and further consideration on April
These firms are as follows:
• BSI Consultants
• Dwight French andAssociatess, Inc.
• Pavement Management
• UMA Engineering, Inc. ed to identify a system
the City, the Selection oCt haves the attee bility for a complex system
With the goals and objectives established by size, w Consequently, We
Based on the current staffing lex data iegiurements.
which best fits our needs. a long learning curve or for come to access, edit and operate.
that requires constant
attention,
is simple to use, and is easy
need a system that is a proven
CITY OF DIAMOND BAR
ES
P
AVEMENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM ENGINEERING SERVIC
PAGE 3
objective satisfaction matrix (Attachment 2) was prepared.
This reflects
Upon evaluation of all four firmsqualitative criteria.
the Committee's objective and
Heves that the system by Dwight French and Associatesr�ure
provides the methodology, software, and p
The Selection Committee unanimously DFA's system p stem operates entirely
represents the best choice for the City. the City. It should be noted that thoperates
with AutoCAD.
to meet the goals and objectives established by package
uter-based system running dBase IV and that the graphics
within a microcomp ro
The City currently has both of these software Programs.
, �guna Niguel,
Pavement management system are o p Development and
Some of the cities that haveimplemented
fee from
DFA's p completed
within seven (7) months from the date
Th p sed fee from Dwight Frenbceh andpAssociates is $37,
Temecula, etc. system is scheduled to
implementation of this proposed y
of Notice to Proceed.
Prepared By:
Yank M Ler
David Q. LLiu
C:\HP60\LINDAKAY\CCR-94\PMS.503
ATTACHMENY #1
GOALS & OBJECTIVES OF IMPLEMENTING A
PAVEMENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
GOALS:
• Quantify pavement conditions of all streets.
• Determine the impact of budget levels on pavement condition.
• Develop a program for annual and 5 -year plans of maintenance and
rehabilitation projects.
• Establish a system which is compatible with the City's GIS/Mapping
System.
OBJECTIVES:
• Inventory of existing pavements.
• Assessment of present conditions of overall street network as well as
individual sections.
• Projected conditions of overall street network and individual sections.
• Identification of individual sections requiring maintenance and
rehabilitation in current and future years.
• Determination of budget needs to provide an acceptable level of
service.
• Impact of various budget levels and maintenance options on projected
condition of the network.
• Preparation of the budget based on the PMS and submission of it to
the City Manager/City Council.
• Provisions for future modifications and improvements to the system.
m
m
O
m
D
m
m
z
m
D
c
c
O
z
'O
�
C
D
W
D
O
p0
Z
Or.
z
z
N
O
0
to
C I
O
619
cyl
OD
W
W
-1
O
--%
O
A
O
C)
O
0
y
A
w
N
T
em %
a
�
w
Cil
ee
A
N
N
W
N
N
N
W
CD
-b-
CT
C/3
hpm f@O�
O
O
O
OCA
ti
N
OD
N
0
N
OD
O
O
O
O
%
r
�
d
Ol
�pa
5 c Esti
e
4s
W
W
'13
cn
02 3
ka
I� 0
c 0
C C) x
C 0 XG�fbo
All
�e�f q,
M o
t j
c0
c0w
s` 46
�6
0
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
This Agreement is made and entered into this day of
, 1994, between the City of Diamond Bar, a
Municipal Corporation (hereinafter referred to as "CITY") and
Dwight French and Associates, Inc. (hereinafter referred to as
"CONSULTANT").
A. Recitals.
(i) CITY has heretofore issued its Request for Proposal
pertaining to the performance of professional engineering services
with respect to the Development and Implementation of a Pavement
Management System ("Project" hereafter).
(ii) CONSULTANT has now submitted its proposal for the
performance of such services, a full, true and correct of copy of
which proposal is attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and by this
reference made a part hereof.
(iii) CITY desires to retain CONSULTANT to perform
professional engineering services necessary to render advice and
assistance to CITY, CITY's City Council and staff in the
preparation of Project.
(iv) CONSULTANT represents that it is qualified to
perform such services and is willing to perform such professional
engineering services as hereinafter defined.
NOW, THEREFORE, it is agreed by and between CITY and
CONSULTANT as follows:
1
B. Agreement.
1. Definitions: The following definitions shall apply
to the following terms, except where the context of this Agreement
otherwise requires:
(a) Project: The preparation of maps, surveys,
reports, and documents, the presentation, both oral and in writing,
of such plans, maps, surveys, reports and documents to CITY as
required and attendance at any and all work sessions, public
hearings and other meetings conducted by CITY with respect to the
project.
(b) Services: Such professional engineering
services as are necessary to be performed by CONSULTANT in order to
complete the Project.
(c) Completion of Project: The date of completion
of all phases of the Project, including any and all procedures,
development plans, maps, surveys, plan documents, technical
reports, meetings, oral presentations and attendance by CONSULTANT
at public hearings will be determined by the CITY.
2. CONSULTANT agrees as follows:
(a) CONSULTANT shall forthwith undertake and
complete the project in accordance with Exhibits "A" hereto and all
in accordance with Federal, State and CITY statues, regulations,
ordinances and guidelines, all to the reasonable satisfaction of
CITY and in accordance to the standard of care normally provided by
practitioners of the engineering profession.
2
(b) CONSULTANT shall supply copies of all maps,
surveys, reports, plans and documents (hereinafter collectively
referred to as "documents") including all supplemental technical
documents, as described in Exhibits "A" to CITY within the time
specified by the CITY. Copies of the documents shall be in such
numbers as are required by Exhibit "A". CITY may thereafter review
and forward to CONSULTANT comments regarding said documents and
CONSULTANT shall thereafter make such revisions to said documents
as are deemed necessary. CITY shall receive revised documents in
such form and in the quantities determined necessary by CITY. The
time limits set forth pursuant to this Section B2.(b) may be
extended upon written approval of CITY.
(c) CONSULTANT shall, at CONSULTANT's sole cost and
expense, secure and hire such other persons as may, in the opinion
of CONSULTANT, be necessary to comply with the terms of this
Agreement. In the event any such other persons are retained by
CONSULTANT, CONSULTANT hereby warrants that such persons shall be
fully qualified to perform services required hereunder. CONSULTANT
further agrees that no subcontractor shall be retained by
CONSULTANT except upon the prior written approval of CITY.
3. CITY agrees as follows:
(a) To pay CONSULTANT a maximum sum of $37,020 for
the performance of the services required hereunder. This sum shall
cover the cost of all staff time and all other direct and indirect
costs or fees, including the work of employees, consultants and
subcontractors to CONSULTANT. Payment to CONSULTANT, by CITY,
M
shall be made in accordance with the schedule set forth belITY in
(b) payments to CONSULTANT shall be made by
a monthly
accordance with the invoices submitted bWCONSULTANT, on
basis, and such invoices shall be paid within thirty (30) days of
invoices. The CONSULTANT shall detail the
receipt of CONSULTANT and employee
number, hours worked,
project task it
charges by prof if
ions, total not to exceed amount for the project ed if it
classifications, and percent completed
is a time -and -material basis project,
charges shall be in
accordance
is a lump sum basis project- All respect to hourly rates or
with CONSULTANT'S prop°sal either with
tasks.
lump sum amounts for individual in no event, shall CITY
(c) CONSULTANT agrees that,
a to CONSULTANT any sum in
excess of 90% of the
be required to pay CITY of all final
maximum payable hereunder prior to receipt by
supplemental technical
documents, as
documents, together with all Supp to CITY. Final
form and content
in
described _herein acceptableSixty (60) days after
made not later than
payment shall be CITY.
ion of final documents and acceptance thereof by
presentation ipayments for additional
(d) Additional services:
by CITY, and
not included in
requested, in writing, shall be
services Exhibit "A" hereof,
CONSULTANT'S proposal as set forth in services
Charges for additional
paid on a reimbursement basis. on a aid by CITY
invoiced monthly basis and shall be p
shall be
t g0) days after said invoices are received by CITY.
within thirty
4
4 . CIaa_— S tg pry a to CONSUT TANT_:
TY in
(a) Information
and assistance as set forth
Exhibit "A" hereto. copies of maps
(b) Photographically reproducible
ionif available, which CONSULTANT Considers
and other information, Project.
necessary in order to complete the
(c)
Such information as is generally available from
Project .
CITY files applicable to the in obtaining
Assistance, if necessary,
(d) agencies and/or private
information from other governmental to make
Wever, it shall be CONSULTANT's responsibility
parties. Ho to the gathering of such
all initial contact with respect
information. documents, data,
All
Ownership of Documents: reports
5. hs and rep
s models, photographs
surveys, drawings, map shall be
studies, to this Agreement
CONSULTANT pursuant
prepared by u on payment for services
considered the property p
of CITY and, identified
CON
performed by
documents and
other
CONSULTANT, such
CONSULTANT. CONSULTANT
materials shall be delivered to CITY by
such copies of said documents and
may, however, make and retain
T may desire. CONSULTANT shall not be held
materials as CONSULTANT other than
liable for use of such documents by CITY for purposes
intended by the Agreement. interminated by
reement may be term
6. Termation: This Ag to
CITY upon the giving
of a written "Notice of Termination"
date of
CON S
ULTANT at least fifteen (15) days prior to the
5
if in said Notice. In the event this Agreement
termination spec
terminated, CONSULTANT shall be compensated at. CONSULTANTIS
is so t "A'it ,on a pro -rata
applicable hourly rates as set forth in Exhibit
basis with respect to the percentage of the Project completed as of
of termination. in no event, however, shall CONSULTANT
the date paragraph 3(a), above.
receive more than the maximum specified in p
ONSULTANT shall provide to CITY any and all documents,
data,
C hs and reports,
studies, surveys, drawings
maps, models, Photographs
whether in draft or final form, prepared by CONSULTANT as of the
date of termination. CONSULTANT may not terminate this Agreement
except for cause. Any and all
7. Not_ i_ and nesianated Re resentatives:
demands, invoices and written communicat
pions between t7e
notices, aragraph
arties hereto shall be addressed as set forth in this hose persons
p.
furthermore, shall be t
The below named individuals, the parties under this
primarily responsible for the performance by
Agreement:
CITY: David G. Liu
Department of Public Works
City of Diamond Bar Suite 190
21660 E. Copley Drive,
Diamond Bar, CA 91765
CONSULTANT: John C Whitman Inc.
Dwight French & Associates, Drive, Ste. 140
1470 S. Valley Vista
Diamond Bar, CA 91765
otices, demands, invoices and written communications, by
Any such n the addressee
mail, shall be deemed to have been received by
forty-eight (48) hours after deposit thereof in the United States
6
mail, p
ostage prepaid and properly addressed as set forth above.
g. Insurance: CONSULTANT shall neither commence work,
fired
A reement until it has obtained all insurance recti all
under this g
in a company or companies acceptable to CITY nor s
hereunder work on a
CONSULTANT allow any subconsultant
to commence
subcontract until all insurance required of the subconsultant has
finedCONSULTANT shall take out and maintain at all time
been obtained. policies of
during the term of this Agreement the following P
insurance:Before
(a) Worms
..,,,,,,,,.,Pasation Insurance:
work, CONSULTANT shall furnish to CITY a certificate Of
n
beginning w � compensation
insurance as proof that it has taken out full workers or through
employ directly
insurance for all persons whom it may
out the work sP
ecif ied herein, in
subconsultants in
carrying
accordance with the laws of the State of California-
In
alifornia•In accordance with the provisions of California
Labor Code Section 3700, every employer shall secure the payment of compensation to his emp prior to commencing
employees. CONSULTANT
Y
work,
shall sign and file with CITY a certification as follows:of
ovi am aware of the provisions of Section
or Code which require every employer to be insured against
Lab
workers' compensation or to undertake self insuranc
liabilit y for woand I will comply
in accordance with the provisions of that Code,
with such provisions before commencing the performance of the work
of this Agreement."
7
(b) Public Liability and Proper v Damage: Throughout
the term of this Agreement, at CONSULTANT's sole cost and expense,
CONSULTANT shall keep, or cause to be kept, in full force and
effect, for the mutual benefit of CITY and CONSULTANT,
comprehensive, broad form, general public liability and automobile
insurance against claims and liabilities for personal injury,
death, or property damage arising from CONSULTANT's activities,
providing protection of at least One Million Dollars
($1,000.000.00) for property damage, bodily injury or death to any
one person or for any one accident or occurrence and One Million
Dollars ($1,000,000.00) aggregate.
(c) Errors and Omissions: CONSULTANT shall take out and
maintain at all times during the life of this Agreement, a policy
or policies of insurance concerning errors and omissions
("malpractice") providing protection of at least One Million
Dollars ($1,000,000.00) per claim and in the aggregate for errors
and omissions ("malpractice") with respect to loss arising from
actions of CONSULTANT performing the Project hereunder on behalf of
CITY.
(d) General Insurance Requirements: All insurance
required by express provision of this Agreement shall be carried
only in responsible insurance companies licensed to do business in
the State of California and policies required under. paragraphs
8.(a) and (b) shall name as additional insured CITY, its elected
Officials, officers, employees, agents and representatives. All
8
policies shall contain language, to the extent obtainable that:
(1) the insurer, except the errors and omissions insurer, waives,
the right of subrogation against CITY and CITY's elected officials,
officers, employees, agents and representatives; (2) the policies
are primary and noncontributing with any insurance that may be
carried by CITY; and (3) they cannot be canceled or materially
changed except after thirty (30) days' notice by the insurer to
CITY by certified mail. CONSULTANT shall furnish CITY with copies
of all such policies promptly upon receipt of them, or certificate
evidencing the insurance. CONSULTANT may effect for its own
account insurance not required under this Agreement.
9. Indemnification: CONSULTANT shall defend, indemnify
and save harmless CITY, its elected and appointed officials,
officers, agents and employees, from all liability from loss,
damage or injury to persons or property, including the payment by
CONSULTANT of any and all legal costs and attorneys' fees, in any
manner arising out of the negligent, intentional and/or willful
acts and/or omissions of CONSULTANT pursuant to this Agreement,
including, but not limited to, all consequential damages, to the
maximum extent permitted by law.
10. Assignment: No assignment of this Agreement or of
any part or obligation of performance hereunder shall be made,
either in whole or in part, by CONSULTANT without the prior written
consent of CITY.
11. Damages: In the event that CONSULTANT fails to
submit to CITY the completed project, together with all documents
and supplemental material required hereunder, in public hearing
form to the reasonable satisfaction of CITY, within the time set
forth herein, or as may be extended by written consent of the
parties hereto, CONSULTANT shall pay to CITY, as liquidated damages
and not as a penalty, the sum of Two Hundred dollars ($200.00) per
day for each day CONSULTANT is in default, which sum represents a
reasonable endeavor by the parties hereto to estimate a fair
compensation for the foreseeable losses that might result from such
a default in performance by CONSULTANT, and due to the difficulty
which would otherwise occur in establishing actual damages
resulting from such default, unless said default is caused by CITY
or by acts of God, acts of the public enemy, fire, floods,
epidemics, or quarantine restrictions.
12. Independent Contractor: The parties hereto agree
that CONSULTANT and its employers, officers and agents are
independent contractors under this Agreement and shall not be
construed for any purpose to be employees of CITY.
13. Governing Law: This Agreement shall be governed by
and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of
California.
: In the event any legal proceeding
14. Attorney's Fees
is instituted to enforce any term or provision of the Agreement,
the prevailing party in said legal proceeding shall be entitled to
recover attorneys' fees and costs from the opposing party in an
amount determined by the court to be reasonable.
10
15. Mediation' Any dispute or controversy
arising under
or in connection with any
Of the terms and
this Agreement,
conditions hereof, shall be referred by the parties hereto for
A third party,
neutral mediation service shall e
mediation. expenses
elected, as agreed upon by the parties and the costs and
s In the event
thereof shall be borne equally by the parties hereto.
'es are unable to mutually agree upon the mediator to be
the parte
selected hereunder, the City Council shall select such a neutra ,
t mediation service and the City Council's decision shall
third party megood faith efforts to
be final. The parties agree to utilize their
n such dispute or controversy so submitted to mediation.
resolve any par
and
hereto that
It is specifically understood and agreed by the p
and mutual good faith
referral of any such dispute or controversy, precedent
efforts to resolve the same thereby, shall be conditions p
to the institution of any action or proceeding, whether at law or
in equity with respect to any such dispute or controversy.
This Agreement supersedes any and
16. Entire Agreement: between the
all other agreements, either oral or
in writing,
parties with respect to the subject matter herein. Each party to
this Agreement acknowledges that no representation by any party
Other agreement, statement,
promise not contained in this Ag or
which is not embodied herein nor anyreement shall be valid and binding,
if it is
An modification of this Agreement shall be effective only
Y
in writing signed by all parties.
11
NESS
WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this
IN WIT
e day and year first set forth above:
Agreement as of th
CONSULTANT:
Dwight French and Associates, Inc.
Name and Title
Approved As To Form:
City. Attorney
CITY OF DIAMOND BAR
ATTEST: City Clerk
12
Mayor
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council
FROM: Councilwoman Eileen Ansari
RE: Council Sub -Committee For Library Services
DATE: April 19,1994
ISSUE:
Shall the City Council establish a sub -committee of the
Council for library services liaison and related matters?
RECOMMENDATION•
It is recommended that the Mayor appoint a Library Services
sub -committee of the City Council, comprised of two members
of the Council.
DISCUSSION•
The community of Diamond Bar is provided library services
through the County of Los Angeles Library District. The
District has suffered significant reductions in revenue, as
a consequence of State of California legislation which has
shifted property taxes, from County revenues, thereby
adversely affecting the full funding of library services.
The City recently provided short-term (March through June
funding support to the Library District to add two days of
library services, to the three days of County funded
services. There continues to be a need to communicate with
the County, the Library District, library user and support
groups, other cities and the State legislature regarding the
future provision of library services. A Council Library
sub -committee is an effective mechanism to accomplish such
objectives.
1:1 • ' II I
TO: It
ismond Har City council
gRCK; JUtan G. Tucker
Z
DATE: March 1, 1994
RE: Public Records Issue
Z.
INTRODUCTION.
This office waa requested by the Interim City Attorney to
follow up on our previous opinion regarding the public record
status of Councilmember nary Miller's personal financial documents
which were used in the formation of a 'no conflict' opinion by the
former City Attorney. There appears to be two major issues
involved. The first issue is whether such records are 'public, for
the purpose of dissemination to the general populace. The second
issue is whether such records would be available for review by the
other members of the City Council. Theme issues are discussed
separately below.
1. We reiterate our previous opinion that a city attorney's
review of personal financial documents of i councilemmber for the
purpose of rendering a conflict of interest opinion does not
necessarily serve to transform these documents into 'public
records' under the Public Records Act. As previously noted, the
Act provi&W a "catch-all" exception to public disclosure
requirements if there is no applicable statutory exception. This
exception states that a document is not subject to public
disclosure it 'on the tacts of the particular case the public
interest served by not making the record public, clearly outweighs
PSTO 1544% cooiuos . OOMJ%
n
d by disclosure of the record.' i
obtains personal financial docume
m s from the subject individual.
The IFppC does not consider such documents as automatically becoming
public Me= Y because they were used in forming the opinion. FPPC
file documents are seg2egated into -disclosures and "nondisclosure'
categories for the purpose of public Recorder Act, requests. . I"!s
Turvill stated that financial records which are already public,
Interests filed by all public
such as the Statement of gconomic rsonal financial
the ypPC. How®vor. P�
officers, are disclosed by lic disclosure- such
documents which are not normally
subject to pub
as personal checks, personal transaction records.
Of tax zero=s'
are Most often not considered subject to disclosure under the
public Records Act and are placed in the 'nondisclosures Portion of
n subject to a
the file. Therefore, eves if this matter had is likely i.kelY that the
full investigation and opinion by
the FPpC, it
subject to public dissemination.
docusyaats at issue would not �
In the present situation, the question of whether the
lac is now
documents reviewed by the former City
Attorney are pub
moot because the City does not even have Po
esession of any of those
ts and has no way Of responding to a public Records Act
docume,nled to the present
nts ase subsequently revue
request. I! the documents ect to
Attorney, we believe that they would still not be subj
Cit y
disclosure to the public at large under the public Records Act for
the reasons Previously stated.
"W second issue i9 whether information revealed to a
3.
tonne by one councilmereber mube revealed to the oe
ity attorney
r embe
re of the council. There are differing visas on this issue int,
and there does not appear to be any case law directly o
-3•
ps111101015�1'S��tt�x- (n101M
The argument against revealing such information is that it wculd
further t*
, public policy of full disclosure of facts to the city
attorney without concern that these facts will be disseminated to
others. This policy was furthered in the present situation, as Mr.
Miller's voluntary disclosure of confidential information permitted
the former City Attorney to render a more informed opinion than
otherwise would have been possible. The argument in favor of
disclosure to the other councilamembers would be that the City
itself is the client and the entire council constitutes the
decisionmaking body of that entity.
In the present situation, even if the attorney-client
privilege was inapplicable vis-a-vis the other four members of the
council, the privilege would still apply as between the Council as
a whole and the rest of the public. The attorney-client privilege
applies to public agency clients even outside the purview of the
Brown Act procedures (gQbgrts v Ci y of P lMda" (1993) 5 Cail.4th
363), and a public officer is entitled to claim the privilege to
prevent public disclosure of requested information falling within
the scope of that privilege. (70 Op. Atty.Gen. 28 (1987).)
Therefore, even if there is no barrier to other Councilmembers,
review of whatever documents Mr. Miller may choose to later provide
to the City Attorney, we believe that the documents would still not
be subject to public disclosure because (1) they are subject to
5 6255 of the Public Records Act, and (Z) they are subject to the
attorney-client privilege.
We will be happy to answer any questions the Council may have
concerning this matter.
�t+x�owiuis.aoo�ua�la. miou" -4-
the council► as a
SEL 8 ti���T�(1!1ERl' ttorneY
represents
ef confident'
onf dentialityo ri as
of of
� city privilege Was very b vel
e ted t° the extension
2. I e hoe 6► 1994►
body, of January be eleva n on at, Let me
b itial opent the issue e that °purrent trerated at the
MY did e eat Concer I' t b ev i from e p ast L ague meeting
its pr which a passagesat the
of ward, of the
tions With
recite comn►unica ors an
City Attorney s City attorney s super°ithe city
October 1993: the C kept seCru if xe berthef full city
be u11Y
1 • members tions tWith conf idenadivI ch tY al from void misjcjale der_
staff
f communiot be keg tant that order to a
council cannot.
alt is r ncipal in t their
ri ed
Council• this p stand that
understand understand
not p tion'
musIza
standings • t °f f i the s c ty stw� thin the
e rney i nsnp mpo de
2• „Cis with u ervis( some sit it is s or
cation to s p may in ttorneY► f member or
uni ure d e a taf ember comm eos owls g e city to s memo e
disch this kn with th unictted a staff with th
E en
though
t be Comm counci1 before unicat36 s Will be
an nk that f his the f city ounc 1 have
a e a. t y believe
members of the rr
cit the personadvise
members that torneys to
council
memb ity attor de tial•„ some
City a ose to the has been
Confi of s disci
kept
The pract th Y Wilt rest adv thus appears t° be
3. cies that of in member
Cozen flict 1 Council _6p0j• oun-
their any c 11
on Rule [3 offer of C
itself an inaividf this d the off documents►
s _
given e t violation °f decline of the condi
in dir foregoing evi w ►. copies his able to maintain his
f r
For the Miller I would not be our ultimate
te
Gilman I felt ality' that if your
be a tion of confidenti s reQuest d statutory or
an Harmon fro a min of erence .
hat
Councilor differs
opini°itY it provided for r
be
author
CC: City Of
f Dia and anager Bar
city
LAW OFFICES
MICHAEL B. MONTGOMERY
A LAW CORPORATION
13200 CROSSROADS PARKWAY NORTH
SUITE 350
CITY OF INDUSTRY, IFORNIA 9174a
TELEPHONE (310V'08-1850
FACSIMILE (310) 908-1854
ALSO ADMITTED TO FLORIDA
AND HAWAII STATE BARS
TO: Leonard Hemphill
Robert Owen
MEMORANDUM
FROM: Interim City Attorney
DATE: February 18, 1994
OF COUNSEL
MATTHEW C. BISHOP
ALAN R. BURNS'
JOHN ROBERT HARPER
NAPA COUNTY OFFICE
1475 FOURTH STREET
NAPA, CALIFORNIA 04550
(707) 258-8090
ORANGE COUNTY OFFICE
453 S. GLASSELL STREET
ORANGE, CALIFORNIA
92008
(714) 771.7728
WENDY D. DAWER
RE: Your Public Records Opinion of February 15, 1994.
The City Council, at its meeting of February 15, 1994,
decided to take you up on your generous offer to, "discuss
this matter further if the Council so desires".
As I discussed with Leonard on the phone, there is no
dispute with your opinion, so far as it goes. Certainly
the mere fact that a writing is in the possession of the
public, does not make it a public record, nor does the
mere fact that the City Attorney happens to review it.
One point is significant, and that is that the question
may well be moot. Mr. Arczynski's letter of February 1,
1994, states, " . . . if I had the documents, I would not
divulge the same; however, since I do not, the point is
somewhat academic, is it not?" My inquiry was not
concerned with the subject matter of the documents, but
simply whether or not the documents were public records.
Along that line, at least two unanswered questions remain:
1. If the City Attorney happens to review the
documents in his official position as City Attorney, by a
Councilmember who intends to, and then does, rely and act
on the City Attorney's opinion re conflict of interest,
and at public meetings, then is the populace at large
entitled to review the documents upon which the City
Attorney, based his opinion of "no conflict"? You may
wish to add to the quotient the fact that the votes in
this case could affect the permanent nature and character
of the community in that the issues involved general plan
adoption and major discretionary land use permits for
major developments; and
M am<�rts r�c�um\Hc�impFit 1 L\Owaan
Page 1
JAMES L. MARKMAN
AN OREW v..RCZYNSK1
RALPH O. HANSOM
JEFFREY K'NO f
0. CRAIG rCx
WILLIAM P. _URLEY CU
MARSHA G. SLOUGH
JJLIA A. KEMP
PAMELA P. KING
HERIBERTO F. OIAZ
BONNIE BAILEY -JONES
.W �� �Ot I[O�b NUMBER ONE CIVIC CEN -ER P--=
P O Box 059
February 1, 1994
Michael Montgomery
13200 Crossroads Parkway
Suite 350
Industry, California 91786
BREA.CALIFORNIA 92622- X53
(71x1 990-09C
TELEPHONE `13101 69'-19"
9113 FOOTHILL GMLE14At24-
SUITE 200
RANCHO CUCAMONGA-M'"C" OK
TELEPHONE 1 I - •R'
��aop�el-oars;- ,C.
IN REPLY PLEAg�'R[FE��y; G
77
n
Brea -
Q11
M
Re: Your correspondence of January 6, 1994
Dear Mr. Montgomery:
It is the purpose of this correspondence to some respond
to yours of January 6, 19941 which appears to relay
ort
of public record request from one Terri Birrell pertaining to
documents and records with regard to the non -issue of Diamond
Bar Councilmember Gary Miller's involvement in the somewhat
ou are
euphemistically titled "south Pointe Master Plan." As Y
undoubtedly well aware, Mr. Miller, at one had
asouth
interest in a portion of the real property within
Pointe Area. Having divested himself ofany
interest
tto the pin the
subject property well over one (1) y
ear ect
application being filed, I provided the quite unremarkable
opinion that, pursuant to the requirements and strictures of
the Political Reform Act of 1974 (California Government Code §§
87000, st seq.), the provisions of which I understand you are
passing familiar, Mr Miller had no conflict under the law.
As a result of that divestiture, and the time frame
involved, it was abundantly clear to all that Mr. miller ensure
no
conflict of interest. Yet, in an attempt on his partand
to that "politics" did not enter the fray, Mr. millers imply early
unequivocally announced to all and sundry
that hnot participate in the deliberations on the project. In fact,
as your self-styled "citizens group" client must recall, Mr.
Miller even went so far as to totally absent himself from
meetings at which it was discussed (and, while Mayor, handing
hahae actions on the
over the gavel to the Mayor Pro Tempore)• the were
part of Mr. Miller were not only unavailing, Y
virtually counterproductive. In hindsight, if Mr. Miller was
to be subject to the personal abuse, venomous attacks and
Michael Montgomery
February 1, 1994
Page Two
f
vituperative slurs of members of the public in any event, he
probably should have participated.
Your desire to serve as a conduit to the public under
a purported Public Records Act (California Government Code §§
6250, at seq.) request perplexes me. I know of no attorney
representing cities in California who considers his or her
files to be available to the public under the California Public
Records Act. To presume that such files are available
thereunder strikes me as the height of folly and would, if
nothing else, eviscerate the salutary purposes of the
attorney-client privilege. Moreover, to simply share, with all
who have some chimerical need to rummage in the affairs of a
public official, the most personal of documents, including tax
returns and the like, is the antithesis of the zealous
safeguarding of a client's matters required of those of us who
attempt to honorably engage in the profession of law.
As I have stated, with some frequency, to
Councilmembers (including your erstwhile clients Ms. Ansari and
Messers. Harmony and Werner) I will not, and do not, share such
auricular matters with the merely inquisitive who purport to
espouse a "need to know". To do so would set at naught the
ability to provide thoughtful counsel to those requesting the
same. We take on faith that you would not remonstrate your
clients to forthrightly and candidly share all of the facts and
documents necessary to a thoroughgoing analysis of the client's
lot, all the while knowing that you will simply divulge the
aggregate thereof to any who inquire. That approach would,
doubtless, produce a client unwilling to impart, frankly, the
true state of the facts since, perforce, all will be presented
in the public domain and the postulate for candid analysis will
be reduced to absurdity.
Stated otherwise, if one's client cannot feel secure
that what is conveyed to one's lawyer goes no further, there
seems little, if any point, to the exercise. The client will
simply provide a factual presentation that puts him or her in
the best light or, worse, will enshroud the pertinent data all
with the deleterious effects as have been visited upon others
unable or unwilling to confide in their counsel the unvarnished
truth. The lawyer's role will, then, be reduced to the
provision of an endless stream of homilies or truisms, with a
dollop of twaddle thrown in for good measure.
Michael Montgomery
February 1, 1994
page Three
1` Leaving all of that aside, as manifestly statedto
your client, Max Maxwell, in September of the year last pa
all of the documents provided by Mr. Miller were returned to
Mr. Miller and not retained by this office for reasons which
should be abundantly clear, even to those who seek the
documents. To assert that this office "lost" the same is
laughable and requires no further response.
In summary then, if I
divulge the same; however, since
somewhat academic, is it not?
Very ly yours,,
Andrew V. Arczynski
AVA:Clf
C\loll\LMONTG
had the documents, I would not
I do not, the point is
cc: Councilmember Gary Miller
bcc: Terrance Belanger, City Manager
uw O/SCU
MICHAEL B. MONTGOMERY
A LAW CORPORATION
1BBao
CII0118101006 PAWWAY NORTH
am no
CITY OF INIXXTaY. G YCF*M 01740
TREPHIM 9141 $*Iwo
F"Tf! Sm 104
ALSO AD1s"ED TO FLORIDA
AND MAWM STATE BARS
KEWRANDUM
TO: Mayor and Members of the City Council
City of Diamond Aar
THROUGH: City Manager
FROM: Intorim City Attorn
DATV: January G. 1994
SUWECT: Separate Legal Opinions
OF COUNSEL
MATTHEW C. BISHOP
ALAN R. BURNS'
JOHN ROSEM HARPER'
NAPA COUNTY OFFICE
1475 FOURTM STREET
NAPA, CALNORNIA 04660
(►0712054000
ORANGE COUNTY OFFICE
4413 S. GL,ASSEU STREET
ORANGE. CALIFORNIA
son
t714) r71-7720
"PWAnow ealao4. —
WENDY 0. DAWER
I havo received the enclosed request for an opinion from
Couneilmember Papen. I am responding to tho Counall an a whole,
because I am unclear of the Council's policy re individual opinion
requests.
mrst, responding to Atte. Popon's question, the appollate decision in
ward v. SuRgrior Court, 1977, 70 Cal. App.3d 23, 138 Cal. Rptr.
32, provides that then can be no separate attorney-client
relationship between the public a`enoy attorney and each separate
officer. As stated at palls 33, "He in no vise represents the officers
personally." Therefore, these is no attorney-client relationship
botween the attorney and the individual members of the council. No
such relationship udsting, any records given to me in my capacity as
City Attorney, would of neosssity have to be turned over to the City
Clerk.
As to the nomad part of the request, porsonuel and disciplinary
matters are exempt fr m disclosure, whore the release "would
con Ututo an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy." GoYISEA nt
Code IM4.
w
I N* the council to clarify whether or not the City Attorney is
eapeoied to respond to individual opinion requests .
JAMES L. MARKMAN
ANDREW V. ANCZYNSKI
RALPH 0. HANSON
JEFFREY KING
0. CRAIG FOX
WILLIAM P. CURLEY DT
MARSHA G. SLOUGH
JULIA A. KEMP
PAMELA P. KING
HERIBERTO F. DIAZ
BONNIE SAILEY•JONES
eA 9d'
A� & V CVA
NUMBER ONE CIVIC CENTER CIRCLE
September 24, 1993
Max Maxwell
3211 Bent Twig Lane
Diamond Bar, California 91765
Re: Yours of August 10, 1993
Dear Mr. Maxwell:
P O. UI[ 1059
6R[A.CALIFORNIA 92622•IOSO
17141 990-0901
TELEPHONE
13101 9 9 1-3 6 1 1
9113 FOOTHILL BOULEVARD
SUITE 200
RANCHO CUCAMONrGA.CAUFORNIA 9,730
119130 960-2742
TEL[RHONE
Qis091 3 1111 -o 21 e
IN RMY PLEASE REFER TO:
Brea
This correspondence is in response to yours of August
10, 1993 with regard to a request for information pertaining to
Mayor Miller's alleged conflict of interest concerning the
South Pointe project.
Preliminarily, let me point out that I have spoken
with Mr. Montgomery with regard to corresponding with you,
directly, and Mr. Montgomery, on September 22, 1993, indicated
that he has no concerns with my direct correspondence with you.
Additionally, it must be noted that your correspondence was
directed to me at the City Hall. As you may know, I do not
maintain an office presence at the Diamond Bar City Hall on a
daily basis and, accordingly, mail `directed to as at that
location is collected by the City Clark's office and forwarded
to me. Unfortunately, the letter dated August 10, 1993 was not
received by the undersigned until shortly after September 9,
1993.
Specifically with regard to your query, please be
advised that I have reviewed the files pertaining to Mr.
Miller's interests, or more appropriately, lack thereof,
vis-a-vis the South Points area. As you may know, the matter
is considWmad by this office to be attorney-client privileged
as to aq information presented to me by Mr. Miller and,
additionally, any information provided by this office to Mr.
Miller with regard to the topic in question or related topics.
However, Mr. Miller has specifically instructed me to
correspond with you on the topic and to provide whatever
r
n=D THIS DATE
TOt Michael Montgomery, Interis Cit ttorney
PACK: Phyllis PiPen, Councilmembe
LUTE s January 5, 1991
$UgJZCT: Attorney -Client privilsgs of Couneilmembers
CC: Terry Belanger, City Manager
At the conclusion of last nights council meeting or rather early
this morning (Approx. 3:0Sam), Mr. Harmony raised an issue
regarding attorney client privilege for counciJ.smbers.
picas• provide the council with the bacrovad ialoss►Stion, S
discussion Of the issue, your opinion.amcode Section, etc. that
would support your opinion.
ii I understand your statement, Couneilmembers proprietary
personal, business or financial inlomation is not confidential.
Does this also APPLY to Personnel files? Diicipiinary actions?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
CALL TO ORDER:
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE:
ROLL CALL:
Next Resolution No. 94-21
Next Ordinance No. 03(1994)
6:00 p.m.
Mayor Werner
Council Members Ansari, Papen,
Miller, Mayor Pro Tem Harmony
and Mayor Werner
SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS, PROCLAMATIONS, CERTIFICATES, ETC.:
CLOSED
PUBLIC COMMENTS:
CLOSED
COUNCIL COMMENTS:
CLOSED
SCHEDULE OF FUTURE EVENTS:
CLOSED
CONSENT CALENDAR:
CLOSED
PUBLIC HEARINGS:
NONE
OLD BUSINESS:
8.1 SECOND READING OF ORDINANCE NO. 02(1994): AN ORDINANCE
OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DIAMOND BAR AMENDING
TITLE 22 OF THE LOS ANGELES CODE BY ADDING NEW CHAPTER
22.54 AND ESTABLISHING PROPERTY MAINTENANCE STANDARDS -
On April 19, 1994, the City Council held a public
hearing, received testimony, waived full reading, and
approved as amended, Ordinance No. 02(1994). Continued
from May 3, 1994.
Recommended Action: It is recommended that the City
Council approve for second reading and adopt Ordinance
No. 02(1994).
Requested by: Community Development Director
8.2 ENGINEERING SERVICES CONTRACT FOR THE DEVELOPMENT AND
IMPLEMENTATION OF A PAVEMENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM - In
accordance with the requirements of Prop. 111 for State
Gas Tax Fund and the criteria stipulated by the Prop. C
Local Return Guidelines, local jurisdictions must certify
that it has in place a pavement management system (PMS).
This is to foster the cost-effective use of public funds
prior to expending Prop. C funds. The system needs to
provide an overview of the condition of the total street
W
Max Maxwell
September 24 1993
Page Two
inforPRtion I may have in
to me.; Accordingly, MY Possession which he
notwithstandingthe Mr- Miller has has provided
with the attorney-clientinstructed me,
YOU regarding the mattrprivilege, to correspond
provided toymereview of our files reveals that the information
destroyed b Y Mr. Miller was returned to Mr.
ion
Stated otherwise, °ffice after review b Miller or
personal It is not my normal y the undersigned,
confidential records either Ofaat=Ce tO maintain
individual nature with regard to business or
interest matters, clients on conflict of
request of the client typically return such do
any inadvertent release of the same in Orrice ato, or, at the
information• Accordingly,personal, private and preclude
request, this office does with regardtoour
supplied to us, maintain the material whichwas
very trulY Yours,
raw V. Arczynskf
City Attorney
AVA/nic City of Diamond Bar
N\1011\LXAXnL.L\DB 28.1
cc: Mayor Gary Miller (transmitted'b
Y fax)
Max Maxwell
3111 Bent Twig Ln.
Diamond Bar, CA 91765
714 861-4121
1p
Andrew'Arczynski, City Attorney
City of Diamond Bar
21660 E. Copley Dr., Ste. 100
Diamond Bar, CA 91765
Dear Andrew Arczynski;
August 10, 1993
I am requesting copies of the information Mayor Gary Miller
submitted to your office that clearly states his position on not
having a conflict of interest in the South Pointe Master Plan, or
the R -N -P Development Inc. properties.
Gary Miller stated publicly that this information is available from
your office many months ago. I have already asked for this
information, however all the City gave me is a letter dated January
5, 1993 addressed to Councilman John Forbinq, where Gary Miller
stated his position as: "The purpose of this letter is to inform
my city Council colleagues that I have made a decision to not be
involved in either the processing of nor the decisions relating to
one of the maps that has been submitted (Map No. VTM 51407) that is
a part of the South Pointe Master Plan."
The above statement is NOT a clarification of Gary Miller's
potential conflict of interest, nor does it meet the requirements
Of supplying to the public enough material to clarify the issue.
Please forward the material that Gary Miller has submitted. If
the above letter is all that exists, please respond in writing to
clarify the matter.
Thank you,
Max Maxwell
LRT RL"CY MIL.l7
MAY 9, 1994 PAGE 2
system, a means of documenting street maintenance/
rehabilitation needs, and a means of rationally
prioritizing street improvement projects in terms of
needs and cost-effectiveness. To accomplish this work,
it is necessary to retain the services of a qualified
engineering firm. In response to the City's Request
for Proposal, the Selection Committee received and
evaluated four (4) proposals.
Recommended Action: It is recommended that the City
Council award a professional engineering services
contract to Dwight French and Associates in an amount not
to exceed $37,020.00, plus a contingency amount of
$3,000.
Requested by: City Engineer
8.3 DISCUSSION RE: COUNCIL SUB -COMMITTEE FOR LIBRARY
SERVICES - Continued from May 3, 1994.
Recommended Action: It is recommended that the Mayor
appoint a Library Services sub -committee of the City
Council, comprised of two members of the Council.
Requested by: Councilwoman Ansari
8.4 MATTER OF REQUEST FOR INFORMATION FROM FORMER CITY
ATTORNEY - Continued from May 3, 1994.
Requested by: Mayor Pro Tem Harmony
9. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING/CITY COUNCIL & PLANNING COMMISSION
JOINT MEETING - 7:00 P.M.
9.1 DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT NOS. 92-1 AND 2; VESTING TENTATIVE
TRACT MAP NO. 51407, CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-8;
VESTING TENTATIVE TRACT NO. 32400, CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
NO. 91-5, AND OAK TREE PERMIT NO. 92-8; VESTING TENTATIVE
TRACT MAP 32400, CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 91-5, AND OAK
TREE PERMIT NO. 92-3; TENTATIVE TRACT MAP NO. 51253 AND
CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-12; OAK TREE PERMIT NO.
92-9; THE SOUTH POINTE MASTER PLAN; AND ENVIRONMENTAL
IMPACT REPORT NO. 91-1 - This is a joint public hearing
of the City Council and Planning Commission to consider
a request for approval of a mixed use project, known as
South Pointe Master Plan, consisting of land uses which
include residential, commercial, park, open space and
school facilities. The project site is approximately 171
acres in size and is located north of Pathfinder Rd.,
west of Brea Canyon Rd., east of Morning Sun Dr., and
south of Rapid View Dr. The project proposes to develop
30 acres of commercial retail/office space of 290,000 sq.
ft.; approximately 200 single-family detached residential
dwelling units, a 28 acre neighborhood park; and the
construction of a middle school. Continued from May 2,
PAGE 3
MAy 9, 1994
1994. that the City
It is recommended that
Recommended Action: Colmission receive a a the public
Council and Planning project developers; open
from City staff and Pro 7 and take appropriate action.
hearing; receive testimony;
Requested by: M/Werner
10. ANNOUNCEMENTS* -
11. ADJOURNMENT'
k `a 1
CITY OF DIAMOND BAR
AGENDA REPORT
AGENDA NO. '�4 , j
TO: Terrence L. Belanger, City Manager
MEETING DATE: May 9, 1994 REPORT DATE: April 26, 1994
FROM: James DeStefano, Community Development Director Revised May 5, 1994
TITLE: Development Agreement Nos. 92-1 and 2; Vesting Tentative Tract Map No. 51407, Conditional Use
Permit No. 92-8 and Oak Tree Permit No. 92-8; Vesting Tentative Tract No. 32400, Conditional Use Permit No.
91-5, and Oak Tree Permit No. 91-2; Tentative Tract Map No. 51253 and Conditional Use Permit No. 92-12;
Oak Tree Permit No. 92-9; the South Pointe Master Plan; and Environmental Impact Report No. 92-1.
SUMMARY: This is a joint public hearing of the City Council and Planning Commission to consider a request
for approval of a mixed use project, known as the South Pointe Master Plan, consisting of land uses which include
residential, commercial, park, open space and school facilities. The project site is approximately 171 acres in size
and is located north of Pathfinder Road, west of Brea Canyon Road, east of Morning Sun Drive, and south of
Rapid View Drive. The project proposes to develop 30 acres of commercial retail/office space of 290,000 square
feet; approximately 200 single-family detached residential dwelling units, a 28 acre neighborhood park; and the
construction of a middle school.
RECOMMENDATION: It is recommended that the City Council and Planning Commission receive a
presentation from City Staff and project developers; open the public hearing; receive public testimony; and take
appropriate action.
LIST OF ATTACHMENTS: Staff Report
Resolution(s)
X Other
EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION:
SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST:
A7 Public Hearing Notification
_ Bid Specification (on file in City Clerk's Office)
1. Has the resolution, ordinance or agreement been reviewed N/A _ Yes _ No
by the City Attorney?
2. Does the report require a majority or 4/5 vote? MAJORITY
3. Has environmental impact been assessed? X Yes No
4. Has the report been reviewed by a Commission? —Yes X No
Which Commission?
5. Are other departments affected by the report? X Yes _No
Report discussed with the following affected departments: PUBLIC WORKS
RFOIEWED BY:
4&/,V1
Terrence L. Belanger Frank M. sher - es DeStefano
City Manager Assistant City Manager Community Devel pment Director
CITY COUNCIL REPORT
AGENDA NO. 1-2-1—
Report Revised MaY 5, 1994
MEETING DATE:
May 9, 1994
Mayor and Members of the City Council
Honorable May Commission
TO: Honorable Chairman and Members of the Planning
Terrence L. Belanger, City Manager
FROM:
Vesting Tentative
ment Agreement Nos. 92-1 and 2; 92-8 and
SUBJECT: Tract Map No. 514,071
Conditional Use Permit No.
07, Vesting Tentative Tract No.
Oak Tree Permit No. 92-8' 91-5, and Oak Tree
32400, Conditional Use Per ac No. 51253 and
permit No. 91-2; Tentative Tract Oak Map
Permit No. 92-
Conditional Use Permit No. 92-12;
he South Pointe Master Plan; and Environmental Impact
9; t
Report No. 92-1•
request approval of a mixed
The applications submitted
ISSUE STATEMENT: known as the South Pointe Master ien i 1,
use project, uses which include
Of land The
consisting open space and school facilities.
commercial, park, p 171 acres in size and is
project site is approximately west of Brea Canyon
located north of Pathfinder
Drivel a , of Rapid View
Dr 3o acres of
Road, east of Morning and south to develop
Drive. The project proposes 000 square feet;
off ice space of 290, residential
commercial retail/office
detached and the
approximately 200
single-family
park;
dwelling units, a 28 acre neighborhood
a middle school.
construction of
It is recommended that the City Council receive a
ro ect developers; open
RECOMMENDATION: and take
P resentation from the staff and
testimony,
the Public Hearing, receive p
appropriate action.
1
PROJECT SUMMARY: The South Pointe Master Plan has been proposed to guide
the development of 171 acres in the South Pointe Middle
School/ Sandstone Canyon area. The Master Plan incorpor-
ates property owned by five entities; the City of Diamond
Bar, Walnut Valley Unified School District, Arciero'and
Sons, Inc., RNP Development, Inc. and Sasak Corporation.
The proposed project of record, if approved, will
consist of approximately 82 residential acres for
construction of 200 single family homes, 30 acres
proposed for a future commercial/ office use, 28 acres
proposed for open space as a public park site, and 31
acres proposed for the construction of the South Pointe
Middle School (see Exhibit "A"). As presently
contemplated, the project will be developed over a
projected ten year period. Under the proposed
development plan, all of the residential dwelling units,
one-half of the commercial/ office use, and the park site
will be completed within a projected five year period.
The remaining commercial/office use is projected to be
completed within the remaining ten year period.
To accommodate the proposed land uses, a number of
circulation system improvements are required. These
include the creation of new local streets within the
project site, a new access road to the school from Brea
Canyon Road, improvements to Brea Canyon Road, and area
off-site street and intersection modifications including
new signalization.
The proposed project will require the approval and
implementation of Development Agreements between the City
and the project applicants, adoption of a Master Plan,
Conditional Use Permits, Oak Tree Permits, Subdivision
approvals and an Environmental Impact Report. The
Planning Commission has reviewed the proposed project and
has recommended City Council approval.
PROJECT APPLICANTS: The applicants for the proposed project are:
(1) RNP Development, Inc. 4439 Rhodelia Dr., Claremont
CA 91711
(2) Arciero and Sons, Inc. 950 North Tustin, Anaheim,
CA 92807
(3) Sasak Corporation, 858 W. 9th Street, Upland CA
91785
(4) City of Diamond Bar, 21660 E. Copley Dr., Ste. 100,
Diamond Bar, CA 91765
2
of the master plan area include the
Unified School District. Ownership
The property owners within the boundary
applicants and the Walnut Valley attached.
boundaries are identified within Exhibit "B".
the City Council adopted the General Plan.
On July 27, 199 3 4 prohibited the hearing
BACKGROUND: Ordinance No. P tember 14, 1993,
Prior to the General Plan's adoption, On Sep went
ublic hearing process to consider develop
and consideration of the South Pointe Master P an. The Council received
the City Council began the p Project.
Staff and a summary of the
applications for the South p s 1 efrom the Plan1City The
a presentation v theproposal
from the City's environmental consul October 5,
environmental review p
tember 28, 1993,
public hearing on the project was continued to Sep As a result of the City
1993, and January 4, 1994. which
1993, November 16, 1993, to repeal Resolution 93-58,
Council action of December 14,
the project was tabled.
Subsequently, actions were
adopted the General Plan,btained which
o a new General Plan and a Stati letter was CaliforniaoOffice o
taken to develop ment
Planning and Research General Plan Extension
applied for develop
to process certain p asked the
enables the City Unified School District has recently
projects. The Walnut Valley district may begin construction of the
City for assistance
i n order
rde At issue e s the removal of aPP
that roximately 400,000
middle school fa plan
earth from the school site in order S South Pointe Master ilitate coon
cubic yards of The
of the permanent South Pointe school.
contemplates the relocation of the earth from the school site to Arciero s
proposed subdivision site. against the project.
input has been received for and ag submittal of an
Considerable community inP ers have discussed now before the
As a result, the private develop with the project
Commission has been asked to participate in the
alternative proposal for consideration alongas
The Planning the may deliberate and comment,
City Council. such that Y ro ect not previously
public presentationthe
appropriate, upon any proposed modification to ublic hearings. Time is of
its earlier p ards
considered by the Commission during specifically as reg
---
the to the WVUSD school project,
the essence in regards $8 million) and construction contract considerations.
tnls
State Capitol fundsC SD is ar , herefaccomproviding
If any contemporaneous assistance to the
forward, therefore,
to move the decision making p developers.
necessary nests from the school district and 00cubic yards of
a response to the req SD cannot remove the 400, which is
it should be noted that the WVU overnmental body,
dirt without the permission of the authoritative g
the City Council of Diamond Bar.
3
PROJECT REVIEW:
D6VqloRe_r_F_r2R0sa1
The South Pointe Master Plan weaves
interests into a comprehensive land use
neighborhood compatible with the built
five public and private ownership
plan designed to provide a mixed use
environmental.
full III[ CITY M OIINWN 110
UTII POINTE
IEII IILANNEU CUMMUNIIY
Ii".1 ❑IIf/ M4.10 5c-01901[
ouX— mn
0 . IXXII p`Xf xl III[
1�1C II n0 t SIIxS ixC,
i�01F CWX'.�UIIO.
the subdivision of a primarily undeveloped
ro ect proposes uent use of the
The Master Plan p jphased development and subseq ur oses.
171 acre site to accommodate the P ark, open space, and school p P
site for residential,
commercial, p
in Exhibit "C", the project site has been divided into five (5)
As depicted Project specific development standards have been
planning areas or enclaves. P has been designed
proposed for each enclave. Each tent standardst map
tiv
consistent with the proposed develop
Vestin Tentative Tract No. 32400
by Arciero and Sons and consists
Tentative Tract No 32400 is proposed 91 single family homes are proposed
Vesting set aside
of 93 lots on 47.44 acres. Ninety -on 6 acres (2.58 and 3.34 acres)
with two lots totaling approximately I'D") The project indicates a
(See Exhibitper acres. Preliminary Title
for commercial purposes- roximately 2.2 units
residential density of app
dicate no unusual characteristics. The site is zoned R-1-15,00
Reports in 4
The proposed map is located within Enclave 3. The minimum lot size proposed
for Enclave 3 is 7200 square feet with a minimum pad size of 6000 square
feet. The proposed project contains lot sizes that range from 7200 (lot 131)
to 15,095 (lot #14) square feet. Pad sizes ranges from 6,070 (lot #69) to
13,365 (lot #45) square feet. Primary access is from Brea Canyon Road with
a secondary access point through the future commercial development.
Earthwork quantities indicate 1.795 million cubic yards of cut and 1.810
million cubic yards of fill. The proposed map is consistent with the design
and development standards contained within the Master Plan.
Vesting Tentative Tract Mab No. 51407
Vesting Tentative Tract Map No. 51407 is proposed by RNP Development, Inc.
and consists of 84.20 acres containing 90 single family residential parcels
with 28.13 acres proposed for recreational open space and 21.9 acres proposed
as a commercial center. This map is located within Enclave 1, as described
within the Master Plan development standards. Minimum lot sizes for this
Enclave are 8,000 square feet with minimum pad sizes of 6,900 square feet.
The proposed residential neighborhoods within this Enclave are designed to be
compatible with the existing style and type of development pattern adjacent
to the project. The property is zoned RPD -10,000-6U. VTM 51407 provides for
an overall density of 2.59 units per acre on the 34.62 acre residential site.
Lot sizes range from 8,977 sq. ft. (lot 124) to 18,679 sq. ft. (lot 134).
Pad sizes range from 7,079 sq. ft. (lot #26) to 13,322 sq. ft. (lot #30) .
28.13 acres have been set aside for open space/recreational purposes (lot
#91). Three commercial lots are proposed ranging in size from 3.40 acres to
13.05 acres for a total of 21.45 commercial acres. Earthwork quantities
indicate 2,567,000 yards of cut and 2,571,000 yards of fill for the proposed
map. The circulation pattern consists of a residential collector, street
"A", from Brea Canyon Road to the middle school site, and a residential
street "B" proposed extending through to Morning Sun Drive. The project
proposes six residential dwelling units facing Larkstone Drive on property
presently owned by the Walnut Valley Unified School District.
The proposed map would supersede previously filed Tract Map No.'s 32576 and
35742. Those maps dedicated the right to prohibit the construction of
residential units within certain lots. That right was accepted by the County
and is valid and enforceable against any development request. In 1979 an
offer to dedicate the property as a "future park" was rejected by the County.
The developer is currently limited to a total of two dwelling units. Other
restrictions on the property relate to flood hazard and restricted use areas.
This proposed map, if approved, would supersede and erase the existing
development restrictions placed upon the property. (See Exhibit "E")
There are other parcels in the community which are also subject to similar
development restrictions. Properties with such development restrictions have
been re -subdivided by Los Angeles County. The applicant has specifically
requested approval of this application 'package which permits the City to
evaluate the change in entitlement on the merits of the proposed project.
5
isio
or
provides a means to remove such restrictions. If a resubd r val n the
reversion to acreage of the tract is subsequently filed for app royal and
offer of dedication previously rejected is terminated upon the approval
recordation of the new map. (See Exhibit "F")
Master Plan
The use of a "Master Plan" is proposed to guide the overall development. The
The
components of the plan include permitted uses and development standards.
proposed zoning regulations and development standards will be imp oe ent d via
The
the use of development agreements for the RNP and Arciero prop
Tentative
standards are attached to the Sasak Pois las a contained wi hin the component of epreviously
Map conditions. The complete documentplan is a tool for implementing the
prepared report. The use of a master p policy and zoning
General Plan and often bridges the gap between General Plan p Y
standards for the property under consideration for development.
Development Agreements
The use of Development Agreements are proposed for the prciero and RNP
development project. The Development Agreement
the Hillside Management regulations,
document to incorporate the Master Plan,
the Oak Tree Permit, the Development Standards with reference to the
Tentative Tract Maps. Cities are provided with the ability to enter into
Development Agreements with any property owner. Development Agreements are
essentially a negotiated contract between a public agency and a private
developer. The Development Agreement establishes the termthe sapp d cants tions
from which the development can proceed and provides
assurances baih
sed upon their commitment to timing and compliance with the
agreements incorporate land transfers, contract
agreements. The proposed
d the successful completion o
zoning, and commitments by all parties toward the
the proposed project. Attached to this report are maps which illustra�eo project
existing and future ownership of property
as a result of p j
implementation.
The Hillside Management Ordinance requires a conditional use permit approval
for each tentative tract map proposal. The hillside management standards
guidelines have been incorporated within each development. The impact of the
project grading is analyzed in the Draft
ctionsvirTheeDevelopment CodeReport
requires
the earth resources and aesthetics se i
an Oak Tree permit for the removal of any oak genus which is eight inchesnrade. Each
alf feet abve the natural g
subdivision
diameter measured four
contains soak trees which would require removal.
proposed subdivision
7
In accordance with requirements of the Code, an oak tree inventory as
conducted for each subdivision site. Vesting Tentative Tract Map 51407
contains 449 oak trees. Tentative Tract Map 51253 contains 53 trees
scheduled for replacement. Vesting Tentative Tract Map 32400 will require
the removal of 276 oak trees. The Draft Environmental Impact Report indicates
that 92 percent or 768 of the 835 inventoried oak trees will be removed as a
result of the proposed grading activities on-site. All oak trees removed as
a result of the proposed project are proposed for replacement at a 2:1 ratio.
The Developers' proposal provides potential benefits to the community in the
form of facilitating the construction of the permanent middle school,
development of a publicly held park and open space, creation of a freeway
oriented commercial site and numerous area -wide traffic improvements.
Action Required:
1. Certification of the Environmental Impact report along with
Findings of Fact and a Statement of Overriding Considerations.
2. Abandonment of the dedicated right to restrict construction of
residential buildings upon RNP and Sasak properties pursuant to
Government Code (S51903).
3. Approval of each tentative tract map, Development Agreements,
Conditional Use Permits, Oak Tree Permits, and the Master Plan.
(The Council must make written findings pursuant to Government Code
§65360, and §65361, and the conditions of the extension letter,
that there is little or no probability that the project will be
detrimental to or interfere with the future adopted General Plan if
the project is ultimately inconsistent with that plan).
4. Recordation of EIR Certification
5. Completion of approved conditions, as required, for issuance of
grading permits (including the applicant obtaining an Army Corp of
Engineers, Section 404, permit and a California Department of Fish
and Game, Section 1601-1607, permit for alteration of the stream).
6. Recordation of final documents, maps, etc.
8
OA saa�---
Alternative I - North South Can ro osed for consideration
ro ect has been P P Canyon area
the proposed p j of the Sandstone Tract Map
An alternative to a the preservation Arciero and Sons ( the
designed to encourag t involves Ar for
and is desig The nonce adjacent to the middle schooNo. 51407)
for open space purposes. ro erty► Tract Map-
32400) trading their p p Development► Inc' ( p site and include
No. of the RNP the former RN The proposal
westerly 35± acres 103 homes on school.
property. Arciero would
develop
Road to the middle the school site-
pro
new road access
export from
would incorporate the excess earth scheduled for
(See Exhibit nor their remaining acreage•
Canyon site to the City'
upon Arciero's former site, restrictions
RNP would not build P + acre Sandstone Canymap future
RNP offer of dedication of the removal of existing Avenue. Any
conditioned upon adjacent to Grand subject to all City
would be owned by RNP, located plans
roperty, Grand Avenue site would
Subdivision
fent proposal develop benefits of this
p f or the
develop environmental review and date. Potential of the school
regulations for at a later the public,
fornot limited to, the facilitati to
would be submitted but are review of Sandstone Canyon
proposal include, acts.
construction, preservation amen ironmentai imp
and substantial reduction of
Action Re uired Commission pursuant to
Referral of revised project
to Planning
I. re ort and recommeCd Repo t, preparation n an
Section
65857 for a p Findings of Fact and a
2, Certif icatio Supplemental EIR EnvironmentalImpact
with
addendum or Considerations• agreements
outlining
Statement of Overriding easement or
Preparation of revised project conditions conservation 32400,
3. Prep 1 (i.e. application Arciero, Tract
Alternative former
building rights restriction upon the RNp Grand
)
site• uncil consideration(pursuant to Government
4, planning Commission and City Corestrictions
Avenue site for removal of map Tract Map 51407 and its
Code §51093)• Vesting Tentative Development Agreement.
5. Approval of revised Tree Permit and ermits.
associated CUP, Oak Sasak) and related p
Grand Avenue Site (The Council
Approval of Tentative Tract 51253 ( 65360, and
24031 for RNP ent Code S65360,
is
Approval of Parcel Map ursuant to Governor that
must make written findings p the extension letter, to or
§65361, and the conditions of project will be detrimental rect is
probability that the General Plan
little or no p the future adopted
interfere with that plan)* permits,
recordation
ultimately inconsistent withired for grading P
Completion of conditions req
6• westerly
of maps, etc. the most
stream exists upon site earth may be
intermittent blue -line of school
Although an Tract 51407, a significant amount
rocess h of the 404 and 1601-
portion of concurrent with the p
relocated to Tract 51407 9
1607 permits.
•• -
Altern tive 2 p eServa east -west open
t to consider is the maintenance of an Tract 32400
Another design concep the development of Arciero's 75 homes
space amenity by only permitting
in 1991, Arciero proposed a subdivision
1991 tentative
site. As an example, a previous tentative map. on
75 single family lots are proposed
upon their acreage utilizing P feet and average 11,660
map consists of 85 lots on
47.6 izer from 7200 square151 cubic
19.5 net acres and rang uantities indicate the need for 393,
square feet. The earthwork q 21,2 acres are set aside
yards of import (presumable from the school site). 6.9, devoted to streets. P
the acreage�� An U.S. Army
as open space with the balance y a "blue line stream. permit would
Arciero's property is encumbered by artment of Fish and Game p This
Engineers permit and California Dep the existing streambed.
of Eng' modification to and
be required prior to any owned by
ve provides the opportunity to facilitate thschdevelopment
alternate P hts restricted east -west properties acrest. (Exhibit "H")
preserve the buildiGng acres) and RNP Development
Sasak Corporation
Action Required Section 65857 for
1. Referral to Planning Commission pursuant to
report and recommendation. act Report along with
Considerations and
2. Certification of the Environmental In►P
Findings of Fact and a Statement of Overriing dro riate
Addendum. Sasak) with appP
3, Rejection of VTM 51407 (RNP) and TM 51253
conditions, and agreements to
findings and conclusions.
4. Preparation of revised map, went
facilitate the revised Arciero subdivision. OT and Develop
Council must make written findings pursuant to
5• Approval of new VT M 32400 with associated CUP, conditions
of the
Agreement (The and the c
Government Code §65360, and §65361, robability that the
extension letter, that there is little or no p
e depted
trimental to or interfere with rwith othat
project will b ro ect is ultimately
General Plan if the p 7 for issuance of
plan). roved conditions, as required, Corps of
Completion of app the applicant obtaining an Army
6• including Department of Fish
grading permits (including
and a California
Engineers, Section 404, p
Section 1601-1607, permit for alteration of the stream
and Game ,
10
u� Prosect
Alternative " — require
the off-site
selected, would req
A "no project" if alternative, resently found on the South Pointfiddle
exportation of the surplus soil p construction of permanent
immediately,
the existing excess soil will be used within
School site in order to facilitate, alternative off-site
school buildings.
Asproposed, ositing the soil at an
the project boundaries. Dep supplement to the act Report for the
location could require an addendum or
y certified Final Environmental Impact outside of the
District's previousl
The transportation of the soil, s upon local
South Pointe Middle School• require an estimated 26,000± truck trip
project boundaries, would req
streets. The
additional time and cost of this alternative would be borne Y
the School District.
Alternative 4
Certify the EIR, Deny projects, or specific components.
Alternative 5
Continue discussion of the South Pointe Master Pl fives r further environmental
analysis or investigation of additional alterna
ENpIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT: the City has
Act,
ort should be prepared to assess
In accordance with the Cal li ImEnvironmental
act g Dental Quality . ect. The City
determined that an Environmental ro osed pro? enCity
Inc. as an independent
and analyze the environmeneersefa d ts of the Constructors, An Executive Summary of
engaged ultrasystems Eng'
consultant to prepare the environmental documents.
the environmental review record is attached.
PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE:
Master Plan project was publicly noticed in accordance with
The South Pointe Ma Advertisements were published within the San
requirements. Daily Bulletin on April 11 and
State and local req
Gabriel Valley Tribune and the Inland toValley property owners within a 500 1994•
1994. Notices were mailed to p p8 1994 and April 21,
April 22, interested citizens
radius of the project boundaries on April ,
Several hundred additional notices were of the proposal. mailed to
providing public awarenes
11
PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION:
The Planning Commission conducted
hearings on the proposals. numerous public stud
December 13 A walking tour of Y sessions and public
Noticed Public Study Sessions were held in October and December 19
ublic hearings were held in Januaryite was conducted on
1993. The Planning, February, 92•
project components OCommission recommended cit y' March, April and May,
May 24, 1993. y Council approval of all
PREPARED BY:
James De Stefano
Community Development Director
Attachments:(Pr(Exhibit "ANN) transmitted within May
MAPS 1. South Pointe Master Plan 2� NNreport
i
2 • Project Boundaries (Exhibit NIB$')
4. Planning Enclaves (Exhibit
VTM 32400 (Exhibit I'D")
5. VTM 51407 (Exhibit TIED)
6. TM 51253 (Exhibit
7• Revised VTM 51407 (Exhibit
8 • Previous "Gil)
(1991) V'I'M 32400 (Exhibit ��H��)
9• Environmental Review Record
10. City Council Staff Reports and
11. Planning
12. Commission Staff Reports
Minutes
Notices of Public Hearing p and Meetin
13. OPR Extension Letter dated 1/31/94 g Minutes
14. Letter from J. C. Dabne
15. Walnut Valley School District aLetter 9dated 4/494
16. Timeline of Construction for South /
1994-1995 Pointe Middle School
17. Sierra Club Letter received 4/21/94
18. Letter from Frederick & Frances Strunck dated 4
19• 6 page Petition si
20• gned by 102 persons re. /17/94
List of correspondence received from Januar 19. 1 99 Canyon
January 19, 199
June 8, 1993 - both for and against 3 through
21. Draft Environmental Impact
22. Response to Co p Report { Previously mments on the Draft Environmental transmitted
dated February 1993 { previouslypact Report
23. Response to Co transmitted
Comments on the Draft Environmental Impact
Volume II dated November 1993 { previously transmitted
24. Technical a Report-
Volume
Im ac Response to Comments
Impact Report dated May on the Draft
transmitted y 1993 { previously
12
AGENDA ITEM NO. 9.1
PLEASE BRING DOCUMENTATION
PROVIDED FOR THE MAY 2, 1994 MEETING